Location: Bethpage
Top Restaurants in Bethpage
Countries
New York, United States Food Guide: 10 Pizza food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Bethpage
Best Pizza restaurants nearby. Discover the best Pizza food in Bethpage. View Menus, Photos and Reviews for Pizza restaurants near you.. Bethpage is a hamlet located on Long Island within the Town of Oyster Bay in Nassau County, New York, United States, as well as a census-designated place (CDP) with borders slightly different from those of the hamlet. The CDP's population was 16,429 at the 2010 United States Census.
Things to do in Bethpage
10. 3 Brothers Pizza Cafe
Overall Ratings
3 based on 24 reviews
Reviewed By jalva1012
It was nice to come in here and have Vegan options. Price online me is different from price in the restaurant. Price online has not been updated to reflect price increase. Started with the world famous Vegan mozzarella sticks. My wife enjoyed them. I wasn't impressed. Definitely not worth $11 for 6 mozzarella sticks. Also had a large eggplant parm pizza. We both agreed that it was good. Not worth $26 in my opinion. They also have an ALL Vegan cafe in a different location where they make their own cashew cheese for the pizza. The manager was telling me that I he homemade cheese is much better than me he processed daiya cheese I had just purchased. That kinda took the wind out of my sails. Oh well ... I may be back.
9. Mario's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 37 reviews
Reviewed By JustaHoosier
Mario's offers a lovely little restaurant with very friendly and attentive staff. The owner/manager was present and obviously takes great pride in his restaurant. Come hungry--the portions are huge! We found the food authentically Italian and delicious! The prices were very reasonable for Long Island. We went on a Saturday and the place was full, but the wait short. We highly recommend!
8. Villa Maria
Reviewed By Mark L
We are new to Ling Island and have not found many pizzeria places that were outstanding. This place did a very easy job with handling the order. The pick up was also very easy. In and out quickly without any wait in line.The pizza had a very good flavor. The pizza was extremely thin and the crust edges were of a very good texture. Will definitely return.Thanks for the feedback, Mark. Great to hear you loved the food. Hope to see you again soon!
7. Phil's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 125 reviews
Reviewed By sukieusa
This is a gem of a little restaurant in a strip mall. It is also a pizza place. The decor is nothing fancy, but the food is fantastic. All are very large portions, enough to take home and have another meal the next day. The wine is a reasonable price too.First trip I had the eggplant parm, excellent and so much food. The second visit I had the grilled salmon. 3 really nice size grilled pieces, cooked just right and so tasty, served with a salad or pasta on a bed of broccoli rabe, also cooked just right.The only critical thing I can say is that there is way too much oil in everything and that is the only reason I didn't give it 5 stars, but of course that makes it taste good.The serve on both visits was good, attentive but not annoying. Will be back!
6. Ciminelli's Cafe
Overall Ratings
4 based on 21 reviews
Reviewed By Matt C
Food at this place was pretty good, nothing out of the ordinary for an Italian place. The service was a bit slow but other than that it was enjoyable.
Where to eat Italian food in Bethpage: The Best Restaurants and Bars
5. Pappardelle's Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 31 reviews
Serving robust flavors and hearty portions, we offer consistently delicious brick-oven style pizza with the best homemade dough and sauce in town! Serving specialty and gourmet pizzas, we also have a large selection of pastas, seafood, calzones, and more!
Reviewed By barry m
Food was very good but not extraordinary. Restaurant setting is kind of typical for a pizza restaurant with a dining area. During winter it is quite drafty with customersmoving around between tables to try to find a warm spot. Waiter just shrugged his shoulders when asked about it,I ordered the 16 ounce rib eye. Generous size, but kind of fatty/oily and not well trimmed.I trimmed it myself and was ok. One thing about it was that it was expertly grilled, and it was evenly cooked medium rare in both the thickest part and the thinnest part.My wife ordered shrimp Parmesan, and she was quite satisfied with it. She said thatthis was a great choice to order in a restaurant, compared to making at home.Both dishes came with salad with many choices of dressing,Service was a little slow, but generally helpful. Note I rated this restaurant as a good value,I used a restaurant promotion to obtain the good value rating.
Most Popular Chinese food in Bethpage, New York, United States
4. Gino's Pizzeria
Reviewed By cksplash1
I order from Ginos almost weekly (they deliver). We've sat in the dinning area for lunch a few times and have gotten terrific service and really good food. Out of the many pizzerias in my area, we always choose Ginos. Great fried calamari, penne ala vodka, pizza (try their Mac and cheese slice), heroes and pizza!
Top 3 Mediterranean food in Bethpage, New York, United States
3. Villa Monte
Overall Ratings
4 based on 58 reviews
Reviewed By NewYorkHildreth
Although I only went for pizza, the restaurant has much more to offer. It is a small, traditional pizzaria in a strip mall, but their innovations in pizza inclue BBQ and Jack Daniels slices, along with a great variet of other takes on "grandma" and chicken wings. My acid test is always the crust, which I gound to be good but not great and too easily burnt in the oven reheat.
2. Domenico's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 140 reviews
Reviewed By bobr264
First time visit and I will definitely return. Everyone was super to deal with. The meal was delicious with a capital D with plenty of leftovers. Felt welcome and appreciated. On the way out---and we left at closing time---at least five different employees stopped to thank us for coming. Don't have that happen too often.
1. La Piazza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 213 reviews
The name you trust, the food you love. We are committed to bringing you the best Pizza in the area, and one of the best dining experiences you can have on Long Island. With locations in Plainview, Merrick and Melville. Call or come in today. No reservatio
Reviewed By seasidegirl603
They deliver and ordered a pizza pie, pasta primavera and the Mediterranean salad. Be sure to ask them not to burn the bottom of your pizza if you donât like it black on the bottom. The pasta primavera was delicious and plentiful. The salad was lacking ingredients and fell short.
Where to eat Asian food in Bethpage: The Best Restaurants and Bars
