Location: Southampton
Top Restaurants in Southampton
Countries
New York, United States Food Guide: 10 Italian food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Southampton
Reviews on Italian food in Southampton, New York, United States. Southampton, New York, on the east end of Long Island, shines in the summer. Sandy beaches and celebrities make this the place to be. The rest of the year, enjoy the museums, luxury shopping and fine dining. Visit farms and wineries nearby.
Things to do in Southampton
10. Paul's Italian American Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 58 reviews
Paul's Italian American Restaurant Provides Italian Food Services to the Greater Southhampton, NY Area.
Reviewed By dave809
Paul's is a terrific Italian family restaurant that serves well-prepared dinners at prices that will not make you flinch like most Southampton restaurants will. Our family (locals) dines there regularly and we're very happy with the consistent food, service, and overall value provided. Convenient location just a few feet away from Agawam Park and Jobs Lane. Their table are small but separated so that you still have some privacy. Enjoy.
9. Cafe Crust
Overall Ratings
4 based on 40 reviews
Reviewed By dgyuen
We had another delicious dinner at Cafe Crust. Unpretentious in The Hamptons, but fresh, delicious fare! Started out with their Spinach Salad- might have seemed pricey at first, but it was delicious and big enough for two. Had the brick oven-baked Marguerite pie- fresh organic tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, and fresh basil (made the other half with sweet Italian sausage and red roasted peppers! Outdoor dining tonight was perfect- always friendly and accommodating wait staff is a plus.
8. Uncle Joe's Pizza & Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 46 reviews
Reviewed By CTS_Knows
This is a pretty nice little family restaurant. We eat here about twice a year when visiting family. The eat here a lot. Last year we had a young Latin looking girl who had no idea of ingredients in the dishes. She was very nice but no help to us while ordering. This time we had an older women. I'm not sure what her problem is but not friendly at all. She seemed very flip about her job. My son thinks she must have had a real hard life judging by her attitude. Don't bring it into work. The rest of staff is great as well as the food.
7. Francescas
Overall Ratings
4 based on 59 reviews
Reviewed By AllenFein
My new favorite Italian restaurant! Good happy crowd this dark rainy December evening. Wonderful menu. Great helpful staff - our attentive server was Michael. Modest bottle beer selection. Generous wine pours. Excellent large calamari fed 4 with leftovers. Garlic knots perfect. Our party of 4 shared two delicious dishes and all had ample left overs to take home. Then if room, home made huge selection of ice cream/gelatos. Prices very fair. Will return soon for pizza as they prepare huge number of appetizing offerings!
6. Villa Paul
Overall Ratings
4 based on 67 reviews
A family owned business for 52 years! Serving a continental menu with classic Italian favorites, Long Island Duck, fresh local seafood and tender steaks (marinated available). We have a cozy dining room with a fireplace, a sunny indoor porch and a private
Reviewed By stringali
Well folks.......I have been out in Hampton Bays for 7 years and said many times that "I have to try Villa Paul" I cant believe it took me 7 years to get here. Villa Paul is a wonderful restaurant which offers an amazing dining experience. Denise our waitress was just amazing with her table service and control of the delivery of our dinner. We went all out with the apps.....escargot, fried calamari, mussels in white wine and garlic, meatball trio and baked clams....yes folks, we went all out!!!Ford diner we ordered the shrimp scampi, Tuscan chicken and the amazing roast duck in a cherry sauce.. oh boy was that delicious... check out the pics!We had a great time here tonight, service was amazing and the night was memorable...after 2 bottles of Chardonnay...whew, and dessert! Is that right....2 s's?I look forward to my return!WOW, thank you for your wonderful review! We are so happy that you enjoyed your experience with us, and Happy Anniversary to your in-laws! Sorry it took you so long to discover us (we hear that quite often) but hopefully your review will encourage others to give us a try. We've been here now for 54 years! PS: Great Pictures!
5. Tutto Il Giorno
Overall Ratings
4 based on 141 reviews
Reviewed By FrequentTripster
Excellent lunch but a dinner prices. Space is cozy modern and service is good but not overly polished. Would benefit from a few lunch items for the weekend.
4. Sant Ambroeus
Overall Ratings
4 based on 162 reviews
Reviewed By Frank000
The coffee area really looks as an Italian âbarâ..you can have your cofffee or cappuccino at the counter or you can sit.The coffee is excellent as well as the cakes and pastries.The atmosphere is really like being in Italy.It offers also fine food but we had other angagements so we could not try the restaurant.. it has an open-air alley with white parasols and plants which looked really inviting.
3. Scotto's Pork Store
Overall Ratings
4 based on 78 reviews
Reviewed By C9168CGlindam
Scotto's has always had wonderful takeaway Italian food. Their addition of the wine bar, where you can sip on a glass of great wine while enjoying a personal pizza or slice, PLUS have the great service and conversation with their wine bar staff (we love Sarah and Brittany!) - it's the perfect way to wrap up your day. Then take some fabulous food out to heat up or serve for tomorrow night's dinner and you're set. Their weekly dinner specials to take-away are reasonably priced and delicous as well! Check them out!
Best American food near Southampton, New York, United States
2. La Parmigiana Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 219 reviews
Reviewed By suzyd43
Great restaurant with delicious food. So hard to choose what to order. We did take out, and I learned that they will deliver, when you use the Door Dash app. We ordered a grilled chicken parmigiana, which was lighter without breading, ravioli, veal with mushrooms and spinach, and a wonderful salad with chicken, mozzarella, and red peppers. Almost forgotto get dessert but added cheesecake to our order. It was rich and creamy. Another winning meal from this favorite.
Where to eat Seafood food in Southampton: The Best Restaurants and Bars
1. Edge Water Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 228 reviews
At the Edgewater Restaurant, we're all about the experience. We work really hard to create and maintain a calming, tranquil escape, where you can get away from the annoyances of everyday life and just relax with your company. Here you can choose to lose y
Reviewed By maries939
We had a spectacular day and evening to enjoy with our friends. We ate at Edgewater and were happy with the service. The scallops were good, stuffed flounder was ok, the salads were fresh. I wish I could say something great about this place, but I canât. Food used to be better I think. Maybe it was just an off day. The view is worth another try.Consistently crafting a perfect meal is truly our passion, Marie, and I'm sorry to see that this wasn't the overall impression you left with after stopping by. From the ingredients to the finished product -- it's all about showcasing the very best of the best. We'll be sure to pass along your input, and here's hoping that we can welcome you back for the five-star experience that we know this staff can easily show you. -John
Most Popular Bar food in Southampton, New York, United States
