Location: Oyster Bay
Top Restaurants in Oyster Bay
Top Things to do in Oyster Bay
- 1. Old Westbury Gardens
- 2. Sagamore Hill National Historic Site
- 3. John P. Humes Japanese Stroll Garden
- 4. Cold Spring Harbor Fish Hatchery & Aquarium
- 5. Shu Swamp Preserve - Charles T Church Nature Preserve
- 6. NYCB Theatre at Westbury
- 7. Bayville Adventure Park
- 8. Caumsett State Park
- 9. Planting Fields Arboretum State Historic Park
- 10. The Paramount
Countries
New York, United States Food Guide: 10 Italian food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Oyster Bay
Reviews on Italian food in Oyster Bay, New York, United States. The Town of Oyster Bay is the easternmost of the three towns which make up Nassau County, New York, in the United States. Part of the New York metropolitan area, it is the only town in Nassau County to extend from the North Shore to the South Shore of Long Island. As of the 2010 census, it had a population of 293,214.
Things to do in Oyster Bay
10. La Pizzetta Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 50 reviews
Reviewed By drjeff77
Five of us went for early dinner and we had a really nice experience! Service was very good as was the food. Salads were fresh and good...Their mini- pizzas were tasty as were the pasta and chicken dishes! Good hearty food- nothing extraordinary! Easy to find a parking spot- just north of 25A on the western side of the road...
9. Restaurant Joanina
Overall Ratings
4 based on 306 reviews
To all of our valued customers and friends, we thank you for choosing us over and over again and hope that we can continue to serve you for many years to come.
Reviewed By Sandwichguy_12
Excellent wait staff, cheese appetizer, hearty Italian pasta dinner, full bodied wine recommended by the waiter and finished with caramel gelato. This was our first time and we would go back again if ever in the area. Huntington village has a nice feel
8. Angelina's Italian Cuisine
Overall Ratings
4 based on 57 reviews
Reviewed By rgschenck
My husband, daughter, and I were in the area to attend a funeral for a close family member. We arrived in town, after a 7 hour drive, exhausted and hungry. We asked our hotel manager where we could eat some good Italian food, and he sent us to Angelina's.We sat and ate and drank for over 2 hours. We did share with some of the staff that we were in town for a funeral, and they took care of us like family. The food was delicious and the staff were sweet, accommodating, and professional. We ate course after course of expertly prepared and beautifully served food - seafood, pasta, meat, you name it - with great adult beverages. Not a single thing to criticize. I drank very nice Montepulciano Red, while my husband enjoyed a great Negroni. We even pack in mouth watering, home-made ricotta cheesecake. The next evening, after the funeral, we returned for another (lighter) meal, and found the same wonderful deliciousness and subtly attentive service. Seriously, they anticipated our every need with smiles at every turn.Hope to return for a happier occasion. In the meanwhile, we say THANK YOU, and highly recommend Angelina's.
7. Cafe Al Dente
Reviewed By Bob J
Was glad to hear the Café al Dente reopened up in Oyster Bay. The former establishment on Spring Street was very good. Unfortunately, this new one is not up to the former. Service was adequate at best and the food so-so. The polenta appetizer was over-fried and very dry. Salads were better, but the main courses disappointed. The Pork Marsala for example had no hit of marsala wine and was made using canned mushrooms. Yuck. Chicken Picata was bland. Won't be back.
6. Osteria Leana
Overall Ratings
3 based on 28 reviews
Reviewed By abitofinfo
My daughter and I met for our monthly mom/dtr dinner date...out on the town. Our palates demand the best. Osteria Leana is wonderful! Their meet and greet hostess (so pleasant), attentive wait staff, variety menu and specials of the evening..along with the comfortable ambiance, decor, seating, open kitchen (spotless)!!! Reasonable prices - plenty of free parking. Our compliments to the owner, the chef, and the entire staff..for getting it RIGHT!!
Where to eat Seafood food in Oyster Bay: The Best Restaurants and Bars
5. Ralph's Famous Italian Ices
Reviewed By GloriaH119
We recently went to their new location in Mamaroneck NY.(I wasn't able to add this location when I did this review). This was our first visit to Ralph's. They offer two kinds of ices(water or cream). In addition to ices they have ice cream and soft serve. I had the cappuccino ices(cream) and chocolate (water). They were both very flavorful. My husband had the chocolate ices. They have many flavors to choose from. In addition they let you sample flavors to help you pick a flavor.
Where to eat Steakhouse food in Oyster Bay: The Best Restaurants and Bars
4. Nino's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 20 reviews
Reviewed By John P
Hands down best regular pizza. Very spoiled and picky pizza lover. - 2 well down slices and garlic knots with oil
3. Pietro's Brick Oven Pizza
Reviewed By Cynthia V
This place is under new management. Ever since that happened the food there is amazing! Everything there is good from the entrees to the pizza and the calzones and stuffed rolls. Their service is also great. After a few times of going there they remember you. My husband and I have gotten take out food from there and also have sat down and ate there. All the times we've gone there the food has been wonderful! I would definitely recommend going here to anyone in the Oyster Bay area!
2. Mario's Pizzeria of Oyster Bay
Overall Ratings
4 based on 35 reviews
Reviewed By walterw457
The restaurant was easy to find, adequate parking and the interior was clean. There were numerous pizza varieties to choose from. The two slices I tried were great. Each slice had an abundance of toppings, they were flavorful and the crust was light and crispy. All in all it was one of the better New York pizzerias I've been to. I'll definitely return if I find myself in this area again.
1. Autentico
Overall Ratings
4 based on 31 reviews
Reviewed By thgreatalex
My husband and I consistently return to this restaurant as we have never had a bad meal here. In fact, every dish Iâve tried thus far has been excellent. The ambiance is cozy and understated. Make reservations -this place is impossible to grab a table past 8pm. We bring friends all the time here and everyone has equally been satisfied. It also doesnât hurt that we saw Billy Joel here with his wife:)
Most Popular Diner food in Oyster Bay, New York, United States
