Location: Penfield
Top Restaurants in Penfield
Countries
New York, United States Food Guide: 10 Bar food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Penfield
Find out what Bar restaurants to try in Penfield. Tony LaFountain (R; 2010-present)
Things to do in Penfield
10. Don's Original
Overall Ratings
3 based on 35 reviews
Reviewed By Lauren S
The food is commonplace and mediocre; never inedible, yet never outstanding. The attached pub has much more atmosphere than the hotdog stand-like restaurant, but even the pub lacks character. On the other hand, the staff is super friendly at every hour of the day; never trying to hustle you along at closing. The beer is cold and the clientele is happy with many regulars.
9. Bistro 1778 Kitchen & Cocktails
Overall Ratings
4 based on 35 reviews
Reviewed By rjfmkt
Our first visit got mixed reviews. This visit was MUCH better. Their menu has some inventive items all reasonably priced. Portion sizes were large. Food was hot and flavorful. Our server (Julie) was engaging and helpful. Will definitely be back.
8. Shadow Lake Golf & Racquet Club
Overall Ratings
4 based on 52 reviews
Shadow Lake has been Rochesterâs choice for a premier public course for over 30 years! The clubhouse facility overlooks sparkling Shadow âLakeâ, a former crushed stone quarry (1920âs) before the site filled with spring water. In recent years, the lake was
Reviewed By cantesynge
I came out to Shadow Lake to play nine holes with family. This facility has an executive course - the perfect length for a short golf day. The course was accessible but still challenging. We were there on a Sunday, and so we could not get a drink at the bar (weddings abound at this location), but the interior looked inviting. I would definitely come back to this course.
7. Fairfields Bar & Grill
Overall Ratings
4 based on 50 reviews
Reviewed By ken s
We were looking for a relaxed atmosphere with decent food. Maybe our expectations were too high on the latter. We were seated quickly on a Saturday night in a comfortable, clean booth (though you could smell the odor of a common disinfectant universally used in restrooms and floors). It was quiet and not crowded. Our server was friendly and attentive throughout the night. Prime rib is a special every Saturday, and 2 of us ordered that. The dinner rolls that came out quickly and warm (warmer than the entree) were delicious and the best part of the dinner. The prime rib was barely warm, had a faint but distinct odor of meat that was old/starting to turn, was a strange color, and was pretty tough and stringy. My dining partner and I ate a few bites (and did not get sick from it), but really could not eat it. The frozen vegetables that accompanied it were ok (again not very warm), but when I asked for a second helping (because I couldn't eat the meat), the second batch was partially frozen. The soup I got (lentil and sausage) was edible, and in the end I ate it because I was hungry. It had a two very small bits of sausage, and another tiny bit of meat that clearly wasn't sausage. My 3rd dining partner had a chicken salad that was mediocre, but edible. Since neither I nor my friend ate our prime rib, I was expected to be compensated for at least one of the meals (and all I asked for to replace it was a scant amount of frozen uncooked vegetables), but we were charged the full price for both meals. From the majority of good reviews I see here, perhaps it is safer to order the bar type food.
6. Timothy Patrick's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 68 reviews
Reviewed By attorneylittle
Had a great time at TPâs on St. Patrickâs day. The cottage pie had big chunks of tender beef and was really good. Seafood chowder came with the meal and was as well. Two people in our group had French onion soup with their cottage pie and was a big hit. So much cheese. It was perfect. All around good experience and affordable prices.
5. The Penfield Pour House
Overall Ratings
4 based on 65 reviews
The Penfield Pour House is a local pub style sports bar with a new warm look and a home town feel. Our greatest asset from customer response is our genuinely friendly staff that ensures a memorable experience is had by all. A wonderfully unique menu sets
Reviewed By Anniversarita
My first visit to the Pour House for lunch was a success. Our sandwiches were extremely good. So, a month later I took my family there for lunch. Not the same. One of our orders came much later than all the others, one of our salads came with no dressing, the pot roast platter was extremely salty. My turkery, avocado, salad had the fresest greens ever, but the turkey was not roasted.....just ordinary deli turkey. Only my husband's hamburger was satisfactory. Our waitress tried, very hard, apologizing for the late entree, bringing the missing dressing quickly, but......her willingness just wasn't enough to save the day. We won't go back, but if you do, try the sandwiches!
4. Mulconry's Irish Pub and Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 143 reviews
Reviewed By Fondue4two
It wasn't too crowded on a recent Saturday evening when we stopped in for dinner. I've heard that Friday nights for the fish fry can be absolutely jammed. We did have to wait 20 minutes or so for a table though it appeared some tables were empty. Once seated our waitress was very efficient getting us our food and drinks.The menu is pretty big with both typical tavern fare and some real Irish specialties. We both ordered the beef on weck - it was a solid sandwich. The roll was excellent. The onion rings were good for being breaded, though I prefer beer battered. And the fries were huge.Overall a good choice in Fairport.
3. Jeremiah's Tavern
Overall Ratings
3 based on 152 reviews
Reviewed By I_love_baking
We visited on a Tuesday night. As others have noted, we waited despite seeing many empty tables. We were told 20 minutes but only waited about 7. I found the menu to offer something for everyone: burgers, steak tips, taco, pulled pork, wings. A nice variety. Our server, Janae, was good and patient, and filled our waters often. She checked on us a sufficient amount. My pulled pork was tender but didn't really have enough sauce - I simply asked for more. It was served on a piece of bread that got mushy in five seconds flat. That was puzzling. The cornbread was ok, a little overcooked on both the top and bottom. The sweet potato fries were good. My husband enjoyed his taco sampler and my mom enjoyed her patty melt with mushrooms and friend onions. Overall we were satisfied. We will return. I'm sick of Italian or Chinese as my only choices, so this is a nice change.
2. Donnelly's Public House
Overall Ratings
4 based on 164 reviews
Reviewed By Christopher B
A must stop in the village of Fairport, just north of the Erie Canal. Excellent food, the service is great and a very comfortable place to sit and relax for a beer, snack, lunch, or dinner. A wife range of choices to eat and the portions are above average. We love visiting Donnelly's. Right next door is a great place for pizza: TKs. A must stop as well!
1. McArdle's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 172 reviews
Welcome to McArdleâs Restaurant. We are a family owned and operated restaurant located just outside the village of Fairport near the Erie Canal. The attention to detail, quality and superior service makes McArdleâs a localsâ favorite. As you enter McArdle
Reviewed By billjillmackybronson
We go here all the time. Have always appreciated the service, love the atmosphere and the high back booths make our silly family fun feel like weâre almost at home getting away with our nonsense without many people noticing. We all love the food and there is a great variety of it.We highly recommend it.Thank you for the kind words and recommendation. We are so glad your family feels comfortable here. We look forward to serving you (and your silly family) again soon!JohnMcArdle's
Where to eat American food in Penfield: The Best Restaurants and Bars
