Location: New Hartford
Top Restaurants in New Hartford
Countries
New York, United States Food Guide: 10 Bar food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in New Hartford
Discover Restaurants offering the best Bar food in New Hartford, New York, United States. Paul Miscione
Things to do in New Hartford
10. Boneyard BBQ Barbeque Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 31 reviews
Reviewed By LukeB2006
Some of the best Barbecue I've ever had, reading the negavtive reviews I realize that the loud bar atmosphere is a recurring "problem", but that's the fun of it. You go to a place called "Boneyard BBQ" for the food as well as the experience. Reading the negative reviews I see that people think the food isn't good, I couldn't disagree more. I've been twice already and have been very satisfied every time. The ribs are delicious, so is the Pulled pork, chicken barbecue and hog wings. All the sides I've tried were good and I really have nothing to complain about. The atmosphere is great, the people are very nice. Those who have written negative reviews went last year, so maybe the restaurant made an effort in that regard, if so goof job.
9. Ocean Blue Restaurant and Oyster Bar
Overall Ratings
4 based on 236 reviews
Reviewed By loveroftravel30
We are from NYC, so we did not expect to find $39 entrees in Utica.The upside, this is a rooftop restaurant with a recently renovated space. Menu was creative with an open kitchen. While mainly a seafood restaurant, we chose the more reasonably priced option of grilled cheese with short-ribs and the burger priced around $20. Both were good, but not return good.Desserts looked good, but we were full.
8. Packy's Pub
Overall Ratings
4 based on 32 reviews
Reviewed By anthonyp227
One of our favorite place. The food and service is consistently good. If you can save some space, treat yourself to any of the home made desserts. You wonât be disappointed. No matter what you get off the menu it will be good. I tried the lightly breaded fish. Delicious.
7. Gerber's 1933 Tavern
Overall Ratings
4 based on 120 reviews
Reviewed By kmartin16
I believe I reviewed Gerber's once before so this is a follow up to that positive review. For those that don't know, Gerber's is a pioneering spot near the Aud that is small but warmly decorated with local artists' work displayed throughout and decor informed by it's speakeasy past. The lamp shades have Gerber daisies painted on them, thus the name. Since last review I had brunch and a couple of lunches, which were all excellent. I generally go for lunch and my go to order is reuben or pastrami which never fails. I always get a cup of soup for my side too as they are always home made. Today I had the pickle soup and it was thick, delish with a lot of carrot in it. I also had the fried bologna sandwich with long hots, which comes with potato chips and pickle spear. Wow, that will be my new go to order. With the stone ground mustard and horseradish that was on the table, and the very spicy roasted long hots, this was a delightful sandwich on crunchy hot toasted bread. Bravo. You can come for a drink here after work too and the staff is knowledgable and friendly and the bar is well stocked. Full disclosure, I know the owner well but I would give the same review if it was run by a stranger. Check it out.
6. Pumpernickel's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 41 reviews
Reviewed By BeReal1977
I love the atmosphere in there.. Friendly staff.. Attentive.. Great food.. I had the grilled cheese with bacon, side salad and fries.. Feel good food.. The owner came out and said hello which he always makes a point and you donât see that often anymore.. Unfortunately I always forget about the place but happy I hit it up today with friends..
Where to eat Mediterranean food in New Hartford: The Best Restaurants and Bars
5. Tom Cavallo's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
3 based on 126 reviews
Reviewed By bryan377
I've had an association with this pub that lasts decades. If you live in the Utica area, this is where you go. It's a local gathering place. I often joke that the waitresses here have a little attitude, but they are usually in the midst of heavy volume. My family likes Italian food and chicken fingers and pub foods. Given the wide bredth of menu choices, there is something for everyone. Between friends and family, the opinion of the food here differs significantly. Most of our extended family sees it as good. I always like the food here, I can't say I love it. I think you need to try it and see where your tastes lie. I see this as a reliable and affordable Utica Mainstay. If you are local, you are likely to see someone you know. For that reason, a visit always feels like a return home. No matter how you look at it, it's worth a visit and then you can draw your conclusion.
Top 5 Lebanese food in New Hartford, New York, United States
4. Swifty's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 218 reviews
Reviewed By W4765DXmargaretm
We stopped in for dinner & drinks! Sara was our waitress & she was lovely! I asked her opinion about local beer options & food! She offered great selections! I had the local Saranac Blueberry Ale! It was served in a nice chilled glass with some actual blueberries in the glass! I loved it!! For dinner, my husband had the chicken cutlet parmigiana & I had the boneless wings, medium. We also ordered the scallops wrapped in bacon, as an appetizer. Everything was fantastic! The scallops were fresh & hot. Very delicious!!! The chicken parmigiana was incredibly tasty, being this was a pub & not an Italian restaurant. Highly recommend!! I wish I had taken photos to show you. Definitely stop in for lunch or dinner!! The staff was great!!
Where to eat American food in New Hartford: The Best Restaurants and Bars
3. 99 Restaurants
Overall Ratings
4 based on 76 reviews
Welcome to your New Hartford Ninety Nine Restaurant where we have "A Passion To Serve." Come dine with us and check out our 9 Real Size Entrees for just $9.99 or come enjoy our Thursday Night Trivia at the bar.
Reviewed By Brodiem
This was our first experience at this restaurant. The service was wonderful. The food was great! The menu was reasonably priced. You got great food for the cost. Strongly recommend this restaurant for lunch. Oh, on another thing, very kid friendly! We brought the grandkids with us and they enjoyed themselves too.
2. Nail Creek Pub
Overall Ratings
4 based on 150 reviews
Hello and welcome to Nail Creek Pub & Brewery. We opened our doors in March of 2008 with the intent of bringing craft beer to the Mohawk Valley. At that time, most people said that the areas citizens didn't want craft beer. They told us that nobody would
Reviewed By napngs
We visited here exactly one year ago. We were in Utica for the same events this year. Utica's Tomato Pie Day at the Parkway Center, Wine & Chocolate event at the Memorial Auditorium, and the Utica College Physical Therapy students' "Muscle Hustle" on Varick St. These have become annual events for us. The anchor of Varick St is Saranac Brewery. This street is a busy, hip mix of breweries, pub, and eateries, many w/ outdoor seating. Nail Creek Pub has outdoor seating. You better bring your "A" game if you want to serve the public on this crowded street. That being said, after a brew stop at the Celtic Harp across the street, we decided for dinner at the Nail Creek Pub. This craft brew pub offers to Belgian beers, two stouts, & a saison. Also wine and full liquor bar. This place has a very loyal local clientele, but is very friendly to visitors like us. A good crowd was already enjoying the day we we sat down (table 11, front corner).Two women were flying around taking care of all. We ordered drinks and dinner. My bride ordered the roasted red pepper soup ($5.) and a Mediterranean grilled cheese sandwich ($9.). Soup first, a bit too much heat for her, but very excellent to me so I finished that. I had a shrimp po' boy. It comes on grilled bread, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, and remoulade ($10.). All served hot and as expected. Funny thing, if you don't want fries, you can get a 16 oz. Utica Club beer instead - Brilliant. A limited menu but not limited on quality. Week nights specials are available.Dinner for two w/ two wines, one Jameson, tax & tip $57.00. A good value to us. We don't know the names of the two women working this day but they were doing a very good job keeping up on this busy day (O# 180315). Hours: M-Sat 11:30am-2am, Sun 10am-5pm. Yes, they offer a Sunday Brunch too.The local "clubhouse" feel of Nail Creek Pub distinguishes it from the other bars on Varick St. We will visit again. Thank you.
Most Popular Italian food in New Hartford, New York, United States
1. Carmella's Cafe
Overall Ratings
4 based on 135 reviews
Reviewed By teena1014
Havenât been here in about 20 years and was startled that is hasnât changed one bit! Even the same things were hanging on the wall. The food was mediocre, at best. The haddock Florentine was tasteless. I ordered a wine and she brought me two... 2 for 1. Who brings two to the table like that?!Anyway, I wonât ever try again.
Best Middle Eastern food near New Hartford, New York, United States
