Location: Nutley
Top Restaurants in Nutley
Countries
New Jersey, United States Food Guide: 10 Pizza food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Nutley
Best Pizza restaurants nearby. Discover the best Pizza food in Nutley. View Menus, Photos and Reviews for Pizza restaurants near you.. Nutley is a township in Essex County, New Jersey, United States. As of the 2010 United States Census, the township's population was 28,370, reflecting an increase of 1,008 (+3.7%) from the 27,362 counted in the 2000 Census, which had in turn increased by 263 (+1.0%) from the 27,099 counted in the 1990 Census.
Things to do in Nutley
10. Rocky's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 12 reviews
Right Across the Street from Shop Rite Food Market, small white building with parking on the side.
Reviewed By Tom C
North Jersey is home to the best pizza on the planet. So many different types: thin or thick, traditional pizza oven to brick oven. For the most part, they're all very good and one must decide what they're really in the mood for. Nutley is blessed with great food everywhere, but when it comes to pizza, GOD smiles down on us. Case in point; Rocky's, which is the quintessential old school Italian owned pizzaria. Delicious dough, perfect sauce, high quality cheeses and toppings. I always order mine with extra cheese and sauce plus toppings and wear old paint stained clothes to eat it. The pie just goes with gravity. But, let me say this. Upon getting through as much as you possibly can get through at one sitting, you'll be grinnin'. Your best bet is pick it up youself, so it's on you to get it home intact..!
9. Ritacco Brothers Brick Oven Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 13 reviews
Reviewed By NJWorldTraveler3
Always looking for a great local pizza restaurant. Was told to try the Grandma pizza. It was everything I expected an more. It's square and medium thickness but very, very, tasty. Try it and you won't be disappointed.Haven't tried anything else on the menu but certainly will. Place appeared neat and clean and rather busy. Parking on the street can be a problem.
8. Casa Turano
Overall Ratings
4 based on 13 reviews
Reviewed By 604DonM
This is actually one half of two adjacent restaurants that share a kitchen. This side mostly caters to take-outs and, well, catering. But, it does have a small casual dining area. The food is terrific and the staff a re friendly. It's a nice casual place to eat without going through the process of a more formal sit down restaurant.
7. Luna Wood Fire Tavern
Overall Ratings
4 based on 17 reviews
Reviewed By tebigfan
Overall a very nice establishment - friendly staff and nice atmosphere. The Non-Pizza menu is fairly creative and overall very good. The real standout here is the Wood Burning Oven Pizza. Fantastic! A wonderful variety of Pizza not found anywhere else in our area. They offer takeout as well - the pizza is thin crust and definitely worth eating in or taking out.
6. Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 86 reviews
Reviewed By Tonypana
The crunchy dough and fresh tomatoes ,basil and mozzarella cheese make this pizza very special and really stands out for its freshnes and quality. The sangria is one of the best in town.Very nice place to have excellent pizza and a good drink !
5. Michaels Pastaria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 23 reviews
Reviewed By kimbadreamer
I've been here twice - both times we were seated on the side at a small, cozy table. While I ordered the same thing both times I've visited and found consistently good Rigatoni Bolognese, my boyfriend has not have the same experience with the dishes he has tried. The calamari is a good appetizer however the salads are extremely overpriced ($14.00 for cesare salad for 2). The salad was not even that good - way too much dressing made for soggy lettuce. My boyfriend had the pork chops the first visit and the chicken marsala the 2nd visit. The marsala was nothing like we've ever had. The sauce was dark and a bit bitter. My only suggestion is to be careful what you order because not everything is made well. Again, the Bolognese was consistently good and the small portion was a totally adequate portion.
4. Napoli Trattoria & Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 22 reviews
Reviewed By MelissaWorldtravelor
A friend recommended this restaurant and Iâm glad I decided to come here. I took my 87 year old grandmother and she really enjoyed the food she ordered the risotto with seafood which was very tasty a little salty for me yet still very delicious . I got the freshly made pasta with crab meat. We also ordered a salad with buffalo mozzarella cheese, on water melon,strawberries and blueberries with a fig dressing that was so yummy. Service was great waitress was very friendly and everything was good so I do plan on returning here for dinner. I highly recommend this Italian restaurant if you are in the area. Itâs also a BYB so make sure you buy your wine before you come here.
3. Taste of Tuscany
Overall Ratings
4 based on 67 reviews
Reviewed By Lynb61
Taste of Tuscany is a small pizzeria and restaurant. The food is fresh and tasty. Service was great. I had the bruschetta pizza slice which was topped with lots of tomatoes. My friend had a chopped salad which was awesome. Itâs a nice go to place for lunch.
2. Ralph's Pizzeria and Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 91 reviews
Reviewed By Sue Y
Ralphâs came highly recommended to me, so I was not prepared for such a poor experience. Our server had a bad attitude with us, which I felt was very uncalled for. We waited a long time for some of the appetizers. We were a party of 7, and our entrees came out at different times. Some of the food was just OK, and some of it was not good at all. I cannot recommend this restaurant at all.
1. Queen Margherita
Overall Ratings
4 based on 168 reviews
Reviewed By Sprinkles111
The food is excellent, hands down from what the group I was with said. I am Gluten Sensitive & at the time, this place was not accommodating so I had mussels and a salad Kindly sucks when you are with a group and they indulge & you have to split the bill. Ok - onto my review: The place is really SMALL & tables are too close together so if you like family style with people next to you - this is for you. THE NOISE FACTOR is nothing short of absolutely annoying. The night we were there the owner sang, great voice, however, with the place being packed and people talking it was truly a non-enjoyable night out. We could have done without his singing. Parking is on the street so prepare to walk on a Fri or Sat. There is a bakery connected to the restaurant which is really good. THE OWNER SHOULD INVEST IN SOME NOISE FILTERING products to put on the ceiling or walls to make this a more enjoyable dining experience. Also some GLUTEN FREE dishes would be encouraged since many people have this sensitivity especially when a person has a thyroid disease !!!
Where to eat Italian food in Nutley: The Best Restaurants and Bars
