Location: Shrewsbury
Top Restaurants in Shrewsbury
Countries
New Jersey, United States Food Guide: 10 Italian food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Shrewsbury
Discover Restaurants offering the best Italian food in Shrewsbury, New Jersey, United States. Shrewsbury is a borough in Monmouth County, New Jersey, USA. As of the 2010 United States Census, the borough's population was 3,809, reflecting an increase of 219 (+6.1%) from the 3,590 counted in the 2000 Census, which had in turn increased by 494 (+16.0%) from the 3,096 counted in the 1990 Census.
Things to do in Shrewsbury
10. Europa Grill
Overall Ratings
4 based on 28 reviews
Reviewed By loulombo
Three couples tried the Europa Grill for the first time on a Friday night. They take reservations, but not crowded at all. Perhaps due to bad weather.Europa offers both Portugues and Italian. Almost all in our party had seafood of some type, from the tuna (cooked perfectly) to the Snapper (also delicious) to the Pasta with shrimp to the skirt steak with shrimp.Overall rating from the group was a 4+ out of 5. We had coffee and dessert as well. The place was quiet which was nice as we could hear ourselves talk. We spent 2 hours plus, but it was quite enjoyable. Not rushed. This is a BYOB and salads come with the meal.We will return.
9. Federico's Pizza Express
Reviewed By Bevi1083
Excellent pizz, subs, steaks, and entrees. Homemade sauce and great salad. Victor takes pride in everything that he serves. They also do catering, and we have had several house parties catered by them. They will provide everything you need to make your guests very happy!
8. Mangia Brick Oven Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 12 reviews
Reviewed By jackF893HR
Looks like your typical pizza place in the front, but there is a dining room in the back. Not very large, but nice. The food was great and wish I had asked what sauce was on the salmon as it was delicious. I am not a salmon fan but my husband ordered it for himself and when I tasted it, I thought that if I had the recipe I would definitely eat salmon regularly. He enjoyed it very much as well. I had ordered a pizza after reading all the rave reviews. I ordered a Margherita pie which is tomatoes and fresh slices of mozzraella . The crust was baked perfectly and the portion was at least 12 cuts though small slices. I then ordered NY cheesecake which was excellent. The service was great even though it was our waitress's first night on the job. Whatever questions we asked and she didn't know she immediately found answers to. The owners were very friendly as well We would definitely visit there again.jackF893HR,Thank you so much for your review! It means a lot to our business to get feedback from our customers. We strive to provide quality products and service. If there is anything we can do to make the experience better for our customers please let us know.sincerely,The Mangia Family
7. Taliercios
Overall Ratings
5 based on 108 reviews
Reviewed By 1109RandyS
This is THE best italian deli in the area. The sandwiches are enormous. The bread is fresh. Most of their business is catering for events. We order here all the time for small gatherings when we need food. Everything they make is outstanding. Its a no brainer. If you live in the area and have not tried this place, do yourself a favor and stop in.
6. Guido's Famous Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 31 reviews
Reviewed By CypressTX_Traveler
Even on his death bed my Dad wanted Jersey pizza. As Jersey transplants to 60's Texas my childhood was an endless quest by the parents for the mythical holy grail of "good" pizza.. This place delivered great pizza,the kind that even tastes good cold and smells so good hot you want to open the box before you get home. Hubs and I both noticed salt, says a lot for him to notice! I'm presuming the cheese in our cheese pizza was the culprit.
Best Brew Pub food near Shrewsbury, New Jersey, United States
5. Ruffino's Pizza and Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 45 reviews
Eatontown's Oldest Pizza and Restaurant Establishment since 1975. Specializing in homemade Italian meals and Brooklyn style pizza. Using locally grown produce, we are known for our great eggplant parmesan and other homemade recipes. Dine -In or Take Away.
Reviewed By bawestvirginia
I love anchovies and capers (no salt problems for me obviously!), so the putannesca pizza was a given. It was great. Good crust, evenly placed goodies. The salad for 2 was not as successful, but ok. Delivery was prompt and polite. I may not be in this area again, but i'll eat here if so!
4. Buona Sera Ristorante & Bar
Overall Ratings
4 based on 429 reviews
Reviewed By 132davidr
Decent service, food and setting. I like when tables are far enough apart that you canât be overheard but can still what others are eating. Wife had the chicken cacciatore that was very favorable and a healthy sized portion. Mom had the 12 oz sirloin which provided more than enough for our dogs the next day. And I had the branzino fish grilled in oil that was superb and most importantly did not not kill me with all the sharps little bones which were expertly removed.
Where to eat American food in Shrewsbury: The Best Restaurants and Bars
3. Via45
Overall Ratings
4 based on 215 reviews
via45 is a rustic italian eatery. We offer vegetarian, vegan and Gluten-Free choices. each plate is offered to guests according to their preference and dietary restrictions. all foods are prepared "in the moment".the hand written menu changes every day...
Reviewed By legendgerry2017
This was a special occasion, my wife's 61 st birthday. We could only make reservations for 5:30 pm on a Saturday. This was okay with us so we took it.This is a farm to table restaurant so the menu is somewhat limited, but again that was fine with us.Our table was a long table with the three of us at one end another couple at the other end, which felt a little awkward, the chairs were irregular.The bread served was absolutely delicious and our appetizers were excellent. These were ready on a timely basis. However, we waited approximately 30 minutes for our entree. The excuse was that the chicken I ordered took long to make. Why did they wait until after I ordered to tell us that?Our server was okay, but never brought over a bucket or holder to keep our wine chilled after she said she would.When my entree arrived, it was so hot my mouth was burned on the inside. Had to wait longer for it to cool to a warm but not burning temperature. Once it cooled somewhat it was very good.The matre de was very standoffish and not really a welcoming individual.Overall, food was very good, communication and attention to details of the over all experience were not good and for the cost of the meal and reputation they have this should have been better.I would not recommend this place even though the food is good, they need to be more considerate of their customers and solicitous. Much more hospitable places available in Red Bank.
Where to eat Cafe food in Shrewsbury: The Best Restaurants and Bars
2. Birravino
Overall Ratings
4 based on 354 reviews
Reviewed By Marsha C
Our group of 5 went for a post-graduation dinner and all appeared to be happy with our choices. The service and menu were excellent. Killed to have one of their craft beers which I enjoyed. They served a selection of assorted breads with our drinks. We ordered a house salad which was large enough for 3 of us to share. The menu was extensive and everyone had different selections which we all enjoyed. The wait staff here very attentive. Overall excellent experience
1. Pazzo Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 372 reviews
Reviewed By charlesd288
First time visiting Pazzo MMX on Front Street in Red Bank with my Jersey Family. We parked in the adjacent pay parking lot. Started with Margherita Pizzas for appetizer, small but Good. Had the Veal Parmigiana with Ziti as the main course-Good. Sauce was a bit bland, and the Veal was relatively thick sliced. It was a large portion that I shared with others. My wife had the Shrimp which she found to be Very Good. Dessert was Cheesecake and Espresso. Cheesecake was Good/Very Good. The Espresso was Fair. Service was Very Good. Setting was very noisy when full.
Most Popular Seafood food in Shrewsbury, New Jersey, United States
