Location: Pitman
Top Restaurants in Pitman
Countries
New Jersey, United States Food Guide: 10 Italian food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Pitman
Reviews on Italian food in Pitman, New Jersey, United States. Pitman is a borough in Gloucester County, New Jersey, United States. As of the 2010 United States Census, the borough's population was 9,011, reflecting a decline of 320 (-3.4%) from the 9,331 counted in the 2000 Census, which had in turn declined by 34 (-0.4%) from the 9,365 counted in the 1990 Census. The borough was named for Rev. Charles Pitman, a Methodist minister.
Things to do in Pitman
10. Pasta Pomodoro
Overall Ratings
4 based on 61 reviews
Reviewed By Jared W
This is a no frills, great food Italian restaurant. A few things I look for when eating Italian...the bread they serve and the Chicken Marsala. Well, Pasta Pomodoro serves delicious, crispy on the outside/soft on the inside, warm, little dinner rolls...and their Marsala is outstanding. Their chicken is always tender and very flavorful. The penne vodka with grilled chicken will be one of the best you've tasted. This is a small Italian joint that makes excellent food...plain and simple.
9. Nick's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 16 reviews
Nick's Pizza in Glassboro, NJ serves delicious pizza made with only the freshest and finest ingredients.
Reviewed By DanaSmith8
Ordered 3 regular pizzas- cheese, buffalo chicken, and mushroom. The buffalo chicken pizza had an average amount of meat and buffalo sauce and was the winner of the three pizzas. One could taste the spiciness from the buffalo sauce. The mushroom pizza was definitely lacking in mushroom. I feel like it was maybe 1-2 small mushrooms chopped and scantly scattered over the pizza. Either put more chopped mushrooms on the pizza itself so that one would taste the mushrooms or slice the mushrooms then top the pizza with it. Looking at the mushroom pizza one could not tell it was mushroom because the pieces of mushroom were so small. The cheese pizza was average. Overall I would probably want to explore more pizza places in the area before I order from this establishment again.
8. Val's Seafood Trattoria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 84 reviews
Reviewed By Patrick M
We saw this place on Facebook and decided to give it a try. From the outside it doesn't look like much and you might miss it if you were just driving by. On the inside it is done up like you are eating in a plaza in Italy. the service was very good. The food was very good, I ordered Scallops over butternut squash risotto. The scallops were well cooks and the risotto was nice with chunks of butternut squash in it. The serving size was large and filling. Overall a decent place to eat. Would go again.
7. Gino's Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 12 reviews
Reviewed By requinn3
Me and my wife stop by Gino's every now and then when we are on the run and just want to sit down for a couple slices instead of ordering a whole pizza. They have a nice sized selection to choose from if you just want to order by the slice. Fries are pretty good and served in a large portion. The service is eh. It's just so-so and what I would expect from a pizzeria, but I don't go there for the service.
6. Pizza Italia
Reviewed By AndiamoAMagna
If you re going to the hollydell ice arena, pizza Italia is a good option for a quick slice of pizza. It's located one block from the rink. Pizza is on the salty side. Crust is ok. Some tables to eat inside.
5. Italian Affair Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 153 reviews
Reviewed By otrs
I took my mom for lunch as she wanted a place to eat where they had wine and she is in assisted living We just got appetizers : the eggplant balls which were plentiful & delicious $8.00 and their version of bang bang shrimp were very good also but you only get 3 for $12.00! Waitress was nice & service was good. Place is very nice & clean inside. We were the only patrons besides a family of 6. We also had coffee & dessert. Mom raved about Limoncello cake. My tiramasu was a little too strong on the brandy. Not cheap but will go back to try dinner.
4. Mannino's Cucina Italiana
Overall Ratings
4 based on 113 reviews
Reviewed By Larkus86
When I saw the white linen table cloths and linen napkins in their photos it set my expectations for a better experience than we had. We ordered appetizers, salads, and entrées. And that's the order the food should be presented. Instead, we received apps and salads simultaneously - so either one gets cold or the other gets warm. They had a $16 filet mignon egg roll which I ordered off the specials. It wasn't nearly as good as the chipped beef eggrolls I get at my local bar and was twice the price. The wrapper was soft and doughy instead of having a crisp exterior and the inside was just mush. The salad was delicious - I forget the name but it consisted of a few long romaine lettuce leaves as a base with tomatoes, crispy prosciutto some other bits and a blue cheese dressing. I would recommend that for sure. But the entrée, I had the chicken Marsala, was probably one of the worst I've ever been served. The traditional thickened brown sauce was replaced with a runny, pale tan cream base (which I've never seen at any other Italian restaurant in my life). The chicken wasn't dusted and browned at all but rather a couple of pale, chewy, salty, thin slabs. I left it uneaten, and just ate some of the pasta and the mushrooms. When presented with my largely uneaten plate at the end of the meal, the server's helper asked "Do you want it boxed" instead of "Did you enjoy your meal" or "Was there anything wrong?" In fact, no one checked in on our table at all to see if our meals came out correctly and we had to flag the single waiter or single helper down in the half full restaurant for more water several times. The bread didn't even hit the table until after the appetizers were delivered (about 20 minutes into our visit). The price point for the place is upper mid-range, but after the first course, the waiter's assistant, when clearing the first course plates, would take the silver ware off the plate and drop it on the table. Beyond making our table dirty with food bits and sauces, you should never touch a diner's utensils unless you intend to clear them. If you're trying to save on water, at least have the decency to say "Do you want to keep your knife and fork?" That would signal the diner to either find a place to put their utensils for re-use, or allow them to say "I'd prefer a fresh knife and fork." If this were some chain place like Olive Garden, you'd expect to be treated like cattle. But not so much in a place like this.On the plus side, the restaurant was clean and well lighted and the hostess and two floor staff were friendly enough, though not engaged in our actual dining experience as a whole. There were too many diners to pull off having only one waiter and a helper.We came for dinner and sadly the food, and service of same, is where they fell down.
3. Mama Marie's Italian Market
Overall Ratings
5 based on 42 reviews
Reviewed By Safetyguy_328
First time here. Like Pitman nice small town. Today is a cold icy day so many businesses have delayed opening. My client the Borough owns at 10, Iâm here at 9:10 so âpenguins walkedâ here for breakfast. Reviews are promising.Place is clean and bright and quiet on a sunny morning. They have prompt friendly service. Fried eggs were good and the pork roll was great. Comes with a hash brown which was nice and crisp as I prefer.Nice views of Main-street. Overall a nice local place with good food.
2. Terra Nova
Overall Ratings
4 based on 204 reviews
Reviewed By disneygirl85
Not a very good meal. No one in our party of 5 enjoyed their meal. The lobster bisque and house salads were very good. But the entrees were a disappointment. My chicken verde was poorly prepared. A too thin, over breaded and over cooked chicken breast was sliced into sticks. I can say the salad portion of the plate was very fresh. Two of our deserts had to be replaced because the didnât taste right. We were seated well away from the nearly empty main dining room and spent much of the evening asking for them to put on the heat. Even the sugar packets were hard. Wonât be back.
1. Pizzeria Mannino's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 79 reviews
Reviewed By Millerdes
Donât go to the main Manninos restaurant. Get your bottle of wine and bring it to the Pizzeria!! Food and service are a million times better! Staff is friendly, attentive and outgoing. Pizza is amazing and Iâm not a huge pizza person. Great for a night out with friends or a date night too!
