Location: Middletown
Top Restaurants in Middletown
Countries
New Jersey, United States Food Guide: 10 Italian food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Middletown
Best Italian restaurants nearby. Discover the best Italian food in Middletown. View Menus, Photos and Reviews for Italian restaurants near you.. Middletown Township is a township in Monmouth County, New Jersey, United States. As of the 2010 United States Census, the township had a total population of 66,522, making it the state's 16th largest municipality, having seen an increase of 195 residents (0.3%) from its population of 66,327 in the 2000 Census, when it was the state's 17th most populous municipality, which had in turn declined by 1,856 (−2.7%) from the 68,183 counted in the 1990 Census. Middletown is one of the oldest sites of European settlement in New Jersey.
Things to do in Middletown
10. Pasquale's Pizzeria III
Join us in our passion for freshly-made Italian food! At Pasquale's Pizza, you'll be given access to the authentic taste of real Brooklyn pizza. If you've never experienced such a thing before, expect to be blown away by the quality and exciting combinati
Reviewed By kl1smith
We get Pasquale's pizza 3 - 4 times a month. The pizzas are really good and they are always delivered piping hot. The delivery people are especially courteous. We order "custom pizzas" - not on the menu as such (ex. no sauce, broccoli rabe, sliced tomatoes) and they always accommodate our requests. Also - there are $2 coupons in the local super saver ads.
9. Villa Pizza & Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 38 reviews
Reviewed By 914christinee
My family has visited Villa for many occasions, but this will be the last time.We had a Motherâs Day lunch for my mom and grandma there today. While the food is good, the service was so concerning that I wonât be back. We had six dishes ordered. Four were served despite the fact that the pizza and Stromboli seemed to be not only uncooked and unmade, but we wondered if they needed make the cheese? I donât know how baked veal and pasta dishes could be plated so far ahead of time that everyone finished their meals before the pizza and Stromboli came out.In a time like this, I feel as though a restaurant should offer to comp a dish, give a dessert, etc. While the server apologized, that was as close to âmaking it rightâ as they came. Romeoâs Pizza is just down the road and has amazing pizza. Save yourself the wait time and non apology and just go there.
8. Pronto Pizza
Reviewed By MooseMom57
Bought a Groupon in order to try this place out and will definitely be back. We went on a Saturday night and it was DEAD but I'm not sure why. We arrived around 5:45 and were the only eat in customers. By the time we left a few more people had wandered in and only ordered slices.The atmosphere isn't great but the waitress (Erin) was really nice and patient with us. We started with jalapeno poppers (good). I had the chicken francaise ($16.95) which was wonderful (I brought half of it home). I could cut the chicken with my fork. My husband had the lasagna ($12.95). The sauce was very good and it wasn't your usual pasta heavy lasagna but full of cheese and meat. It is one of those rare restaurants where salad and bread are actually included with the meal. The salad was decent with olives, red onions, cukes, tomatoes and greens. We'll definitely be back!
7. Palumbo Restaurant and Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 22 reviews
Reviewed By JJohnsonFam
Palumbo's is our take-out choice. Authentic Italian food with great sauces. Their shrimp parm is terrific! Calamari is cooked perfectly every time. Their pizzas have a crispy crust and fresh toppings. Excellent for the price! Staff si very friendly.
What to do and see in Middletown, United States: The Best Places and Tips
6. Toscanella Village Cafe
Overall Ratings
3 based on 25 reviews
Reviewed By kazu79
Old management see other reviews. New management was those that were behind the scenes anyway. Give it another try. Was here to day. Friendly fresh and good food. Glad it continues. Best of luck.
Middletown Food Guide: 10 Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Middletown
5. Lubrano's 36
Overall Ratings
4 based on 11 reviews
Reviewed By DMACK15
Great hidden gem. Fantastic Italian food. Bread is baked to order. Plenty on the menu for everyone from fish to steak to pasta. Pizza is amazing as well. It's BYOB.
4. Villa Restaurant
Villa Restaurant is a family-owned and operated Italian restaurant providing fresh food without the inconvenient and unexpected changes you constantly find at other restaurants. This means you will always be able to get your favourites, and enjoy the exce
Reviewed By Barbar S
I had a beautiful baby shower at the villa pizzeria in Middletown last Saturday & the service by Michele & her assistant was impeccable! Had a wonderful buffet luncheon & was impressed with all of the selections I had chosen chicken parm, chicken marsala, stuffed shells, penne vodka, eggplant rolatini salad & the garlic knots were a big hit with everyone!! The staff was very accommodating in that they allowed me to set up/decorate the night before store items in their refridgerator & bring in some special desserts & they were very helpful in assisting with that as well!
3. Nino's Family Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 283 reviews
We believe that quality fresh products are to be prepared in a simple and unique way, then served with pride and friendly service resulting in customer satisfaction. Our philosophy is very simple - genuine food and fair price. We are often imitated, but n
Reviewed By 473frede
We visited for dinner. Great early bird specials. The muscles in red sauce were great! I got the eggplant parmesan, chicken parmesan, and ravioli trio. My wife got the gnocchi. Bread with dipping sauce and large salad with housemade dressing. Everything was delicious. The service was great. We took home enough food for 2 more meals including the sauce from the muscles Mmm! My dinner came with bread pudding, my wife got a piece of tiramisu. All for $55. We come here whenever we visit Wildwood!!
Where to eat Seafood food in Middletown: The Best Restaurants and Bars
2. Patricia's of Holmdel
Overall Ratings
4 based on 179 reviews
Family Casual Fine Italian Restaurant
Reviewed By madamsusan
We heard the great reviews for a couple of years and finally made a reservation to have dinner there. There were many family groups and couples dining in a very congenial atmosphere. Quite a few seemed to be regulars. Our dinners were excellent! My husband's tomato salad with onions, mozzarella and cucumbers was huge and was easily enough for 3 people. I initially planned to skip having an appetizer but couldn't resist the fried ricotta stuffed zucchini flowers. I'm glad I caved because they were delicious. Our entrees of Veal Parm with a side of pasta and Veal Milanese were very good and enormous. No complaints from me because I didn't have to make dinner the following night there were so many leftovers. Although we were completely stuffed we had to order the zeppoles with Nutella dipping sauce with cappuccini for dessert. They were scrumptious and again could be shared by 3 or 4. Service was pleasant and attentive. Prices were reasonable and it's always a savings when it's BYOB. We will definitely return soon!
Most Popular Brew Pub food in Middletown, New Jersey, United States
1. Taliercios
Overall Ratings
5 based on 108 reviews
Reviewed By 1109RandyS
This is THE best italian deli in the area. The sandwiches are enormous. The bread is fresh. Most of their business is catering for events. We order here all the time for small gatherings when we need food. Everything they make is outstanding. Its a no brainer. If you live in the area and have not tried this place, do yourself a favor and stop in.
