Location: Keyport
Top Restaurants in Keyport
Countries
New Jersey, United States Food Guide: 10 Italian food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Keyport
Find out what Italian restaurants to try in Keyport. Keyport is a borough in Monmouth County, New Jersey, United States. At the 2010 United States Census, the borough's population was 7,240, following a decline of 328 (-4.3%) from the 7,568 counted in the 2000 Census, which had in turn declined by 18 (-0.2%) from the 7,586 counted in the 1990 Census. Keyport's nickname is the "Pearl of the Bayshore" or the "Gateway to the Bayshore".
Things to do in Keyport
10. Denino's Pizza Place
Overall Ratings
4 based on 79 reviews
Welcoming your loved ones to our family-friendly restaurant. Owner Michael Denino's father created his first authentic NY style pizza in 1951. Michael's strove to bring traditional quality pizza to Denino's Pizza Place. Our restaurant always uses the fres
Reviewed By Miketheattorney
I am a regular here and in Staten Island, but I don't think I've ever written a review. Tonight I had the always delicious buffalo wings, salad with their wonderful balsamic, fried shrimp (really good) and a plain pizza. Everything was delicious. Never disappointed here.
9. La Strada Pizza
Reviewed By corptool
We gave this place another try for dinner, even though we had not been happy before. I should have stuck with my original impression. They do have seating, but it is not pretty, with plain chipped Formica tables and cheap paper napkins from a table dispenser. We sat a while until the waitress came over. They need to treat for fruit flies, since there are way too many of them inside the restaurant on a cold winter day. There was nobody else in the restaurant but the four of us - never a good sign.We ordered and got our food in a timely manner. The food was hot and tasted OK with large portions, but everyone at the table said their food was just mediocre - not even very good. Then, when the unitemized bill came, it seemed to be several dollars too high. I rarely get an unitemized bill in a restaurant and never like it, since it always means that they are hiding something. When I asked for an explanation at the cashier (same waitress), she and the owner told me that they upcharged me 50% from the listed menu price without telling me because I ordered Alfredo Sauce on my pasta (the dish went from $12 to $18). The waitress said nothing when I ordered it and would not adjust it when I was at the register. This was not a good dining experience, even for a mid-range pizza place. I don't recommend it. You can do much better in the local area.
8. Angela's Pizza and Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 20 reviews
Reviewed By Ria C
Not just for pizza. Start with the fried calamari appetizer. It's HUGE! Share it, the only way to go because you want to save room for the lasagna. It's yummy. They give you a piece of bread with tomato/basil yumm-ish-ness. Salad comes next and then your entree. My lasagna was delicious. Not smothered in ricotta, just enough. Try it, you'll like it. The owner is wonderful and the waitress, Grace, is the best. They have a special going on for New Years Eve. If you're in town, give it a try. Very reasonable at $50 with a BYOB and live music. Can't miss.
Where to eat American food in Keyport: The Best Restaurants and Bars
7. Esposito's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 52 reviews
Reviewed By bstoppiello
Espositos has my absolute favorite pizza! I like either the #12 I believe it is with the sausage and sautéed onions or the pie with the vodka sauce. Both pies I love with the sesame seed crust! Definitely our local favorite pizza place, as itâs so close to home too. I would ask to have your pizza cooked lighted on the bottom. Thatâs what I always do and it ends up perfect. Otherwise you will often get well done.
Most Popular Sushi food in Keyport, New Jersey, United States
6. Patricia's of Holmdel
Overall Ratings
4 based on 179 reviews
Family Casual Fine Italian Restaurant
Reviewed By madamsusan
We heard the great reviews for a couple of years and finally made a reservation to have dinner there. There were many family groups and couples dining in a very congenial atmosphere. Quite a few seemed to be regulars. Our dinners were excellent! My husband's tomato salad with onions, mozzarella and cucumbers was huge and was easily enough for 3 people. I initially planned to skip having an appetizer but couldn't resist the fried ricotta stuffed zucchini flowers. I'm glad I caved because they were delicious. Our entrees of Veal Parm with a side of pasta and Veal Milanese were very good and enormous. No complaints from me because I didn't have to make dinner the following night there were so many leftovers. Although we were completely stuffed we had to order the zeppoles with Nutella dipping sauce with cappuccini for dessert. They were scrumptious and again could be shared by 3 or 4. Service was pleasant and attentive. Prices were reasonable and it's always a savings when it's BYOB. We will definitely return soon!
5. Ray's Real Pizza
Reviewed By Christine C
Ray's is one of my favorite Italian restaurants. Every dish I have tried, and I have tried many, is delicious. While their pizza is delicious, their pastas (especially the baked ziti) are my favorite. The staff are friendly and very helpful too.
4. Italian Touch
Reviewed By Roxanne M
Recently opened restaurant delivers extremely good pizza as well as excellent baked ziti and lansagna. Try the chicken parm and you won't be disappointed. Lunchtime pasta specials at $6.95 are a steal.
3. Keyport Pizza & Restaurant
Reviewed By JJohnsonFam
Consistently(key word) good pizza & calzones. Sub sandwiches are basic Jersey subs but always fresh & good. Owner is there everyday with a smile on his face. Place is small, eat-in, and always friendly. Great to pick up a pie on those no one want to cook night.
2. Assaggini Di Roma
Overall Ratings
4 based on 72 reviews
Reviewed By jasongT6695AV
My parents live in NJ and they go here almost every week for their date night. Weâve had birthday parties here and many meals, this is the first review I thought to post. The staff is amazing. Very attentive, very polite and friendly.The food is absolutely the âreal dealâ Italian food. Absolutely amazing place to grab some great authentic Italian food.Love coming here. Just remember, it is a BYOB so bring some wine, some beer or whatever you feel like drinking and enjoy a great meal with your own alcohol!
Where to eat Pub food in Keyport: The Best Restaurants and Bars
1. Yesterday's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 93 reviews
Reviewed By JohnP761
This restaurant offers an unlimited salad bar, unlimited soup and unlimited mussels in marinara sauce and then the meal. The stuffed pork chops over a bed is spinach was amazing. The house Merlot was exceptionally reasonably priced. Overall this is a great restaurant for a family that wants a satisfying meal.
