Location: Shelter Island
Top Restaurants in Shelter Island
Countries
Most Popular Seafood food in Shelter Island, New York, United States
Find out what Seafood restaurants to try in Shelter Island. Shelter Island is a town and island at the eastern end of Long Island in the U.S. state of New York. It is part of Suffolk County, although it is separated from the rest of the county by water. The population was 2,392 at the 2010 census.
Things to do in Shelter Island
10. The Pridwin Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 54 reviews
The Pridwin Restaurant is situated in The Pridwin Hotel on Shelter Island. We are open for breakfast, lunch and dinner, and also have a full bar, serving speciality cocktails and more!
Reviewed By westportsailors
I want to like this place, but the slow service and inconsistent food can be annoying. However, the view is fabulous and romantic. So, if you go for the view and zero expectations, you will not be disappointed. Chill and enjoy. Just avoid getting upset about the surly wait staff and the cold food. The chicken surprisingly is really quite good!
9. Sunset Beach
Overall Ratings
3 based on 217 reviews
Reviewed By LoriOnline
This is a see-and-be-seen scene with tasty drinks, fresh, very expensive nibbles and a killer view. We sipped Prosecco, snacked on tasty tuna tartare and watched the yachts anchor and the fabulous people disembark. We commoners were too common to be seated upstairs on our second visit and had to settle for road-side but even then, enjoyed over-paying in this fun spot.
8. American Beech
Overall Ratings
4 based on 180 reviews
Come for the considered and approachable coastal American fare; linger for the convivial and vivacious atmosphere; stay for an unparalleled East End getaway.
Reviewed By RyanManhattan
We ate outside on the patio of American Beech. Stunning space inside and out, brilliantly finished and decorated. They allowed our French Bulldog to sit outside on the patio while we dine on a very fresh and generously portioned Lobster sandwich with avocado on focaccia, and an egg breakfast sandwich on pretzel roll. Couldnât have been improved. Perfect.
7. Commander Cody's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 72 reviews
Reviewed By Darline_Gpt
If you are looking for fancy, this is NOT your place! However, if you are looking for the freshest seafood, perfectly cooked, this is most definately your place. Iâve been coming here for years. Itâs a different kind of joint. Itâs always a trip...in a good kind of way. Itâs funky, kitschy and authentic. All I can tell you is the stuffed flounder with scampi butter is totally awesome. Itâs what I have every visit. The biscuits that come with the entree are light and fluffy, made from scratch and delicious. This is a family who invites you into their house, literally, and cooks for you. They sometimes get behind, but itâs OK. Youâll appreciate your dinner all the more. Donât dress up, itâs not a dress up place. Itâs an eating place and itâs terrific!
6. Noah's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 622 reviews
Reviewed By Angela H
Noah's is a lovely restaurant located right on Front Street. Their menu is varied and you can order small plates or regular sized dinner entrees. We had their Octopus Skewers for appetizers and they were really delicious. We also ordered their Seafood Pasta and Striped Bass entrees. Both we well prepared, fresh and delicious.
5. PORT Waterfront Bar and Grill
Overall Ratings
4 based on 74 reviews
Outdoor dining overlooking Peconic Bay and Shelter Island. World Famous Lobster Roll, Fish Tacos and Scallop Chowder. Strong Drinks, live music and happy people. Outdoor tiki bar. Family Friendly. No reservations. From the team that brought you SALT Shelt
Reviewed By ParisLibellule
We ordered Tuna poke bowls, mussels, and the clam poâboy. The Tuna poke bowls were overwhelmed by the taste of seaweed, the mussels were average and the clam poâboy was ok but French fries soggy. A mediocre meal for $200 is outrageous.
4. Osprey Bar & Lounge
Overall Ratings
4 based on 91 reviews
Dedication to local farmers and fishermen ensure the dishes celebrate freshness and inspiration. New American style menu is complemented by handcrafted cocktails, world beers and a meticulously curated wine list to round out your exceptional dining experi
Reviewed By sugarsnappeaplum
We came here for dinner with a group of friends and enjoyed cocktails (outstanding espresso martinis!) at the bar as well as outside, alongside the bocce courts! Had a wonderful table in an enclosed room/porch (due to the weather, but still a great atmosphere). Delicious food and wine!! The osso buco is fantastic as well as the seared scallop appetizer. Waitress was very attentive and pleasant!! Very nice spot!
3. Salt
Overall Ratings
4 based on 231 reviews
Reviewed By Sussie33
Arriving by boat is the best way to experience Salt! Service was ok - itâs difficult for everyone in biz in the summer so expect delays but June through September the service is primo. The food was delicious and I would highly recommend this for a very positive fun and unique Hamptons experience.
2. The Frisky Oyster
Overall Ratings
4 based on 404 reviews
The Frisky Oyster offers imaginative cuisine in a sophisticated, metropolitan atmosphere craved by locals and visitors for years. Our menu changes daily to showcase the most exceptional, local ingredients. The local and international wine list is personal
Reviewed By Carrie B
Food was deliciously prepared, but plan on spending $ hip, cool vibe, attentive service. Felt like we we in NYC exciting cocktails. Canât wait to return
Best American food near Shelter Island, New York, United States
1. Little Creek Oyster Farm & Market
Overall Ratings
5 based on 93 reviews
Working waterfront revival on the half shell. Shuck your own oysters at one of the waterfront picnic tables. Shucking instruction and gear provided! Oysters on the halfshell also available. Featuring our own Little Creek oysters from Peconic Bay as well a
Reviewed By RurikH
Ate there last August, I believe, and I loved the oysters. Weâre out for the week and decided to see how well they are doing. Better than ever. The oysters are luscious, in the words of Dudley Moore in the movie 10, â...a conservative 11 on a scale of 1 to 10.â The atmosphere is informal, friendly and funky.
Top 10 Italian food in Shelter Island, New York, United States
