Location: Fish Creek
Top Restaurants in Fish Creek
Countries
Most Popular Seafood food in Fish Creek, Wisconsin, United States
Discover Restaurants offering the best Seafood food in Fish Creek, Wisconsin, United States. Fish Creek is an unincorporated community located in Door County, Wisconsin, United States, within the town of Gibraltar and is located on Highway 42 along Green Bay.
Things to do in Fish Creek
1. Alexander's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 623 reviews
Reviewed By Gwen W
While staying with my sister in Egg Harbor, we had to visit Alexander's again, since I enjoyed it so much last year. The bartenders are friendly, so we decided to once again enjoy dinner at the large bar area. The Manhattans here are excellent, although I wish they would serve a Luxor cherry. I enjoyed the Door County broiled Whitefish, served with a salad, a potato and a vegetable and only around $20.00-amazing!And I would be remiss if I did not mention their signature drink-the Brandy Alexander-be sure to order one after dinner-yummy!
Best American food near Fish Creek, Wisconsin, United States
2. The English Inn
Overall Ratings
4 based on 650 reviews
Reviewed By 931ah
We visited on the recommendation of a friend. Loved the old supper club decor and we were seated by a really friendly host. Our server was very personable however extremely scattered. We ordered their specialty the Beef Wellington and the outside looked beautiful but the filet was full of gristle and tasteless. The dough around it gummy. Au gratin potatoes had a watery cheese on them. In Wisconsin they should know of a cheese that melts well. The one thing that was spectacular was the cherry spinach salad with bacon dressing. Best ever! Ordered an old fashioned which tasted good but lacked alcohol. Ordered a martini next and it didnât have much booze in it either. It was hard to get a second drink. Our server kept whizzing by but never stopped. Dirty dishes sat on our table way too long. We thought about ordering dessert but feared another long wait so we got the very large tab and left.
3. Pelletier's Restaurant & Fish Boil
Overall Ratings
4 based on 638 reviews
Reviewed By R2Ontheroad
Another couple joined us and we stepped in and made a 5 pm supper reservation. Then we strolled to the nearby shops. Came back about 1/2 hour before the boil and secured our drinks and outside table. The weather was perfect. The cooking process was explained and the resulting meal was excellent. Highly recommend this to complete your Door County vacation.
4. Barringer's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 103 reviews
Barringer's integrates our signature style with a Wisconsin Supper club and steakhouse experience. Our menu showcases specially selected steaks, fresh seafood and generous sides. Weekly blackboard specials highlight our daily features.The historic dining
Reviewed By HappyTraveler1957
We came here for dinner. The restaurant was far from full, but yet they were turning people away, telling them it would be an hour wait. Seemed odd. We opted to sit at the bar, where there were some empty seats. It took quite a while for them to take our food order and even longer for the food to arrive. Perhaps they were short staffed. We had the beef stroganoff which was very good. Probably would not return though, given the lackluster service.
