Top Restaurants in Lewis Center
Countries
Most Popular Pub food in Lewis Center, Ohio, United States
Discover Restaurants offering the best Pub food in Lewis Center, Ohio, United States including Matt the Miller's Tavern, BJ's Restaurant & Brewhouse, The Liberty Tavern, Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern, Prohibition Gastro Lounge, Caribbean Jerks, Uptown Deli and Brew, Olentangy River Brewing Company, Atlas Tavern, O'Nelly's Sports Pub & Grill
Things to do in Lewis Center
10. O'Nelly's Sports Pub & Grill
Reviewed By Robin K
I wasn't sure I wanted to post this review. We went after work, on a Friday and LOVED it. Loved the energy, loved the atmosphere. I don't think it'll stay a secret for long. :-)
9. Atlas Tavern
Overall Ratings
4 based on 22 reviews
Reviewed By Mmadison66
Husband and I stopped by for dinner. We got there about 530pm & pretty empty. As it got more crowded, very noisy. Had bacon ranch fries for 1/2 price happy hour, very tasty!! Well seasoned & done waffle fries with melted cheese, real bacon chopped up & drizzled ranch. I ordered grilled chicken bacon ranch & hubby ordered burger. Huge sandwiches that were delicious. We both substituted fries with our sandwiches. I had 3 way & hubby had chili. He said chili was good. Definitely will go back to try other offerings
8. Olentangy River Brewing Company
Reviewed By Yobie
This truly is an amazing find! The staff is very friendly and knowledgeable about their in-house brewery. My husband enjoyed the brews while I had a very nice latte. It has plenty of seating both indoors and out. Outside had a cornhole setup and a food truck in the parking lot.
7. Uptown Deli and Brew
Overall Ratings
4 based on 166 reviews
Reviewed By Jim L
Smoke salmon is tops. Deli case with desserts, meats, cheeses,etc. Eat in the bar area, the front deli area or in warm times the quiet patio out back where Mario, the owner, keeps a collection of gorgeous blooming flowers. Located in uptown westerville, there are many interesting shops to walk to after your dining experience.
6. Caribbean Jerks
Overall Ratings
3 based on 19 reviews
A fabulous local hangout in the Lewis Center area, where you can come to party your pants off or just simply relax and enjoy a great meal with friends and family. Our scratch kitchen produces favorites such as Lobster Mac and Cheese, BBQ Ribs, hand-pattie
Reviewed By Jesse E
We went to Caribbean Jerks for lunch and found the restaurant to be a very good place to eat. The lunch menu was rather limited but the wonderful staff tried to accommodate my wife's tastes. The homemade chips and queso was excellent. I had a jerk chicken sandwich that was good but not great. My wife had macaroni and cheese with lobster that she really liked. The beer selection was excellent and served icy cold. As the name implies, it had a Caribbean flair that will draw us back.Thank you for stopping in and giving us a try! So sorry you came during Restaurant Week when we have our limited menu available since the focus is on the 3-course Restaurant Week offerings. We keep our lunch specials and our most popular sellers on our limited menu when we participate in this week in January and July. This is the only way we can continue to make all of our homemade scratch kitchen offerings and execute to the highest quality. The other 50 weeks of the year, the full menu is available for lunch and dinner. We are very happy to still be able to make the dish your wife wanted and loved, even though it was not on the menu that day.
5. Prohibition Gastro Lounge
Overall Ratings
4 based on 74 reviews
Reviewed By john_b_263
The Prohibition Gastro Lounge is on the main street through Powell which can have a lot of vehicular traffic on a two lane road. Parking is available on the street but one block away on Hall Street there is a public parking lot. The restaurant has a small store front with some limited seating and a bar on the first floor but there are tables on the second floor where the main seating is located. One drawback for those with mobility issues is the stairs are steep. There is a full service bar available.The listing of different whiskies is extensive and really surprised me. My favorite Woodford Reserve Double Oak was available on the list at a reasonable price. Craft beers are available as well. I thought the drink prices were very reasonable. The menu is limited but the selections are very good. I tried the pulled pork which was amply piled with meat and coleslaw and came with French fries. My wife ordered the salmon which she loved. another in our party ordered the chicken with macaroni and he said the hot spice on the chicken was just right for him. The service was equally top notch. We were promptly seated and our drink orders taken. Our server came back often and checked on us.
Where to eat American food in Lewis Center: The Best Restaurants and Bars
4. Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern
Overall Ratings
4 based on 173 reviews
Rusty Bucket is a casual American restaurant and tavern, a gathering place where people come to share laughter, smiles, and great conversation over food that makes everyone happy. Satisfying and familiar, the menu is classic American fare, thoughtfully pr
Reviewed By gefilte63
I moved from Columbus a year ago and ate at the Rusty Bucket every now and then. The new menu is quite an improvement. I had the Tuna Wrap--marinated tuna steak--and it was great. Fried pickles awesome as well.Good dessert too. My daughter and I split the daily special strawberry shortcake.This is a good place for an informal meal.
Most Popular Mexican food in Lewis Center, Ohio, United States
3. The Liberty Tavern
Overall Ratings
4 based on 128 reviews
Reviewed By SteveN453
I've been going to The Liberty Tavern ever since they have opened. I've dined there with friends, my wife, my staff and even lunches with our men's group. The array of domestic and global as well as craft beers is quite extensive and their selection of spirits is equally broad. The menu offers a nice selection of appetizers, flatbreads, salads, sandwiches/burgers and entrees, all of which are prepared well and are tasty. The service also is pleasant and helpful. This is one of our local favorites and we'll keep coming back here frequently. I do miss the oyster po boy, however!
2. BJ's Restaurant & Brewhouse
Overall Ratings
4 based on 333 reviews
Reviewed By Ewald G
Iâve been to several BJâs but first stop in Columbus- Polaris. The menus are the same as is the beer list. Service was acceptable considered that our girl was breaking in a new server. Problems came with what was served. Our party ordered a range from ribs to burgers to tacos & fish and chips. Ribs were praised while the rest was just average. An odd combination was one order of fries too hot to eat served along with an order of sweet potato fries actually cold to the touch. To the Kitchenâs credit, they did seat a YMCA group of about 30; and had prepared a buffet table to feed the group within minutes. When our server did return, the fries were discussed. She offered a dessert which could not be finished by the four people working on it. It was delicious.
1. Matt the Miller's Tavern
Overall Ratings
4 based on 200 reviews
Looking for a fun place to enjoy craft beers and delicious food? Our upscale tavern a chef-driven of tavern favorites with a unique twist. We offer the finest and freshest ingredients in every dish to enlighten every bite you take. In addition to offering
Reviewed By yoohoo614
There were four of us at dinner and for two of us, it was our first time at this restaurant. The service, by Miles, was great! Among us we ordered fish and chips, flatbread with crab, two salads- one with salmon, and the pasta/shrimp/sausage dish.Rated highest was the fish and chips. Not so great was my salad. The greens were not as fresh as I would expect and the salmon was overcooked- fried, it seemed. I had asked for the salmon to be cooked "medium". It was fresh, though, with no fishy taste. We were seated in a little room away from the larger crowd - which was so nice at first but then our little room was filled with very loud people. I know this is not the fault of the restaurant staff, but it did affect our enjoyment of the experience since we could no longer converse.I'm sorry that you didn't feel the food was consistent for your entire party. I hope that the server, Miles, and the management staff were able to make it right for you. If you ever have an issue or don't enjoy a meal don't hesitate to let them know! We want to make sure that every guest leaves happy and satisfied with the service and food quality! We will use these comments to help us to get better. Thank you for dining with us and we hope you will join us again,Kristin HlavinMarketing Communications CoordinatorCLB [email protected]
