Location: Puyallup
Top Restaurants in Puyallup
Countries
Most Popular Pizza food in Puyallup, Washington, United States
Reviews on Pizza food in Puyallup, Washington, United States. Puyallup, Washington (/pjuːˈæləp/ ( listen) pew-AL-əp or /pjuːˈɔːləp/ pew-AWL-əp) is a city in Pierce County, Washington, about 10 miles (16 km) southeast of Tacoma and 35 miles (56 km) south of Seattle. The population was 37,022 at the 2010 Census and the Washington State Office of Financial Management estimated the 2014 population at 38,670. Named after the Puyallup Tribe of Native Americans, Puyallup means "the generous people". It is also home to the Washington State Fair, the state's main fair.
Things to do in Puyallup
10. Farrellis Wood Fire Pizza
Overall Ratings
3 based on 22 reviews
Reviewed By michael_smith56
Stopped in for lunch and ended up ordering two pizzas, a pineapple and Canadian bacon, and Margarita. Other than a salad, the menu is limited if you are looking for a vegetarian option. The Margarita pizza was delivered topped with congealed cheese and balsamic vinegar, some type of gritty red sauce and a sprinkling of diced tomatoes. The crust was alternately mushy in the center and doughy/gummy on the outside. Most boxed, frozen pizzas, as bad as they can be, are better than this "artisan" pizza from Farrelli's. The large pizza was $27 and a cup of coffee $3.75, so the grand total for one small pizza and one large, plus two cups of coffee came to a grand total of $49.16.
9. Round Table Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 24 reviews
Reviewed By QCao009
This is one of the worst delivery experiences I ever had. A pizza for 33.00 delivered an hour later, lukewarm, tasting like cardboard. I had called the restaurant back twice when the promised 45 mn delivery was exceeded. And the staff and delivery service were anything but helpful. To make matters worse, we live right around the corner.
8. Amante PIZZA and PASTA
Overall Ratings
4 based on 14 reviews
Reviewed By JessicaL842
Although I did not order the pizza from Amante's, I was in the house when it was delivered. The pizza clearly got dropped in transit. The cheese was all piled on one side..it clearly just needed to be remade. Not to mention, was very doughy and under cooked. We didnt think much of it other then it was a bummer we had to wait for another pizza. My brother called Amante Pizza to let them know that the pizza was unedible, only to be met by a ferocious owner who was yelling and screaming on the phone and refused to have another pizza delivered. The pizza was then packaged up & driven to the Amante Pizza location. What happened next was astonoshing. 2 Amante Pizza owners yelling and shouting at my brother about how he is disrespecting their food and causing shame to their business. For several minutes, the owners were shouting and getting aggressive about us not accepting a pizza that fell onto the floow in transit. The poor delivery driver sheepishly surfaced, very embarrassed wanting to apologize about the pizza. The owners yelled and screamed at the employee telling him NOT to apologize and ordered him to the back of the kitchen. Owners were refusing to remake the pizza..and also refusing to give a refund. They were acting like they were seriously just going to take our money and not give it back. Owner was so aggressive and heated that he almost acted as if he wanted to get into a physical fight over this dropped pizza. Money was finally returned after several minutes of yelling, shouting and threats from the owners.And to top it off..he was so angry... my brother was "black listed" from ever ordering from them again. Ha! Seriusly??? Wow... keep it up amante pizza. WARNING to soon to be customers: check out all the "hidden" comments on yelp/trip advisor/ etc.... comments just like mine are being hidden from public view.
7. Pizza Time
Reviewed By 226phyllisr
Pizza Time has great food and excellent service. Whether you have delivery or take out the service is good. The menu has plenty of great selections. The food is delicious. If you haven't tried this down town Pizza Time, well it is time you do.
Where to eat Italian food in Puyallup: The Best Restaurants and Bars
6. Sparks Firehouse Deli
Overall Ratings
4 based on 46 reviews
Reviewed By U634XYjeffb
Visited around 8:00 pm on a Sat night and although there was only one party there it was super-loud and mimicked a bar crowd more than a restaurant setting. Wife got the Cuban sandwich which was great, I got a cheese pizza that was a little above average. Couldn't help but notice both employees behind the counter eating food with their fingers and then continuing to work. But despite the the loud crowd it was a good choice for a quality sandwich at a fairly reasonable price.
5. Wicked Pie Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 35 reviews
Reviewed By April P
I recently dined at Wicked Pie Pizza. The restaurant is fairly small but clean, cozy and excellent food. The staff were super nice and even allowed me to modify a pizza for my dietary needs. Thank you for the 4 Star review. Glad to hear you enjoyed your pizza and the staff was up to par .We hope to see you soon!
4. Trackside Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 71 reviews
Reviewed By nascent4u
My husband is from the east coast and a big pizza critic. I got 2 large pepperoni pizzas for my 2 grown sons and husband. No left over for the first time ever. And they were decent size (16") pizza's too. Trackside Pizza is sure to be our New Family Favorite for our Pizza go to place. My husband was very impressed and for the first time he didn't have anything critical to say. LOL
3. Casa Mia
Overall Ratings
4 based on 76 reviews
Reviewed By OldPilot1967
FOOD: a very good Mexican alternative for lunch. Fresh ingredients.SERVICE: Friendly and attentive wait staff.VALUE: A good meal for a reasonable price.ATMOSPHERE: the buzz of low conversations from couples, families and business folks. This is not a romantic get away; a nice little diner. We look forward to returning soon.
2. Mod Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 41 reviews
Reviewed By John S
I like the idea of pay one price to build your own pizza. You can get a 6" mini for under $7 and an 11" for under $9. The crust is thin but that was fine because I like thin crust pizza. They also serve salads and beer. Will be back.
Most Popular Pub food in Puyallup, Washington, United States
1. The Rock Wood Fired Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 72 reviews
The Rock Wood-fired Pizza & Spirits is a family focused, full service casual dining concept. Though focusing on gourmet wood fired pizza, The Rock offers an array of pastas, burgers, sandwiches and salads. Add unique microbrews and cocktails to the list a
Reviewed By Rehsinup19
We met some friends here for dinner and had a fun experience. The food and drinks were good and we enjoyed the rock music in the background. Our server was prompt and friendly.Thank you for the taking the time to review us! Hope to see you again soon.-Sincerely, GM Neil L.
