Location: New Philadelphia
Top Restaurants in New Philadelphia
Top Things to do in New Philadelphia
Countries
Most Popular Pizza food in New Philadelphia, Ohio, United States
Best Pizza restaurants nearby. Discover the best Pizza food in New Philadelphia. View Menus, Photos and Reviews for Pizza restaurants near you.. New Philadelphia is a city in and the county seat of Tuscarawas County, Ohio, United States. The county's largest city, New Philadelphia is located on the Tuscarawas River. It is located 71 miles (114 km) south of Cleveland and 119 miles (192 km) northeast of Columbus. The population was 17,288 at the 2010 census.
Things to do in New Philadelphia
9. East of Chicago Pizza
Reviewed By watergirl35
Its nice they have the buffet all the time. Great for kids. The pizza is ok. If you like the style they have. Always have had great service when we have been there.
8. Little Caesars
Reviewed By watergirl35
Its not Penso's pizza, but its a fast pizza. Its not bad pizza for the price. The kids like it, I like the price and the speed. Good for an on the go day or night. Don't like the crazy bread at all.
7. Sbarro
Home of the original XL NY Slice. Since 1956, Sbarro has been serving the XL NY Slice. Starting with made-daily hand stretched dough, San Marzano style sauce and topped with 100% Whole Milk Mozzarella cheese.
Reviewed By RyRy1010
The Pizzas are giant you can't beat it for the price here. Almost every Tuesday I get a large pizza there and it's 10 bucks. Twice the size of any other pizza place. Any other pizza place would charge 20 bucks for this pizza.
6. Maggoo's Pizza, Pasta, & More
Overall Ratings
3 based on 24 reviews
Reviewed By 287jeanniem
Tonight was the third time in five weeks we've eaten here. The first two times the food was excellent: the legendary salad and pizza were flavorful and delicious, as was the baked spaghetti. Tonight, however, everything tasted only of garlic with no other flavors discernible. The salad dressing was heavy on oil and garlic and totally lacking the vinegary-herbaceous taste it's known for. My pepperoni & cheese pizza had very little cheese and its crust was like tasteless cardboard, no bready or yeasty taste whatsoever. Both were huge disappointments. My husband's baked spaghetti was bland and crunchy/crispy, the result of too little sauce & cheese. And the surcharge for the increasing price of lettuce? Come on, how bush league is that? Aldi had big, solid heads for $1 yesterday. And when the price goes lower, will the price of salads decrease proportionately? Don't think so. This inconsistency is why we quit eating here for several years, but we'd heard raves and decided to give it another shot, or actually three. Bottom line, you can't depend on food quality here. And service isn't good, despite a herd of wait staff. It's always slow, unless you have the good fortune to get Carol as a waitress. She's always on the ball and quick without rushing anyone.
5. Penso's Pizza Shop
Overall Ratings
4 based on 16 reviews
Reviewed By David Cory E
Up until Penso's, I was going with more familiar names like Pizza Hut, Domino's and East of Chicago (which are still good), but Penso's sort of stole the show for me. I like the high quality toppings and the pizza dough has an immensely nice flavor. But, it has also has an addictive element to it, hence the title. It's definitely not the cheapest take out, but it is very good and comes highly recommended. Just remember, they only take cash and they're usually only open in the evenings, so if you're not familiar with the hours, call first.
Best Seafood food near New Philadelphia, Ohio, United States
4. Pizza Hut
Reviewed By Amusementparkguy
A friend and I stopped here for dinner one evening a couple weeks ago. Being familiar with Pizza Hut, I knew what to expect. The service was good. Food tasted good. The restrooms and dining area needed a little cleaning. Outside that, things were good.
3. Zifer's Mary Pizza Shop
Reviewed By luvtogogirl
Mary Zifer's has the best pizza in Tuscarawas County! The crust is perfectly thick yet crispy. The sauce is unique and the yellow cheese is different but yummy. They also have delicious rigatoni and their salad dressing is great. They do not deliver which is the only downsize to this perfect family owned pizzeria,
2. Your Pizza Shop
Reviewed By TuscarawasOHMom
First time ordering from here in years. Great tasting pizza! Breadsticks were a favorite! Very friendly people there and they thanked me when we ordered again the same weekend.
Where to eat Italian food in New Philadelphia: The Best Restaurants and Bars
1. Damon's All American Pizza Pie
Reviewed By watergirl35
Its seems every time we call their fryer is down. My husband loves the meatballs. I like the calzon. Needs some adult supervision is you ask me. The food is good, when you get it on time.
Most Popular American food in New Philadelphia, Ohio, United States
