Location: Mastic Beach
Top Restaurants in Mastic Beach
Top Things to do in Mastic Beach
- 1. TWA Flight 800 International Memorial
- 2. William Floyd Estate
- 3. The Gateway - The Performing Arts Center of Suffolk County
- 4. Cupsogue Beach County Park
- 5. Long Island Jet Ski Rentals
- 6. Fire Island National Seashore
- 7. Flyboard Hamptons
- 8. Holtsville Ecology Site
- 9. Shrine of Our Lady of the Island
- 10. Long Island SUP
Countries
Most Popular Pizza food in Mastic Beach, New York, United States
Find out what Pizza restaurants to try in Mastic Beach. Mastic Beach is a former village in the southeast part of the town of Brookhaven in Suffolk County, New York, United States. The population was 12,930 at the 2010 census, at which time it was an unincorporated census-designated place. The village is located in the general vicinity of the hamlet of Mastic Beach.
Things to do in Mastic Beach
10. Savanora's Pizzeria
Reviewed By LongIslandGirl1
We get our pizza here every week. It is delicious and reasonably priced. they don't offer a full menu but several choices of pizza as well as calzones and garlic knots and zeppolis. Our favorite is deep dish.
9. Pizza Hut
Reviewed By Jen B
Yeah, I know. Pizza Hut is a chain and you know just what to expect in general, right? This particular store is one of the mainly "delivery and carryout" depots with just a few small tables. What truly stands out about this brand-new Pizza Hut location is the way the staff really aims to please! We routinely ride our bikes to the shop and they are willing to package up the extra for us in several small sized boxes so that I can carry it home on my bike. They let me borrow the breadstick seasoning shaker and put it all over my pizza (love that!), and they do a great job of fulfilling requests (my example: lightly cooked pizza). The one time that they did undercook the pizza in trying to fulfill the request, they immediately put it back in the oven for me and gave me complementary cheesestix and sauce while I waited for it to finish to perfect :). They are unfailingly nice and really want to make things exactly to your liking. As a picky person, I really appreciate that environment!
8. Alitalia Pizza and Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 32 reviews
Reviewed By Rubank13
I think that their Pizza is usually excellent and they have a large selection too. I bought the Wednesday night special large cheese pie last week for $11.95 added sausage, peppers and onions at $3.00 for each topping. $9.00 for toppings isnât the problem. The problem is the sausage was not slices and could not be found. They used shavings or ultra thin (paper thin slices) which you could not see or even taste on the pie. I never saw that before in 30 years of eating at this joint! I also ordered a dozen and a half of chicken wings as a treat to the family. Terrible - my family of 4 tried to eat them but couldnât. They where not crisp, slightly under cooked and drowned in a sauce that was tasteless. Threw them out! Cook must have had a bad day. I think this is the first time they disappointed us so I will go back and try again but will eat at the store like I usually do. Sorry but this was a bad dinning experience that was too costly at $45 bucks for 1 large pie and 18 wings.
7. Combo Pizza
Reviewed By Diana V
Late Friday, tired, hungry, in the mood for a cold beer and hot pizza. Our first time here, small, had some reservations but so glad we proceeded to walk in. Great value in the thin crust pizza, beer on tap, friendly service. We will definitely be back yummy!
6. Vincent's Pizza
Overall Ratings
3 based on 15 reviews
Reviewed By ducksfan28
Before I ordered I went to their web site. I looked at the menu and the Heros are $6.75 each and 80 cents for parm. I ordered two Heros, one with parm. When I arrived to pick up my order I was asked if I had any coupons, I did not. I have been to many places that use coupons and when you don't have them they will charge you the coupon price. They did not. The total was $17.18. They wouldn't even give me a military discount and they charged at least a $1.50 more per hero then the price on the menu on the web site. The sausage and pepper hero should be called pepper hero. Good luck finding a sausage. I have had better. I will go somewhere else next time!
5. John's Pizzeria & Restaurant
Reviewed By Amanda C
Their pizza is sooooooo good!!! My friends and i literally drive past a dozen pizza places to go here because its so good. The only thing is i wish they were a little cleaner. There not gross but they could use improvement in that area.
4. La Volpe Ristorante
Overall Ratings
4 based on 132 reviews
Reviewed By fascor
Have been here a few times on different occasions and the food has always been great! The Linguine Al Nero was excellent!
3. Nino's Pizza Parlor
Overall Ratings
4 based on 13 reviews
Nino's Pizzeria & Cucina is currently located at 201 Mastic Beach Rd, Mastic Beach, NY 11951. Order your favorite pizza, pasta, salad, and more, all with the click of a button. Nino's Pizzeria & Cucina accepts orders online for pickup.
Reviewed By Johnny L
This is the only place I order pizza from. There are a bunch of pizza places in the area and they all fail. Most close within a few months. Every other pizza place tastes like crap around here. Being from Brooklyn, I am a bit spoiled when it comes to pizza. I didn't think I would ever find a decent pizza place out here. I have had a few good slices on Long Island, but nothing in the Shirley / Mastic Beach area until Nino's. Nothing really compares to L&B Spumoni Gardens in Brooklyn, but these guys do a legit job. Give it a try. You won't be disappointed.
2. Mama Lisa
Overall Ratings
4 based on 125 reviews
Reviewed By mayortony
visited here last Sunday with my wife and son and i have nothing but raves for the place. the food was tasty and plentiful, served piping hot. the Sunday menu specials were wonderful and reasonably priced at $20 and under. they include soup or salad, entree, dessert and coffee. the wait staff was friendly and attentive. both the owner and cook take an active role in the dining room, circulating among the guests to make sure all is well. We canât wait to return. best first time restaurant iâve been to in ages. absolutely loved Mama Lisa.
Best Italian food near Mastic Beach, New York, United States
1. Onofrio's Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 30 reviews
Reviewed By momoboosh
Their pizza is not exactly your tradition pizzeria pie, but it is fantastic. A crispier, buttery crust that reminds me of a deep dish without the thickness. I recommend ordering a meatball/pepperoni pie with extra sauce (or as they call it "juicy") Add a house salad with their amazing garlicky creamy Italian dressing. Incredible combo.
Top 10 American food in Mastic Beach, New York, United States
