Location: Hamlin
Top Restaurants in Hamlin
Countries
Most Popular Pizza food in Hamlin, New York, United States
Discover Restaurants offering the best Pizza food in Hamlin, New York, United States. Matt Heyden (R) First elected 2014
Things to do in Hamlin
10. Caraglio's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 19 reviews
Reviewed By CryptoTracker
I live in Colorado , back in NYS for a weekend funeral staying with my brother he ordered from this place! Was excellent ! We enjoyed it and very well priced friendly staff! Would highly recommend this place!
9. Dustin's Pizzeria
Reviewed By Inferno2727
There are several places to get pizza from in town or in nearby Brockport, but this one is by far my favorite. The pizza is good, wings are always meaty and cooked right, subs are loaded with meat and veggies and their fish frys are fresh and delicious. We've picked up and had them deliver and they are always fast. Friendly service too. SO happy to have this place local!
8. K & K Food Mart
Reviewed By eddie1342
The best thing about K & K is the variety, as long as you're not looking for a bargain....there's a price to be paid for "convenience". A good place to stop for a soda and/or a slice of pizza if you're in a hurry.
7. Domino's Pizza
Visit your Brockport Domino's Pizza today for a signature pizza or oven baked sandwich. We have coupons and specials on pizza delivery, pasta, buffalo wings, & more! Order online now!
Reviewed By Brett W
Needed a quick meal for me and the kids while the wife was away. I thought one large pizza and two orders of wings would be a great deal. Low price on a large pizza but an order of 8 wings costs $7.50!! And the wings must have come from baby chicks because there was very little to no meat and mostly soggy breading and sauce. Very disappointing for $25. Pizza was only so so in flavor and quality.
6. Domino's Pizza
Reviewed By eddie1342
Domino's is one of those places that makes me wonder how they stay in business......I have had many frozen pizzas that were far superior to them, as well as cheaper. They have been consistently bland throughout their existence.....I don't get it.
5. Pizza Hut
Reviewed By Andrew J
Stopped in today for lunch and the manager very rudely asked us to move away from the food bar and to go sit in the corner if we couldnt leave him in the car. I explained that we were in compliance with federal law for service animals he didn't want to hear any of it. So we left.
4. Perris Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 28 reviews
Reviewed By Robert F B
My daughter, who has lived in Brockport for three and a half years kept telling me, âDad, skip Perris Pizzaâ... OK, I didn't listen. I found out she was right!My experience was flawed in so many ways that it's unlikely I'll be going back even though I go to Brockport several times a year. Note that I said âexperienceâ. It wasn't just the food...First, let's talk about the food. While the pizza was flavorful with a decent amount of toppings, the crust must be the NY version of a Chicago-style pizza! It was about 1/3â thick! OK, the crust was nicely seasoned. But, way too thick for a NY pizza! The price was fair for a pizza. However, the wings! The wings were a bargain at six for $5.00! They were nicely sized and well cooked, but the âmediumâ sauce was too bland for my palate. I also had a cheesesteak sub which, while OK, was nothing special.Now, for the âexperienceâ, which is primarily the reason for the overall rating. First, I had to wait 45 minutes for my food at around 7:30 on a Friday evening in mid-December. Absolutely unacceptable! Second, I don't know what it is about places on Main Street in Brockport, but this is the second restaurant I've been to where I froze while inside! If there is Global Warming, I now know of two restaurants in Brockport which are not contributing to it!The only positive I can find in Perris is the late hours they keep on weekends for the students of SUNY-The College at Brockport. Between studying, partying, and... (you get the idea!), I'm sure the students appreciate the late hours for pizza delivery.As for me? I'll take my daughter's advice!
3. The Tavern 19
Overall Ratings
3 based on 51 reviews
Reviewed By Robert F B
Overall, this is going to be simply a âGoodâ and âBadâ review in terms of organization.My daughter and I had supper here on the evening of 2/15 to celebrate the great results of an exploratory medical procedure which required me to fast for over 36 hours.The Good: The food. This is without doubt, the best pizza Iâve ever had. My daughter and I had the â4 Corners Pizzaâ. My quarters were âMeat Headâ and âMushroom Madnessâ, while my daughter had the âAll Seasonsâ and âPizza Blancaâ. The pizza was absolutely excellent! Because of the fast, I also added a shrimp cocktail, which was very good, considering how far Hamlin is from the ocean. To drink, we each had a glass of Labattâs Blue on draft. Others have raved about the bread here. Theyâre right. It is indeed excellent! Once we were seated, the service was quite good.The bad: ââ¦Once we were seatedâ¦â Others have mentioned this. While their website mentions the extensive New York City culinary training the founders of Tavern 19 have had, Itâs also apparent that the âcourtesyâ too many in the service profession in the Big Apple are ârenownedâ for, also got brought in. MHO, this seemingly institutionalized wait is either a scam to try to get people to spend more money on drinks at the bar (With Lake Road being a favorite of law enforcement on Friday nightsâ¦) or is a symptom of the chronic understaffing which is so endemic of American businesses today⦠and, itâs not just restaurants! When we got there at 7:20 PM, we were told by the hostess that we would have a wait of âabout twenty minutesâ. Iâd made a mental note of the empty tables. At 8:00, my daughter and I went back into the dining room. (Weâd been in the bar area watching people enter and leave the dining room.) In a few minutes, a table which had remained empty the entire time we were waiting was suddenly âavailableâ, and we were seated.Summation. The superb quality of the food brought up the âscoreâ of the restaurant, which you see here. Had the service been better, the rating wouldâve been higher. Great service is probably the easiest thing to do in any business. But itâs increasingly becoming rare. While Hamlin is a picturesque little town, so is Brockport. And, Brockport has several pizza restaurants with commendable pizzas and much better service. If youâre not hungry and have all evening to wait, this place is worth a try. Otherwise, Iâd suggest looking elsewhere until they improve their seating wait times.
What to do and see in Hamlin, United States: The Best Places and Tips
2. Mark's Pizzeria
Reviewed By Eugene E
Mark's Pizzeria is tucked away at the N/E corner of the 19 and Roosevelt Hiway. Good prices, good service. Good pizza. Delivery is faster than most. Great for Sunday football games.
Hamlin Food Guide: 10 Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Hamlin
1. Krony's Pizza Etc
Overall Ratings
4 based on 39 reviews
Reviewed By Laurie S
We have been going here for years! Excellent food! Excellent atmosphere for dining in and excellent drive thru to pick up food on the home! The people that work there are like family. Always helpful and happy. This is the first place friends want to go when they come to visit from out of town!
