Location: Cromwell
Top Restaurants in Cromwell
Top Things to do in Cromwell
Countries
Most Popular Pizza food in Cromwell, Connecticut, United States
Find out what Pizza restaurants to try in Cromwell. Cromwell is a town in Middlesex County, Connecticut, United States located in the middle of the state. The population was 14,005 at the 2010 census.
Things to do in Cromwell
10. Joey Garlic's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 344 reviews
At Joey Garlic's, we are all about the food! Our mission to make all of our guests feel welcomed and to deliver only the best quality food combined with unmatched service. We are strong believers that no one should leave hungry under our roof! We offer ge
Reviewed By BG1212
We recently went to Joey garlics and had a really good dinner. Itâs not my choice for authentic Italian they do have better than average Italian food. The service was good there were seats available we didnât have to wait in the handicap access was excellent. A young woman was saving two seats at the bar for friends, which really is nonsense. Bartenders didnât want to interject.Thank you so much for visiting! I couldn't be happier to hear you enjoyed your dinner with us! I'm sorry if your experience was anything less than perfect in the bar area. Our bar is self-seating, and I apologize if that put a damper on your visit. I hope we will get another chance to welcome you back for another delicious meal!
9. Freddy's Pizza & Grinder
Overall Ratings
3 based on 14 reviews
Reviewed By rkstr1000
When I moved to Cromwell I searched in ever widening circles for the best pizza. After trying several targets I arrived at Freddy's way across town. Wow, great pizza. Crispy crust and loaded with ingredients. Grinders are so-so. Friday night staff is fun and friendly. Not really much of a restaurant, but just right for take-out. Arrive back home, slide pizza onto pre-heated stone, open a beer and settle down to a game with friends. Yes!Rick
8. PizzaPie
Reviewed By 430debbie
Tucked in the plaza is the most amazing place! My husband had the âTomâ Burger and I will venture to say that it is the best burger the area has to offer. Medium rare and cooked to perfection, hand made and what a flavor it had! Along with fabulous pizza and burgers they now have Gyro love which is American Mediterranean Fusion at its finest! Nothing like this in the area. Homemade pitas that are outstanding and hummus is amazing. Wide selection of foods, too many to list. Take out, delivery, etc. This place is too good to miss! The interior is warm and inviting and extremely creative as well. Donât just take my word for it but try it yourself! You wonât be disappointed. Did I forget to mention the wonderful service? This is for sure our new favorite place.
7. Mario's Pizza
Reviewed By Mike B
First timer and I was very happy. Had their roast beef grinder and it was huge alot of meat fresh bread. The service was great. They have a large slection of meals they all look wonderful.Place was very clean and bright. The help was very friendly.Will try it again
6. West Side Pizza Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 19 reviews
Reviewed By luv2vacation
We love West Side Pizza, if you like Greek pizza you will too! First off the family is wonderful and loves to get to know its customers and they remember you every time you come in!! The pizza is delicious and the amount of toppings is fantastic they do not skimp on the toppings trust me!! Also have Italian meals, salads, breads. wine, beer. Prices are very reasonable. The quality of the food, prices and great service every time makes this a frequent stop. This is not some fancy place just great food, great service, and hometown feel!!!
5. Dar Party Pizza
Reviewed By BC789
Love the pizza and salads here! My wife and I go a few times a month and have never once been disappointedThe bacon on their pizza is maple, bringing a unique flavor profile to it. I would recommend that !
4. ABC Trattoria & Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 40 reviews
Reviewed By GnMe
We're not usually that big on Italian restaurants, but this was a great discovery. Seemed very quiet; maybe it was just the midweek night. Very amiable waitress, and the giant pieces of lasagna were awesome. More than enough to share, although G added a side of sausage, which was also excellent. Homemade breads and extra sauce for dipping. I can't speak for the fish, steak, pizza... but judging by the meals we had I would bet everything here would be good. We'll definitely be back.
3. Cromwell Pizza & Pasta
Overall Ratings
4 based on 50 reviews
Conveniently located along Rt. 99 in Historic Downtown Cromwell at 307 Main Street. Cromwell Pizza & Pasta is locally owned by Fabio Lourenconi. Our establishment is a kid friendly environment to enjoy a meal with friends and family. Cromwell Pizza offers
Reviewed By GnMe
We were visiting family in the area, and our favorite pizza place across the street was closed, so we thought we'd give Cromwell Pizza a try. It was extremely busy for a Tuesday evening, both eat-in and take-away customers. It actually seemed to be more than the staff could handle. They were really hustling, to the point of getting some orders confused, and it seemed that they were trying to juggle oven space for so many pizzas. They could have taken ours out a bit sooner; it was at the point of being burnt. It wasn't bad, but not great either.Thank you for your review. I'm sorry to hear that you're experience wasn't bad nor great. Please feel free to reach out to us directly at [email protected]. Again, thank you for the review, we will work with the staff to ensure orders are handled accurately and with out your review we wouldn't know what areas of dining we need to work on. Hopefully, you'll try us again in the near future.
2. MONDO
Overall Ratings
4 based on 246 reviews
Reviewed By jetset1976
The pizza by the slice was thin and super flavored, the pepperoni was the real kind. Salads were mega sized and so was the pesto chicken panini. Service was great despite being super busy. We ate outside and main Street Middletown was pleasant. Will come back.
1. Zerio's Old World Restaurant & Catering
Overall Ratings
4 based on 58 reviews
Zerio's is a local favorite for Pizza, Soups, Salads, Paninis and Deli Sandwiches.
Reviewed By Morgan2010
I ordered a panini [actually went half-and-half with companion to to taste two]. They are enormous. Thick crusty bread, think sliced meat, cheese and sauces - all add up. The pastrami Reuben and the southwest turkey were both great. Having said that, a warning, this place is typical of so many American restaurants - give you more than you want [and should eat] and charge you accordingly. Unfortunately, this is the business model we have created by our 'love' of either 1]eating too much or 2]feeling happy when we get a doggy bag. Regardless, one delicious panini is enough for two people.
Top 10 American food in Cromwell, Connecticut, United States
