Location: Westerville
Top Restaurants in Westerville
Countries
Most Popular Italian food in Westerville, Ohio, United States
Discover Restaurants offering the best Italian food in Westerville, Ohio, United States. Westerville is a city in Delaware and Franklin counties in the U.S. state of Ohio. It is a northeastern suburb of Columbus. The population was 36,120 at the 2010 census. Westerville is the home of Otterbein University.
Things to do in Westerville
10. Carrabba's Italian Grill
Overall Ratings
4 based on 186 reviews
Reviewed By AroundNAround
We used to loved the app zucchini fritter and they quit serving it a good while back, so we havenât been back since (probably 2-3 years) and we thought weâd give it a try again. So happy to see it was back on the menu! This visit was great. The appetizer was good, the salad was the beat and my spaghetti and meatballs were perfect! Our server, Andrew, was top notch!!! So happy we decided to give it another try!
9. Antonio's Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 27 reviews
Reviewed By JimK4100
We got a carry out order of one spaghetti and meatball dinner that included a salad and one piece of garlic bread. The portions were generous so we split the order and got one extra meatball, The meatball was among the best we have eaten, the pasta and sauce were excellent.. The salad, however, was overdressed with a good dressing and there were brown spots on much of the lettuce. The prep cooks were not being attentive as that lettuce should never have been used,
8. Monte Carlo Italian Kitchen
Overall Ratings
4 based on 64 reviews
Reviewed By davidrS247PH
I ordered the meatballs as an appetizer and then the house specialty parmagina and I ordered the veal with fettuccini Alfredo side. The best part was the alfredo the veal was good but the marnia tasted like it was out of a can the meatballs were good. Service was very good
7. Buca di Beppo Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
3 based on 148 reviews
Worthington, OH is full of great attractions: The McConnell Arts Center, the historic Orange Johnson House, the Old Rectory, and everybody's favorite Italian restaurant, Buca di Beppo! As the top destination for delicious Italian pastas, entrees, and pizz
Reviewed By james6764
We decided to see what all the hype was about with this place. This was the worst Italian food I have ever had. Our server John was a mediocre server at best. Totally lacking in the social skills to be a server. I watched the bartender sit on a counter with his back to the tables so he could watch tv. Totally unethical and unprofessional. The lasagna we ordered was dried out and tasteless. The bread was edible but the olive oil tasted old. Unfortunately we should have skipped dessert. We ordered the Tiramisu, it was the worst I have ever had. It was not light and creamy like any Tiramisu is, if made correctly. This one was mushy and on the dry side. Then to top it all of it rained while we were eatting, which should have been no big deal, but when we walked out to the parking lot it was flooded in a big area where we had parked. The water was to the bottom of the doors of our car. 8 other customers witnessed this and had even commented about how ridiculous this was. My husband had to take his socks and shoes off and roll up his pant legs as best as possible to get to our car. So beware if you go while it rains, this could happen to you also. We will NEVER set foot back in this place again. james6764, we are concerned to hear this and would like to reach you. If you haven't already spoken with someone about your visit or since this review was posted, please visit bucadibeppo.com/frequently-asked-questions, and provide your contact information on our online guest review form and include the details of your experience. Upon receipt of your contact information, a member of our management team will contact you directly.
6. Pasquale's Pasta House
Overall Ratings
4 based on 76 reviews
Family owned restaurant for over 30 years, We offer pizza, pastas and other entrees. We also offer catering options for your office parties to family gatherings. We do offer beer and wine for dine in and take out. Stop by and try our pizza to see how it r
Reviewed By williammZ222ZR
Pasquale's pizza is delicious, great crust, great home made sauce and generous with any toppings you choose for your pizza. They have other Italian dishes but we always get pizza. We usually get the pizza to go, although there is a small dining room in the restaurant. Family owned and run, a great pace to get delicious pizza.
5. Cardone's Restaurant & Bar
Overall Ratings
4 based on 80 reviews
Reviewed By ChefLeigh
My husband and I eat out often and Cardone's is our #1 "go to" restaurant. Chef Dan's specials are always exciting and great. The standard Italian dishes are excellent with outstanding marinara sauce. He has a terrific scallop dish and the appetizers are first rate. I personally get the gnocchi alla Gorgonzola. We recommend Cardone's with the highest recommendation we can give.
4. Pasqualone's Ristorante
Overall Ratings
4 based on 77 reviews
upscale fine dining Italian. Destination location. reservations highly recommended. Enjoy high quality, freshly prepared Italian food by Chef and owner David Pasqualone.
Reviewed By TheWorldTraveler47
Looked online for a good Italian restaurant in Columbus area. After reading the reviews, I picked Pasqualone's. The service was very good and the food was very good as well. I thought the customer service actually was better than the food, if that is possible. The owner/cook met us at the door. My wife and I could actually hear him in the back pounding out the veal. If you have never been here, I would suggest you give it a try. Their red sauce is amazing. I got the veal. It was excellent. The peach sorbet rocks!
3. Carfagna's Kitchen
Overall Ratings
4 based on 165 reviews
Reviewed By Suzibell
Friendly staff but the food is lacking given the price point. Servings small for the price. Quality was decent and flavor ok. I think they cut a lot of corners.
2. Giammarco's Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 247 reviews
Giammarco's Italian restaurant has been offering authentic Italian cuisine like our award winning pizza and Stromboli in Westerville Ohio since 1999. We are a family owned & operated Italian restaurant that uses our age-old family recipes with only the fi
Reviewed By AWise81
My husband and I ordered carry out for his Birthday. He had the chicken parmigiana and the portion was huge and he thought it was very tasty. I ordered the Shrimp scampi and it was also delicious and the noodles were especially good. The portion however was tiny, only 3 little shrimps on a bed of noodles for $19!!! So disappointing...Thank you for your comments and Iâm sorry to hear your thoughts about our Shrimp scamp meal. Please contact me, I would like to invite you back to make things right. My name is Mo Abusido and I am the General Manager- (614) 895-8890
1. Buca di Beppo Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
3 based on 148 reviews
Worthington, OH is full of great attractions: The McConnell Arts Center, the historic Orange Johnson House, the Old Rectory, and everybody's favorite Italian restaurant, Buca di Beppo! As the top destination for delicious Italian pastas, entrees, and pizz
Reviewed By james6764
We decided to see what all the hype was about with this place. This was the worst Italian food I have ever had. Our server John was a mediocre server at best. Totally lacking in the social skills to be a server. I watched the bartender sit on a counter with his back to the tables so he could watch tv. Totally unethical and unprofessional. The lasagna we ordered was dried out and tasteless. The bread was edible but the olive oil tasted old. Unfortunately we should have skipped dessert. We ordered the Tiramisu, it was the worst I have ever had. It was not light and creamy like any Tiramisu is, if made correctly. This one was mushy and on the dry side. Then to top it all of it rained while we were eatting, which should have been no big deal, but when we walked out to the parking lot it was flooded in a big area where we had parked. The water was to the bottom of the doors of our car. 8 other customers witnessed this and had even commented about how ridiculous this was. My husband had to take his socks and shoes off and roll up his pant legs as best as possible to get to our car. So beware if you go while it rains, this could happen to you also. We will NEVER set foot back in this place again. james6764, we are concerned to hear this and would like to reach you. If you haven't already spoken with someone about your visit or since this review was posted, please visit bucadibeppo.com/frequently-asked-questions, and provide your contact information on our online guest review form and include the details of your experience. Upon receipt of your contact information, a member of our management team will contact you directly.
