Location: Sussex
Top Restaurants in Sussex
Countries
Most Popular Italian food in Sussex, New Jersey, United States
Find out what Italian restaurants to try in Sussex. Sussex is a borough in Sussex County, New Jersey, United States. As of the 2010 United States Census, the borough's population was 2,130, reflecting a decline of 15 (-0.7%) from the 2,145 counted in the 2000 Census, which had in turn declined by 56 (-2.5%) from the 2,201 counted in the 1990 Census.
Things to do in Sussex
10. Chappy's Cafe
My restaurant is based on meals that are prepared and cooked in a Home style fashion. All soups and sauce are made fresh. Every taste of My food will remind of Good Tasting Home Cooked Meal
Reviewed By Susan K
Went to Chappy's today for the first time. It is now going to be top on my list for places to go when looking for breakfast or lunch. The food is delicious and extremely reasonably priced. The service was also fantastic. Our waitress was very friendly and answered all our questions. It is great to see someone speak so highly of their place of employment and the various dishes we asked about. Basically everything is from scratch. The corned beef hash is amazing with large chunks of corned beef. The French Toast is made with their homemade bread. We enjoyed everything so much we bought food to bring home for dinner. Chicken salad sandwich with homemade bread was filled with a very tasty blend with lots of chicken. The owner also took time to chat with us which was very nice (we wish him and his wife all the best with their soon-to-arrive special deliveries!). It was truly amazing to find such high quality food and at such affordable prices. We can't wait to return! Just wish they were open at dinner too :)Thank you sooo Much!!! Good news!!!! I open on Saturday nights for Dinner starting February 2nd 2019. Hope to see you!!!
9. Z's
Reviewed By DeaconVince
My family of 8 went to Z's early since we had small children. There were only two wait staff on. We placed our drink order and it took about 15 minutes to get our drinks. We were ready to place our dinner order and the young lady said "I will be right back to take your order" 20 minutes past and we were ready to walk out and the owner heard us and she took the order 45 minutes later the order came out. My grandsons ordered Hot Dogs they were cold and they made the mistake to ask for Ketchup which never came. Most of us tasted the food but were to upset to eat. So we DID pay te bill and went to the Sussex Queen Diner.
8. Pizza Pros
Reviewed By perun99
We needed to find somewhere to eat after a day of skiing and mostly nothing else was open so we stopped in here. The staff was very nice. Even though they looked like they were about to close, they still made us a pie. The pizza itself was just ok, though my kids loved it.
7. Springs Bistro
Overall Ratings
4 based on 42 reviews
Reviewed By JerseyGirl1718
For the most part, this is a "weather permitting" restaurant since the bulk of the seating is outdoors. Views are beautiful from the terrace. Menu is a bit limited. My husband and I split appetizers. I had mozzarella and he had meatballs. Since the mozzarella was a bit dry, we ended up dipping the cheese the meatball sauce. Entrees were good-I had chicken and my husband had the steak. One negative, the wait staff brought out our entrees prior to our appetizers being finished. Dessert was good as well. I had gelato and my husband had zeppoles. We were expecting the street fair zeppoles we grew up with, but were pleasantly surprised by the presentation. The zeppoles were round, covered with cinnamon and dipped in caramel sauce. Only other negative was our attempt at an after dinner drink at the bar. Bartender was inattentive to our needs as well as to the fact that there was small child sitting at the bar. After 10 minutes waiting to get her attention, we left.
6. Pomodoro Italiano
Overall Ratings
4 based on 21 reviews
We are a family owned and oriented restaurant, with traditional, homemade cuisine. Come eat and bring the family!
Reviewed By dan9582018
Dining at Pomidoro Italiano for the very first time, we greatly enjoyed our dining experience. The Chicken Marsala, and Chicken Oreganato were simply delicious. The spaghetti side dish was cooked al dente exactly as ordered topped with a tasty marinara sauce. Hanna, our waitress, was very pleasant, knowledgeable, and attentive. We will definitely be returning to Pomidoro, and are adding this fine restaurant to our list of favorite places to dine. We were also pleasantly surprised at the reasonable cost of this delightful meal. We strongly recommend Pomidoro as a great value.We are so pleased that you enjoyed everything here at Pomodoro! We look forward to seeing you again! Go to our website to subscribe to our daily email. (Including our delicious specials!)
5. Tony's Pizza & Pasta Restaurant
Overall Ratings
5 based on 14 reviews
Reviewed By MrClarkie
Tony's pizza is great, love their veal specials, and their pasta dishes, we have been enjoying their food since we moved here, and appreciate their skill and service. Thank you
4. Pizza Station
Overall Ratings
4 based on 20 reviews
Reviewed By Baywood99
not expecting alot from a pizza place but do expect no bugs- sat at table and there was large spider web with the spiders last few catches in it- obviously has been there awhile. After this kinda lost my appetite so would not go back
3. Milano Restaurante
Overall Ratings
4 based on 148 reviews
Reviewed By T L
We are regulars at Milano's and it never disappoints! The food is fantastic, the atmosphere is warm & inviting. Best restaurant for Italian food by far. The owner Tony is a great guy and is a hands-on chef with great specials and innovative menus. Just went there for New Year's Eve and had a fabulous time with friends. You can go wrong here!
Where to eat Sushi food in Sussex: The Best Restaurants and Bars
2. Lorenzo's Pizzeria & Restaurant
Overall Ratings
3 based on 12 reviews
Reviewed By Joan F
When we lived here this place had the best pizza around. We made a trip in May , 2014 and found out Lorenzo no longer owned it. This is why the pizza is not longer that great. It was okay for a pizza place but I don't think the people that own it now are using the same recipe. The sauce was different and the cheese was not as tasty.If you like pizza it is okay. If you like really good pizza go somewhere else as this is just mediocre.
1. Frank's Pizza and Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 24 reviews
Reviewed By hallercf
A group of five descended on franks for dinner. A good sign was there was a good crowd. Service was excellent and the food exceeded expectations. We had meatball subs, calzones, and Stromboli between us. All was good, big portions but no leftovers.
