Top Restaurants in Sunnyside
Countries
Most Popular Italian food in Sunnyside, New York, United States
Discover Restaurants offering the best Italian food in Sunnyside, New York, United States including SoleLuna, Mikes Pizza, Manetta's Ristorante, Trattoria L'incontro, Oregano, Norma, Toscana 49, Fornino, Ora Di Pasta, San Matteo Pizza Espresso Bar
Things to do in Sunnyside
10. San Matteo Pizza Espresso Bar
Overall Ratings
4 based on 365 reviews
Order your favorite pizza, pasta, salad, wings and more with San Matteo Pizza & Espresso Bar located at 1739 2nd Ave in New York, NY.
Reviewed By mkd_travelmania
Pizza, and panuozzi is what youâre there for. Super yummy. Buratta is great too. Great for a casual date or a family early dinner. Unassuming, oozing with authentic Italian flavor, great service.
9. Ora Di Pasta
Overall Ratings
4 based on 197 reviews
Reviewed By MosieintheCatskills
The pastor was very good but thereâs only about 10 or 12 chairs to sit in so the atmosphere is a little lacking but the pasta is all homemade and very tasty.
8. Fornino
Overall Ratings
4 based on 235 reviews
Reviewed By Beth_sage
The place was packed, but the noise level was not too bad. The three of us ate appetizers of chickpeas, beets and eggplant bruschetta. The two pizzas were more than enough for the three of us. We finished our meal with lemon olive oil cake and strawberry sorbet
7. Toscana 49
Overall Ratings
4 based on 611 reviews
Reviewed By demeer717
The best lasagne I have ever tasted! Understated and classy restaurant with warm inviting atmosphere. I don't often return to a restaurant on a city break...but just had to! Special mention to Maria who cooed with busy bar area along with the waiters demands...always smiling
6. Norma
Overall Ratings
4 based on 172 reviews
Reviewed By CJLNYC1962
We were our for a quick easy dinner and found Norma. Professional servers, nice selection of appetizers including the nicest octopus capriccio I have had anywhere in years. Good wine selection (no hard liquor). Pizzas were exceptional. Coffee and dessert great too. Not cheap, but far from expensive. A little loud, but clean and upscale. I be back.
5. Oregano
Overall Ratings
4 based on 275 reviews
Reviewed By snilsborg
If I could give this 7-stars I would. What was supposed to be a casual birthday dinner turned into an unexpectedly amazing night.Food-wise, the four of us started with the bruschetta and mushroom apps. Both really solid. I got the oregano pizza. As a huge za'atar fan, this might have been my favorite pizza toppings-wise I've ever had. The labneh is what really pulls it together. The pizza itself was very high quality.I was sitting next to a spaghetti carbonara aficionado. Its her litmus test at every Italian restaurant (and she's been to many). She said this was top-3 in the city.The four cheese gnocchi was out of this world. I only had a bite of the birthday boy's dish, but the gnocchi melted in my mouth and the cheeses were blended to perfection.Lastly, the chicken parm was supposedly excellent as well. We were all incredibly satisfied by our meals.At the table next to us were two women who had mouth-watering looking dishes as well. One of them was controlling the music in the restaurant. I'm not entirely sure how it happened, but she put on a song we requested, and we all started clapping and then dancing. Turns out she was the owner! She refilled our drinks, and brought out a birthday tiramisu with a HUGE sparkler. Just look at how happy the birthday boy is - the picture says it all!We ended up hanging out at the restaurant for several more hours. The owner, her friend and the staff were so much fun. Even a spilt glass of red wine and a ruined dress couldn't stop us. My face actually hurt from smiling and laughing so much.It was one of those magical hospitality moments that will stick with you for a long time. I'm certain you won't replicate our experience - and frankly, we couldn't either if we tried - but no matter what, this place is worth the visit.
4. Trattoria L'incontro
Overall Ratings
4 based on 408 reviews
Zagat 2013 and Michelin Guide Recommended. Our cuisine is a combination of traditional classics and state-of-the-art fare. All of the dishes are prepared with an emphasis on using only the freshest ingredients, keeping the integrity of traditional dishes
Reviewed By AmbassadorCarl
It seems to have your typical Italian cuisine but look more closely, or better yet, ask your waiter. The off-menu dishes sometimes gravitate to the menu proper. I've had sailfish carpaccio, elk, ostrich and many game meals that were terrific.AmbassadorCarl, thanks for your review. We're glad you got the chance to stop by for a great meal. You make some great choices when it comes to selecting meals. Our sailfish is an excellent choice. We'll be here waiting when you're ready to try more off-menu items. - Chef Rocco Sacramone
3. Manetta's Ristorante
Overall Ratings
4 based on 178 reviews
Reviewed By paulamarksnyc
A quick ride from Manhattan to a delicious authentic Italian meal.Nice diverse menu with classic and creative items, well priced with good portions.Attentive pleasant wait staff.Good reasonable wine list.We chose the front room as it was quieter and allowed for lively conversation.Will definitely return.
2. Mikes Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 206 reviews
Reviewed By JohnM627
We walked here from our hotel to check it out. Wow, this food is great! And affordable. Their menu offers a lot. From chicken sandwiches and burgers to individual pizza slices or order a whole pizza. We got a couple meat Jamaican pockets. Those were excellent!! They have tables here if you want to eat in.
What to do and see in Sunnyside, United States: The Best Places and Tips
1. SoleLuna
Overall Ratings
5 based on 85 reviews
Reviewed By Frank I
A friend of mine recommended SoleLuna about a month ago. I rarely frequent restaurants in Sunnyside, so this would be something different. I must say, I am glad a friend recommended this restaurant. The food and service were spectacular. The wine list is surprisingly very good with a fine variety of reds, whites and rose and sangria. The food was exceptional. It felt like we were eating homemade family made Italian Food. The staff was very friendly and attended to all our needs. Marcello, our server, went out of his way to please our party. Highly recommend. Give it a try
Sunnyside Food Guide: 10 Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Sunnyside
