Location: Pickerington
Top Restaurants in Pickerington
Top Things to do in Pickerington
Countries
Most Popular Italian food in Pickerington, Ohio, United States
Best Italian restaurants nearby. Discover the best Italian food in Pickerington. View Menus, Photos and Reviews for Italian restaurants near you.. Pickerington is a city in Fairfield and Franklin counties in the central region of the U.S. state of Ohio. It was founded in 1815 as Jacksonville. Pickerington was known as Jacksonville until 1827, when the citizens petitioned the state legislature to change the name to Pickerington in honor of its founder, Abraham Pickering. It is a suburb of Columbus. The population was 18,291 at the 2010 census. As land annexation, development, and immigration into the Columbus area continues, the city of Pickerington (like many area suburbs) has generally followed suit. Pickerington is also home to the Motorcycle Hall of Fame, located at 13515 Yarmouth Dr. off Interstate 70.
Things to do in Pickerington
10. Vick's Gourmet Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 54 reviews
Reviewed By travelbug222910
Good prices, service, and portion sizes, would definitely recommend if you were going we a group because the portions can be split. The pizza was average, but they have some specialty pizzas that sounded really interesting and I will definitely return to give those a try.
9. Olive Garden
Overall Ratings
3 based on 64 reviews
Reviewed By W8807FWjohne
We ate dinner with a friend on Sunday and the place was busier than expected. The server was friendly. Upon ordering she apologized for not having any salad options available due to a recall on Romaine lettuce only. The kale and sausage was disappointing with more potatoes that the titled ingredients. The salmon entree was average. The chicken margarita had hard to cut meat. The food at the Panera next door is better. All OG restaurants have annoying digital video devices on the tables, which most customers pointed away from their tables. Our server used the device to process our payment with a recommended tip % shown but we prefer to make our own tip decision. The server also proceeded to ask several rating questions - uncomfortable and awkward.
8. Cardo's Pizza & Tavern
Full Service Restaurant with Bar. 20+ taps with your favorite local and national craft beers. Largest Patio/Bar in Pickerington, Live entertainment weekly, Pizza and a whole lot more on the menu, Kid friendly and mother approved. Many large TV's with your
Reviewed By lindacrick
Great pizza. Visited on a Saturday night. Very odd clientel. EXTREMELY LOUD country band. Their music was good but SO LOUD for the space. Very kicked back, casual almost grubby place. Groups of families with small kids and singles and red-neck types and couples . People looked tired and worn out. Lots of drinking and KENO. DARK and LOUD. Impossible to enjoy the company you were with. Seemed to be trying to be too many things to too many different types of people.
7. Donatos Pizza
Overall Ratings
3 based on 14 reviews
Donatos is a family-owned pizza company famous for Edge to Edge® toppings on a crispy golden thin crust. Founded in Columbus, Ohio in 1963, we take pride in giving back in every community we serve.
Reviewed By Beautycole
I always get the same thing, bug don on white with sausage (well done) only extra dressing on the side and a pizza. Been ordering from the pickerington location over 5 years. 9 times out of ten its wrong. I usually call, but haven't last two times. Last night sasuge was not well done, few days ago no sasuge at all and dressing was on the sub. Once they gave my ranch dressing. I've ordered the spicy jack before and it clearly was not made with peper jack cheese and half had no sasuge. I love the food so much I keep ordering, however i wish they could get my order right.
6. Pizzeria New York
Overall Ratings
4 based on 19 reviews
Reviewed By Patrice417
As an east coast transplant, I thank God for Pizzeria NY! There must be at least 50 pizza places in and around Pickerington, most of which are chains. I'm telling you people, this is the real deal! Home made, thin crust that is crispy on the edges and chewy throughout, delicious homemade sauce and tons of cheese. AND they cut it in pie shaped slices instead of postage stamp sized squares. I don't know about you, but i can handle a full slice of pizza! Strombolis and subs are to die for. I can't understand for the life of me why anyone would go to a chain and get a mediocre pizza when this little gem is right in Picktown.
5. Genuwine's Vintage Dining
Overall Ratings
4 based on 12 reviews
Reviewed By Mikeshy
My wife, our granddaughter and I went to Genuwineâs for dinner. This was a delightful experience. We started with a reasonably priced bottle of Barbara dâ Alba that was very good. Our server was Kathryn and she made some excellent recommendations in addition to providing good service. We also ordered the Burrata Bowl as a starter. It was large, hot and tasty with a really nice marinara sauce. Our granddaughter ordered the soup of the day which was a roasted red pepper and smoked Gouda cheese soup. It was very good with a distinctly Smokey taste. It was served nice and hot. For entreeâs, our granddaughter had the braised beef tortellini. It was awesome! My wife had the fried eggplant parmigiana with four cheeses. It was good! Not great. I had the chicken Sicily which was also excellent. It had breast of chicken, hot Italian sausage and sun dried tomatoes in a delicious sauce. Finally, for desert, we had the white chocolate ravioli. It was also excellent. We also enjoyed having the opportunity to talk with John and Lucy, the owners. This was a wonderful evening.
4. Reitano's Pizza
Check out our website for our menu! Pizzeria, Pizza, Sunday Bar, Subs, Donuts, Pasta, Dinner, Lunch, Family Food Favorites, Ice Cream, Salads, Specialty Pizza, Appetizers, Children Menu, Draft Beer. And more!
Reviewed By Cleanhotels
We live in Pickerington and had never gone. We found a groupon, $40 voucher for $24. Couldn't pass it up. We ordered 2 large pizzas and a 2 liter of sprite for carry out. (1 pepperoni and 1 sausage and banana peppers.) All for our $24 voucher. It would have been $35. Pretty good deal. We had 4 adults and 2 kids and it was plenty. Everyone said it was good. They have a mix of provalone and mozzarella cheese, the sauce was sweet but not overly. The sausage was italian style. We were suprised, very good stuff. We will definitely be back, give them a try and don't forget to check out the deal on groupon.
3. Pizza Cottage
Overall Ratings
4 based on 59 reviews
Looking for some delicious and fresh pizza? Look no further! There's nothing better than fresh, hand-tossed pizza and our pizza restaurant is made with the freshest ingredients. We are proud to offer our community the best! We also offer other delicious d
Reviewed By Cleanhotels
They don't deliver to individual addresses but do have a drive thru window. Convenient for pick up. Most people go for pizza, which is good but we love their spaghetti and meatballs. We always ask for extra sauce, which is very good. The dinner comes with 2 large meatballs, a big salad and large piece of toasted/buttered sub bun. The spaghetti is regular size, not angel hair. The sauce is sweet but not overly. The meatballs are tender and have a great flavor. We split two spaghetti dinners between two adults and a 10 and 12 year old. All of which are hearty eaters. It's plenty. Or you can always opt to add a couple more meatballs to your order. Can't say enough good about the flavor. Staff are prompt at the window and pleasant on the phone. Two spaghetti dinners AND a dessert pizza for $24. Good value for dinner for four, including dessert. Give them a try.
2. Scali Ristorante
Overall Ratings
4 based on 149 reviews
Reviewed By LG L
The food here is amazing....all of it! From the bread, to stuffed mushrooms, so yummy. The chicken parmesan was tender and perfectly seasoned, the fettuccini alfredo was an upcharge.but worth it. The manicotti was extremely good too and the pizza! Ooh my gosh, big enough to feed two or three people. The leftovers were very tasty the next day too. We will definitely return.
1. Omezzo Restaurant and Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 79 reviews
Reviewed By AngeloS160
This little, very non-descript Italian place serves it's food up well and with a level of authenticity. Even though it is tucked into a strip mall, the restaurant itself is very welcoming and comfortable. The food is very well prepared with a slight flair and will not disappoint. The night we were in with another couple it was relatively slow (only about half full), but the staff was still paying attention like it was an extremely busy evening. The staff was relatively on top of things (I would have liked them to know their wines a bit better), but they were very discreet and made sure we were taken care of. If you are looking for a place that will serve authentic meals in a quiet and comfortable atmosphere, this is it.
