Location: New Hartford
Top Restaurants in New Hartford
Countries
Most Popular Italian food in New Hartford, New York, United States
Best Italian restaurants nearby. Discover the best Italian food in New Hartford. View Menus, Photos and Reviews for Italian restaurants near you.. Paul Miscione
Things to do in New Hartford
10. Trattoria Calabria
Overall Ratings
5 based on 105 reviews
Reviewed By unclejosh
Another wonderful meal with Danny. The homey atmosphere and amazing homemade food are complimented by the warm welcome from the owner. If you are wondering about this place just call for a reservation and prepare to enjoy the experience. It is somewhat akin to a big family meal at your eccentric uncles house. The food appears at a leisurely pace and while there are many courses you will enjoy the opportunity for conversation with your dinner companions. This is a unique dining experience that you shouldn't miss!
9. Delmonico's Italian Steakhouse
Overall Ratings
4 based on 779 reviews
Reviewed By Sandman3858
Blah, blah, blah. So does Syracuse, Albany, and Rochester, and..... That said, this heavily themed Italian themed restaurant that I visit.... only once a year.... IS very good. Food portions are tasty and ample, the service is very good, and it is an inviting, attractive, and clean business. My only gripe is that the dinners are a bit pricey considering a side salad is not included. Substituting a vegetable....even a cheap, white, baked potato for cheap, white pasta or vice-versa will cost you a couple extra bucks in some cases. I substituted a few stalks of asparagus for the cheap, white pasta and is was two bucks extra. That's nickel and diming customers. Again, I rate this place VERY GOOD....and again, Utica has sooo many good restaurants. Be sure to try the others. I do.
8. Tom Cavallo's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
3 based on 126 reviews
Reviewed By bryan377
I've had an association with this pub that lasts decades. If you live in the Utica area, this is where you go. It's a local gathering place. I often joke that the waitresses here have a little attitude, but they are usually in the midst of heavy volume. My family likes Italian food and chicken fingers and pub foods. Given the wide bredth of menu choices, there is something for everyone. Between friends and family, the opinion of the food here differs significantly. Most of our extended family sees it as good. I always like the food here, I can't say I love it. I think you need to try it and see where your tastes lie. I see this as a reliable and affordable Utica Mainstay. If you are local, you are likely to see someone you know. For that reason, a visit always feels like a return home. No matter how you look at it, it's worth a visit and then you can draw your conclusion.
7. Ancora!
Overall Ratings
4 based on 169 reviews
Featuring Mediterranean-inspired, mouth-watering cuisine, including a signature select tapas menu, Ancora! Italian restaurant will have you begging for more. Shared with friends or cherished alone, Ancora! is the ideal complement to any evening. Onsite an
Reviewed By Kesslane
We had the pris fixe selections and each selection was delicious. Service was tremendous and the ambiance relaxed but elegant.
6. Bella Cucina Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 48 reviews
Reviewed By BASTripper
It was Friday night and we were a travel weary family. We entered Bella Cucina and was immediately energized by the beautiful decor and welcoming greeting. The food was delicious, the service was attentive and the evening was truly delightful. This is the perfect restaurant for all and especially for those on the college hunt.
5. Cafe del buono
Overall Ratings
4 based on 69 reviews
Reviewed By Lori12309
My husband, sister and I brought Mom here to celebrate Momâs 87th birthday yesterday. We all really liked the menu and three of us had to consult the waitress for her recommendations, which she was happy to provide.Mom ordered a Reuben, Hubs a fish fry dinner, I a Café burger and my sister hit the jackpot with a crabcake served on crispy spinach from the appetizer menu.All our meals and accompanying sides (especially the coleslaw) were delicious. The service was friendly and attentive and quick and the check (four ample meals, three bottles of Saranac Legacy ale and a glass of Pinot Grigio) at $70 before tip represented a good value. The restaurant is a little noisy, but itâs an excellent spot for lunch with family or friends if not a romantic rendezvous.
4. Michael T's Italian-American Specialties
Overall Ratings
4 based on 59 reviews
Michael T's Restaurant is a local family-owned Italian restaurant in New Hartford, New York - serving delicious Italian dishes and drinks in the Mohawk Valley! Since 1983, we've created and served favorites like chicken riggies, greens and even seafood di
Reviewed By Colleen_QZ
Casual friendly environment. We were seated immediately. I donât mind waiting if I have a drink while we sit and talk, however it was a wait for the waitress to come over and then about 10-15 minutes for our drinks to come. Our table was clean, however there were a lot of flies, dead and alive around our table. The wine list and dessert menus at our table were dirty, with sauce and other things on them, had not been cleaned in a long while. The bread is low quality. My riggies were very good. I prefer a thinner sauce without dairy, however my husbandâs pasta sauce was even richer with more dairy and he loved it so thatâs just a personal preference. Our waitress was very nice and very busy. The prices and portions were very good.
Where to eat Mediterranean food in New Hartford: The Best Restaurants and Bars
3. Cafe Canole
Overall Ratings
4 based on 77 reviews
Reviewed By c9284
This restaurant has it all. There was about 25 of us. Cafe CaNole ......They went out of there way to accommodate us and seat us. The food was amazing...... perfect salad. Thank goodness. No iceberg lettuce....pasta and meatball. Wow. I thought I was in Italy. The chicken. Perfect!! This was my first time there. They are priced just right. I am in love with the restaurant. If I can give them 25 star rating I would
Top 5 Lebanese food in New Hartford, New York, United States
2. Carmella's Cafe
Overall Ratings
4 based on 135 reviews
Reviewed By teena1014
Havenât been here in about 20 years and was startled that is hasnât changed one bit! Even the same things were hanging on the wall. The food was mediocre, at best. The haddock Florentine was tasteless. I ordered a wine and she brought me two... 2 for 1. Who brings two to the table like that?!Anyway, I wonât ever try again.
1. Georgio's Village Cafe
Overall Ratings
4 based on 201 reviews
Reviewed By Joanne A
We were visiting Utica and my cousin and her husband, who come here frequently, took us here. The service was excellent and the atmosphere was quiet enough so we could converse and hear each other. My husband had the rigatoni with a meatball and ate every last bite. I shared the greens with my cousin and the flavor was great and I kept eating them even though the hot peppers were just a bit too hot for me. I ordered the tortellini alfredo and couldn't finish it all. My cousin had the pasta viola and her husband had one of the specials of the day. We ended up taking home some of my cousin's pasta viola, half of the greens and some of my tortellini. I was sorry that we were leaving the next day and would miss out on the leftovers!
Best Middle Eastern food near New Hartford, New York, United States
