Location: New Castle
Top Restaurants in New Castle
Countries
Most Popular Italian food in New Castle, Indiana, United States
Find out what Italian restaurants to try in New Castle. New Castle is a city in Henry County, Indiana, 44 miles (71 km) east-northeast of Indianapolis, on the Big Blue River. The city is the county seat of Henry County. New Castle is home to New Castle Fieldhouse, the largest high school gymnasium in the world. The city is surrounded by agricultural land. In the past, it was a manufacturing center for the production of sheet iron and steel, automobiles, caskets, clothing, scales, bridges, pianos, furniture, handles, shovels, lathes, bricks, and flour.
Things to do in New Castle
1. Primo
Overall Ratings
4 based on 31 reviews
Reviewed By Gma4198
We were in New Castle for the Broad Street Cruise In. While looking at all the cars, trucks, and motorcycles, we saw Primo's and decided to go there for dinner. All went well - got our drinks and appetizer quickly. Then waited, and waited, and waited for our food for a party of 4. After 45 minutes, and seeing another party seated, served, and nearly finished, I found the server and asked about our food and she said it was "next up". Another 10-15 minutes later, we got our food - two primo salads, and two flatbread sandwiches. The food was very good (loved the bleu cheese vinaigarette dressing on the Primo salad). A few minutes later, our server came over and said since she had to cover the bar too, she failed to get our order into the kitchen in a timely manner and brought over two slices of cake on the house (can recommend the lemon blueberry cake!). That was nice, but she really should have come over as soon as she realized our order was not put in, and offer a cup of soup or something. So if I could, I would give separate ratings of the food vs. the service. We would try this restaurant again to try one of the pasta entrees, and hope that our first experience was just a fluke.
2. Mancino's Pizza and Grinders
Overall Ratings
4 based on 26 reviews
Reviewed By JpDrumr
This isn't the easiest place to find, for travelers, as it sits back in a strip center. (It is basically next to TACO BELL.) This Mancino's pizza is, as it is everywhere, GREAT. Mancino's facilities are different, and this one had the good food, in an OK facility. The "locals filled" the place, which was an endorsement, to me.
3. Pizza King
Overall Ratings
4 based on 15 reviews
Reviewed By hawkedd
I have eaten at the Top Hat (Pizza King on Broad St.) for a long time. Since the days when it was an old fashioned drive in.The supreme pizza is what you must try. It was made this way many years before the name Pizza King entered the fray. Piles of great toppings that is best eaten hot. The service (it is a walk in restaurant now) is usually pretty good although when it is crowded it may get a little slow as it seems that they are always understaffed. Their other food is good as well but almost everyone goes for the pizza. Nothing fancy, just good pizza that will make you want to come back again and again.If you lump the Top Hat in with the other Pizza Kings it is the best, period.Ate there last a few weeks ago.
New Castle Food Guide: 10 Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in New Castle
4. Pizza King
Reviewed By KeyLimeKottage
Let me just say that I grew up in New Castle Indiana. I spent many times at Pizza King on Broad St. This particular Pizza King on State Road 3 did not exist when I lived there. I had not been back there for several years but was dreaming of my favorite pizza ever. Once I drove into town this was my first stop. I was with a friend of mine from High School so we stopped to have a late lunch. We ordered a large pizza. Half Royal Feast and half Pepperoni. OMG! It was so crispy, flavorful and OH SO WONDERFUL. These pizzas are not greasy. They are so good. My favorite in the world. The Royal Feast has pepperoni, sausage, onions, green peppers and mushrooms. The pepperoni is so full of flavor and is amazing. No matter what kind of pizza you like you cannot go wrong at this place.
What to do and see in New Castle, United States: The Best Places and Tips
