Top Restaurants in Middletown
Top Things to do in Middletown
Countries
Most Popular Italian food in Middletown, Pennsylvania, United States
Find out what Italian restaurants to try in Middletown including Fenicci's of Hershey, The Soda Jerk Diner & Dairy Bar, J & J Pizza & Family Restaurant, Roberto's
Things to do in Middletown
1. Fenicci's of Hershey
Overall Ratings
4 based on 2757 reviews
Herhey's Oldest Free Standing Restaurant. A local favorite for 83+ years. Featuring our Famous DeAngelis Spaghetti Sauces & our Famous Upside Down Pizza. Homemade, delicious Italian Dishes, featuring Seafoods, Steaks and Pasta. Full pub menu & sandwich se
Reviewed By Al G
While on vacation my wife invited some high school friends and their spouses to have lunch. We chose this restaurant because it was listed as a favorite for locals serving good Italian food. It was 6 people in our group, one of the meals (Stromboli) came out burnt and black. Our guest didn't complain. After we left we went back a day later to speak with Manager Aubrey and she promised us she would make it right and asked for the contact name for the couple. We gave her the contact information and to date she has not contacted them. Also service was not up to par. The restaurant was not very busy and it took forever to get served. Our server and trainee were very inattentive, Erin and Jasmine.Thank you for throwing my servers under the bus. Not necessary and also if you let us k now your food was more well done than you like we would correct it. I am sorry that Aubrey did not follow up perhaps a mistake and thank you again for naming the manager in a public forum, fair Al G if you want to do the same.. Wow Sorry but I have nothing more to say except give people feed back day of Jasmine has not worked for us for 3 months. !! let me include that as well
2. The Soda Jerk Diner & Dairy Bar
Overall Ratings
4 based on 616 reviews
Reviewed By Debra W
6 in our party. Nice variety on the menu. Able to get breakfast at 11:30am. Two of us had omelets, others had not roast beef sandwiches, Turkey dinner. We were very pleased with the great service and fast arrival of ourfood. Will definitely go there again!
3. J & J Pizza & Family Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 42 reviews
Reviewed By M2Denis
I had a Delicious and hot off the grill chicken sub. Quick service. Italian cuisine of pizza , salads and subs. Large selection and will customize orders. Loads of beverages to select from soda/ice tea to beer. Clean dining area with televisions. Family owned and friendly staff make it a great place for kids or a business lunch. Takeout available. Daily specials too. Located on route 230 in Middletown and easy to find. Good eats!
4. Roberto's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 19 reviews
Reviewed By MrsG262
We love the sauce on the pizza. Subs are good too. Reasonable pricing for pizza and subs. Easy to find location on the main street of the downtown area. Eat in and take out and delivery available, also serves beer. Family friendly, quick service.Can order on line.
