Location: Mayfield Heights
Top Restaurants in Mayfield Heights
Top Things to do in Mayfield Heights
Countries
Most Popular Italian food in Mayfield Heights, Ohio, United States
Find out what Italian restaurants to try in Mayfield Heights. Mayfield Heights is a city in Cuyahoga County, Ohio, United States, and is an east-side suburb of Cleveland. The population was 18,827 at the 2010 census.
Things to do in Mayfield Heights
10. Jet's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 21 reviews
Reviewed By Lynnie T
The competition for business, to obtain and keep customers, is fierce Why go to a place or order from an establishment that has a nasty attitude, when you have thousands of dozens of different ways to put a decent meal together. Since my wife gets a lot of food for different places where she works, she is able to sample and see for herself, what she may or may not like. And there are more than enough places in the area that deliver. Here comes Jetâs Pizza. Iâm going to be honest, I never even heard of Jetâs Pizza. But they have a large variety of pizzas to choose from. They have wings, and salads, bread sticks too.. We happened to have salads. The Greek salad and the Antipasto salad. Nice portion and the salads were fresh. Both my wife and I, had some of both. I would have been happy with either one, but I didnât mind sharing.
9. Pizzazz Pizza & Dining Room
Overall Ratings
4 based on 43 reviews
Reviewed By Caribbeandan
I had not been back to this restaurant in over 7 years. It was just as good now as before. There were a nice selection of beers. But, the food was excellent. I had the Veal Parmesan and it was as good as before. The excellent sauce is what made it! And our server was absolutely excellent in all respects!!!
8. Guiseppeâs Pizza & Subs
Overall Ratings
4 based on 10 reviews
Reviewed By Caribbeandan
While traveling in Cleveland, we ordered a Sicilian pizza and subs a few times. We also had a Sicilian pizza for the Super Bowl in February. All were fantastic with delicious sauce. It is strictly pick-up or delivery. Employees are extremely friendly. I'll be there again upon my return to the east side of Cleveland.
7. Gaetano's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 18 reviews
Reviewed By Lawrence K
Hadn't eaten here in years and someone recently recommended it. Was going to another place nearby which was closed so we dropped in here...for the last time. The place wasn't busy at 6:30 but the waitress rushing us to order...maybe they close early. She brought bread with was large slices of white doughy with a thin crust, which I peeled off and ate....the rest unappetizing. I had a tomato salad with onions and some sort of oil & vinegar sauce...tomatoes were run of the mill. Then we shared a luke warm lasagna....not that appetizing. Thought Karen liked their Italian wedding soup. This restaurant would not be our choice or recommendation.....sorry to say.
6. Mario Fazio's Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 194 reviews
We are the original Mario Fazio's love is all around you, fresh seasonal food a great value. Family owned and operated for 46 years.
Reviewed By KFCincy26
My dad and I go to Cleveland every few months and wusually have dinner with his college friend who lives in Mentor while we're there. We're all Italian so we like to find a different Italian restaurant to try and Mario Fazio's was convenient for everyone. It did not disappoint one bit. Even though it was our first time, Lisa (the owner's daughter I believe) made us feel like regulars. We an appetizer, salads, and dinners and it was a ton of food! The Stuffed Hot Peppers weren't exactly stuffed peppers. They were two full links of delicious and perfectly cooked Italian sausage covered in hot peppers, sauce, and cheese. The two older guys had the Eggplant Terrine which was very good and not mushy at all. I had the Doreen's Pasta, which was easily the best dish I've ever had in an Italian restuarant. Our server, Jamie, was very friendly and attentive but also gave us our space.If you ever find yourself around Cleveland and want good Italian, go to Mario Fazio's.
5. crostatas rustic pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 80 reviews
Reviewed By jerryr111
Getting desperate for decent Pizza after having had some of the best on the east coast, we remembered this restaurant that originally was a converted Arabica coffee house. We knew the family name that owned it since it was one of the premiere restaurateurs in the Cleveland area so we decided to give it a shot. Were we ever pleased that we made that choice. The pizza was as good if not better that our East coast experiences and the Ravioli was wonderful. If you have room after your meal and even if you have to take it out, order the Nutella calzone or the Napoleon....you won't be sorry.
4. Arrabiata's Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 49 reviews
Reviewed By Kaufman804
This is a small, welcoming red sauce Italian restaurant in Mayfield Heights. Full bar, ample parking. A lower price menu available until 6:30- full meal most under $20.00. Can also share regular entrees for a $3.00 charge. Service quite good. No complaints.5 of 6 very happy with dinner. Mussels and pasta a bit disappointing.
3. Alfredo's at the Inn Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 97 reviews
Alfredo's at the Inn is a Cleveland restaurant tradition in great Italian and American dining for over 40 years. Alfredo's is located inside the Holiday Inn Cleveland - Mayfield in quaint Mayfield Village. We specialize in pasta, veal, chicken ,seafood, s
Reviewed By meeko-rtw
Surprisingly descent, delicious, old school Italian- American food. Serving all your Italian favourites from long ago, pastas, pizzas, parmigiana, Marsala, something for everyone. Dinners served with with nice warm Italian rolls and house salad. Service was excellent, being efficient and friendly.
What to do and see in Mayfield Heights, United States: The Best Places and Tips
2. Master Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 36 reviews
Cleveland's original pizza chain. Serving Award Winning Pizza since 1955.
Reviewed By mr3putt33
Stopped in while I was in the area visiting a family member at the hospital across the street. I ordered a 1/2 pound of wings and a medium pizza with two toppings. The total came to around $22.00. I waited about 15/20 minutes for my carry out order. The pizza was pretty good but not worth the price. Somehow my 1/2 pound of wings for $5.99 equaled five very small wings. The store was very clean, just over priced.
Mayfield Heights Food Guide: 10 Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Mayfield Heights
1. Piccolo
Overall Ratings
4 based on 133 reviews
Reviewed By WHS-Eagle
Piccolo is a small restaurant which evidently enjoys a repeat clientele. We split an entree, Penne Arrabiata, and an accompanying Panzanella Salad, both excellent, although the arrabbiata was a bit mild. We added an order of two meatballs - tasted like the meatballs from a neighborhood in Chicago -- excellent. We finished splitting an order of spumoni, very smooth and creamy. Everything was accompanied by a nice Montepulciano. Our server was friendly, efficient and knowledgeable.
