Location: Marlboro
Top Restaurants in Marlboro
Countries
Most Popular Italian food in Marlboro, New York, United States
Discover Restaurants offering the best Italian food in Marlboro, New York, United States. Marlboro is a hamlet (and census-designated place) in Ulster County, New York, United States. The population was 3,669 at the 2010 census.
Things to do in Marlboro
10. Antonella's Pizzeria & Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 39 reviews
Reviewed By iLOV3F00D
It is a very large pizza place. They serve slices at lunch. The lasagna pizza is amazing and one slice will fill you for lunch. They heat it quick and are very friendly.
9. Il Barilotto
Overall Ratings
4 based on 301 reviews
Reviewed By Duane L
First visit. Food was excellent, wine was excellent, service was superb. We took Dan's recommendations and had no regrets. Specials were wonderful. I highly recommend it. Space is a bit tight, and room is loud. Nevertheless, it was not uncomfortable. In an area filled with wonderful restaurants, it is hard to choose a favorite, but we'll be back here again. Go early, however, unless you don't mind waiting. Bar is nice but it was packed when we left.
8. Gino's Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 46 reviews
Reviewed By tmvait
We love this place. The food (everything on the menu) is delicious. The service impeccable. The only downside is there is no inconspicuous/subtle waiting area so the entire time youâre eating it is under the watchful yearning eyes of diners that are impatiently waiting for a table in the small 14 table place. Go anyway during not so busy times.
7. Longobardi's Restaurant and Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 124 reviews
Reviewed By Nonnap
Lived in the area my entire life but this was first time at Longobardi's...so dark every time we pass by we always thought it was another closed pizza joint. Took relatives to dinner there since someone told hubby it was good. First thing we noticed were the highly inflated prices for a pizza joint. Bread and 3 pieces of bruschetta were brought to the table. We ordered fried calamari for an appetizer. All rings and they were so tough and chewy. Worse fried calamari we have ever had. One person had stuffed shells with meatballs. The two meatballs were huge but tasteless and she said she has had much better Italian food. Two others had spaghetti with marinara sauce. Simple enough but spaghetti was overcooked and the sauce had chunks of tomato and had too much acidity. Here is the reason for only one star. I went to ladies room before we left and much to my surprise the one bottle of soap there was EMPTY!!! All I could think of was how many of the female employees had used the facilities without washing their hands!!!!! I could not get out of there fast enough. Thankfully I always have a small hand sanitizer attached to my purse!! No, we will not be back due to the highly inflated prices for ordinary Italian food and the seemingly unsanitary restroom. There are too many really good Italian restaurants in the area that serve much better food at more reasonable prices.
6. Stephano's Ristorante
Overall Ratings
4 based on 128 reviews
Reviewed By Gypsgris
I and my wife did not like the main dish very much. I had the Spaghetti alla vongole, a dish I usually love. And the sauce and vongole were good. But the pasta was cheap pasta from a box and overcooked. I definitely can do a better job at home. My wife told me that her chicken was dry and the pasta boring. The bread, when it finally came (the server seemed a bit overwhelmed) was very good. If you order wine by the glass you get a large glass full. But as with the dishes it is quantity not quality. The restaurant was a bit loud in the beginning, better after some people left. The atmosphere is more functional than cozy.Overall, I do not recommend this place, if you are looking for good food. But if you are starving, this might be your place.
5. Aroma Osteria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 248 reviews
Reviewed By nor1234569
Something has changed in Aroma. I've been there at least a dozen times over the last couple of years and unfortunately I won't be returning after this visit. The short story-the entree's didn't arrive until 7:40 pm on a 5:30 pm reservation!! And although management walked by our empty table numerous times, no one even noticed! We arrived on time at 5:30 pm and were quickly seated. We received our glasses of water. Nothing else until 6 pm when I finally asked for a basket of bread. This should have been my first clue. The bread didn't arrive until 6:10pm. At which time I asked to place the appetizer order. I was told that they were too busy to take separate orders for appetizers. Ok fine! At 6:25 our appetizer and dinner orders were taken. 35 minutes later, at 7:00 pm, we asked if the appetizers were coming! At this point we have now been seated for 1.5 hours. There were at least 9 tables around us and all had received their appetizers, dinners and some were on dessert. Appetizers come and are picked up from the table at 7:15 or so.. At 7:30pm - we ask where our entree's are. "We're very busy" we're told. "Five minutes" we were told. But by now every table around had appetizers, dinner, dessert and left! And most of those people came in after us. The 7:30pm crowd was now being seated and we are still waiting for our entrees. During this entire time the manager and hostess, as well as the waitress, walked by this circular table sitting in the middle of the room with a party of 5 and NO ONE every even noticed that we were sitting there for 1.5 hours; most of the time with just glasses of water in front of us. Finally at 7:40 they told us our entree's are on their way. At this point its too late to go anywhere else and we are all sooo hungry. 3 of the 5 entree's arrive at 7:40! Then 1 at 7:45 and finally the last arrives at 7:48pm. For a 5:30 reservation?? Seriously?? All the apologies in the world cannot make up for this! All the time they claimed they were very busy but that doesn't make sense when all the other tables around us were being turned! The truth is that the waitress probably never put in our order at all!! Furthermore, management, who had walked by us a dozen times, didn't even notice. Shame on you Aroma! If I'm paying top dollar for a restaurant I expect top service and good quality of food. I got neither! Yes something has changed at Aroma and its not good!
4. Marlo Pizzeria
Reviewed By IIbeach1
We've all picked up a fresh pizza box, and we all know what it feels like. Warm on the bottom, fragrant, and a certain weight. When I picked up my pizza at Marlo, I thought the box must be empty. It was too light. There was very little to it. Not enough dough, not enough cheese, not enough tomato sauce, not enough of anything. It didn't taste bad, it just was not enough of anything.
3. Tosi's pizzeria & restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 10 reviews
Reviewed By IIbeach1
I remember getting takeout pizza here a few years ago and being quite impressed with the flavor. Not so recently. The crust was dry and chalky, and the toppings were sparse. I have not recently tried the sandwiches or meals here, but good pizza is fundamental, and they must get that right. I'll probably try it again, but there are enough other good choices around that if it's not improved, I will stay away.
2. Pizza Town
Overall Ratings
4 based on 22 reviews
Reviewed By NySnoopy
Pizza town is one of the best pizza places I have ever been to. I literally drive by a number of other pizza places to get here but will continue to do it as long as I can !! Absolute perfection
1. Paradiso Pizza Parlour
Overall Ratings
4 based on 29 reviews
Reviewed By TANSBFl
We were in the area visiting our daughter, and remembering the good food we had here the last time about a year ago, decided to order out again. This time we ordered the large calzone....and it certainly was large! It came in a pizza box, and filled up most of the box. Tow of us ate it for dinner with an antipasto salad. And then three of us finished it for lunch a couple of days later. Both the calzone and antipasto salad were Very good, however the antipasto is not on the menu...we ask for it special, and it's great!So again, I have to give this food two thumbs up!
