Location: Long Valley
Top Restaurants in Long Valley
Top Things to do in Long Valley
Countries
Most Popular Italian food in Long Valley, New Jersey, United States
Discover Restaurants offering the best Italian food in Long Valley, New Jersey, United States. Long Valley is an unincorporated community and census-designated place (CDP) located within Washington Township, in Morris County, New Jersey, United States. Known as German Valley from its foundation during the colonial era, the community was renamed in response to anti-German sentiment during World War I. As of the 2010 United States Census, the CDP's population was 1,879.
Things to do in Long Valley
10. Valentino's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 18 reviews
Reviewed By bagginsnoggin
All I have to say about this place is, I've been here quite a few times over the past 2 years and they never seem to disappoint. Polite and friendly employees, nice tv with sports on, good food selection, decent food price, and excellent food.
9. Giuseppes Trattoria
Overall Ratings
3 based on 20 reviews
Reviewed By Dreijunge
Been going here for years. A great family owned place near Shop Rite. Everything is delicious-from the pizza to the veal dishes.
8. Roman Pizza
Reviewed By Pete C
This pizza is horrendous. When you walk into this restaurant you smell an odor that is absolutely foul. The carpets were stained and filthy. Never again will I return.
7. Pasta Grill by Enzo
Overall Ratings
4 based on 39 reviews
Authentic Italian cuisine with a modern flare using fresh, quality ingredients!
Reviewed By EV8
Don't be fooled if the parking lot isnt full. Went Fri night for dinner. Huge salads and tasty bread. Fire grilled polo fresco was delicious big portion.Nice to find healthy choices on a menu. The scallops on the pasta special were cooked perfectly. Friendly prompt service.
6. Bella Pizza Deli Gourmet
Overall Ratings
4 based on 33 reviews
Great little place right on Main Street. Owned by same people as Benitos Trattoria but at half the price for excellent meals and pizza!
Reviewed By MitchPhyllis65
Bellaâs is a rather plain looking deli and pizza place that offers a good menu selection of specialty sandwiches & heros, salads, pasta, seafood and of course gourmet & specialty thin crust pizzas. We stopped by this weekend and tried a slice of their thin crust pepperoni pizza and the thicker bruschetta pizza. Weâve had better pepperoni pizza, and the bruschetta pizza looked really good and different but had too much garlic for my taste.
5. Benito's Trattoria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 116 reviews
Reviewed By Beth E
Recently dined here with a large group. In spite of being a large group, service was still good, food was hot and tasty and delivered correctly relatively all at the same time. Personally I had the lunch special with salad (many had the tortellini soup which was a meal in itself). Main was veal parm and we also got a slice of cake and coffee or tea. All for the bargain price of just under $15. There was plenty left over to take home. Red sauce was sweet - I really enjoyed it.Parking is ample. I parked out back which put me right near the door because the restaurant is behind the main street.
4. Phil's Pizzeria and Italian
Reviewed By rickypiper
Need I say more? Is there anything more disgusting? Well, okay...yes there is but it was still gross. We had pizza from there before that did not have this "surprise:, but it just not very good pizza.
What to do and see in Long Valley, United States: The Best Places and Tips
3. Mama's Cafe Baci
Overall Ratings
4 based on 306 reviews
Specializing in gourmet pizza, pasta, chicken, and seafood selections, also offering full Gluten Free, Vegetarian and Vegan menus, gourmet desserts & coffees. Enjoy wine, beer and cocktails, we're open late with live entertainment and outdoor garden dinin
Reviewed By Culture93233
I just came back from Mama's extremely disappointed. We got two dishes, chose the dish from the specials popular items menu thinking that it will match my expectation. I had good Italian and bad Italian in life but I have never had such a cheap tasting meal as these dishes. Same was with appetizers. I tried to eat but I couldnât. I asked waitress to take it back because I am returning the dish. Chef(or owner), who was hosting a friend in front of our table came over and acted very concerned while i was looking at my receipt as I was signing and calculating tips. He never offered to take the price out when full and nearly untouched plates were returned. It was not my intention but it might have been a right thing to do. My dish was Pescatore described in menu as seafood with basil and tomato sauce. Well, there was no taste of fresh ingredient at all but overwhelming aroma of dried oregano sauce that you could get at Shop Rite. I have never complained at any restaurant and felt very uncomfortable to return dish but in this case me and my partner were siting and watching our plates that we could not even touch and looking at the cook who was hosting his friend in front of us made me to ask why did the menu offered basil for ingredient and we couldnât taste or see it and meal did not looked fresh. He said âthere is basil as wellâ. Whatever that might mean. I am writing this for those who are browsing for good Italian place in town and do not plan to waste time on disappointment.PSI was there about a year ago and food was different. Never will visit again. Italian food deserves better.Hi Maia, First, thank you for your honest review. I do remember your visit to our establishment, and I am sorry that you had a negative experience. I recall walking to your table, and speaking with you for several minutes about our food and preparation, offering to remake the dish more to your liking. We prepare all of our dishes to order, and utilize only fresh ingredients from local providers. If the cuisine was not to your liking, we would always do all we can to make sure our customers are happy. I hope that you will visit us again, as it truly is important for us to have our patrons engage with Mamas in a positive manner. We are a family owned and operated establishment and value our guests after every visit. I realize that you are upset at the moment, but I urge you to please contact me on the phone 908-852-2820 (ask for Tom or Sheri) or email me directly at [email protected] so that we can hopefully rectify your experience. We hope to hear from you soon. Very Best, Tom
Long Valley Food Guide: 10 Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Long Valley
2. Cornerstone Tavern and Grill
Overall Ratings
4 based on 12 reviews
Reviewed By sheilaw3
We tried every pizza restaurant in the area over the past 12 years and when we discovered Cornerstone in 2013, have finally found the best!! In addition to delicious pizza,- they use the freshest ingredients (the only place that has fresh portabello mushrooms and actual fresh mozzarella) and have some of the best Italian food around! We love their eggplant, seafood and pasta dishes and the garlic knots are the best we have had anywhere (including NYC). The dining area itself is cozy and they have a full bar with some nice wine and good beer selections. The staff is personable and efficient and the owners are friendly and treat you like family! Love this place! Do yourself a favor and check them out for a wonderful dining experience in Long Valley.
1. Pezzo Pizza 2
Overall Ratings
4 based on 66 reviews
Reviewed By Peter C
We ate here twice while staying in Long Valley. On both occasions the pizza was quite good. The salad that we ordered as a first course was generously proportions and well made. Service was prompt and very friendly. The menu is huge, so there should be something to appeal to anyone.
Best American food near Long Valley, New Jersey, United States
