Location: Carthage
Top Restaurants in Carthage
Countries
Most Popular Italian food in Carthage, New York, United States
Reviews on Italian food in Carthage, New York, United States. Carthage is a village located in the Town of Wilna in Jefferson County, New York. The population was 3,747 at the 2010 census. The village is named after the historic Carthage in Tunisia.
1. Stefano's Pizzeria & Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 80 reviews
Reviewed By Quest757681
We were visiting family in Natural Bridge in July, and I hadn't been to Stefano's in years (after moving) so I was excited to finally go back! To say the service was horrible is an UNDERSTATEMENT. Short staffed, cursing staff, careless staff, and completely and utterly rude, staff. Every single item we ordered was wrong. Every - single - item. The waitress should have been dragged out by her rude mouth, the kitchen manager putting on a facade like he actually cares, should have had a swift kick in the butt. NO WAY TO DO BUSINESS. We were very patient, did not complain, and had to deal with her attitude everytime we told her what was wrong with our orders. Like it was our fault you can't get your stuff together? No. She WAS the only one waiting tables and they were busy, but just because your job requires you to handle things like this, doesn't mean to take it out on the customers. I'll buy a frozen pizza next time we come up before going back. I've never had service this bad and we've had some pretty horrible servers before...but Stefano's?Takes the cake on this one. Absolutely disgusted.
2. Sahara Restaurant
Reviewed By Charles F
The Sahara is owed and operated by Belva and she treats everyone like family. We really enjoy visiting and talking about local issues, I've always said it's like eating at home without the dishes to clean. If the Tuscan chicken is on special I highly recommend it but everything is good although I've never tried the frog legs...
3. Primo's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 15 reviews
Reviewed By William S
Just had take out from Primo's. Had a Delmonico steak with scallops. Steak was excellent and the scallops cooked perfectly. MY two sides were a baked potato and spinach. All this plus salad and bread for $31. That is a great deal. Everything is packaged good and as always it was service with a smile.
