Location: Barnegat
Top Restaurants in Barnegat
Countries
Most Popular Italian food in Barnegat, New Jersey, United States
Reviews on Italian food in Barnegat, New Jersey, United States. Barnegat Township is a township in Ocean County, New Jersey, United States. As of the 2010 United States Census the township's population was 20,936, reflecting an increase of 5,666 (+37.1%) from the 15,270 counted in the 2000 Census, which had in turn increased by 3,035 (+24.8%) from the 12,235 counted in the 1990 Census. The 2010 population was the highest recorded for the township in any decennial census.
Things to do in Barnegat
10. Il Giardino Sul Mare
Overall Ratings
4 based on 142 reviews
Reviewed By dinerdon
Haven't been here in a while but went back recently for the early bird dinner on a Friday. The meals were all very good. Portions were large enough even though it was the early bird size and they had a nice selection of entrees. Soup, salad, entrée and dessert for $14-$17 was a great value. All four of us liked our dinners. We also got some Calamari which was one of the best I have had. The pureed vegetable soup was also exceptional IMHO. Not a BYOB but a carafe of house Chianti was not bad at $16. Service was good and we did not wait long for our food. Nice waterfront ambiance. Even had a nice singer after 7.The main menu was more extensive but a la carte. Will go back.
9. Il Casereccio
Overall Ratings
4 based on 18 reviews
Reviewed By Bob S
Last night I had the extreme pleasure of eating at the Casereccio Family Pizzeria & Tavola Calda Restaurant. The Restaurant is located in a strip mall storefront not much to speak of and for all purposes looks like a Pizza Parlor, Not impressive at first glance. The restaurant has some tables in it and you eat by the front window. But this where your questions stops about this place. First the staff is super friending wanting to serve you. Then the food is out of this world.First the large salad with choice of dressing. We ate the pasta with Bolognese Sauce. We all agreed this was the best we have eaten since Little Italy. The bread knots were a meal in themselves ( ate too many). To finish the meal we had cannolis Fresh and crips shells and not too sweet. Only drawback was they do not own an espresso machine. I hope they make it becasue this is on the top of my list for Italian cuisine. Believe it or not they are open for breakfast, lunch and dinner
8. East Bay Italian Grille
Overall Ratings
3 based on 12 reviews
Reviewed By 77RobertH
I have no idea how many restaurants have occupied this space, at least 5. All have made the same strategic mistake, they all assume that locals want huge portions of unremarkable food presented poorly after cooling while an untrained waitress struggles to keep up. Staff the place, train the help, try tasting the food before sending it out, plate as if you are an artist. There are thousands of transplanted seniors in the area who remember what great restaurants can be, and they know that this place is far below what a good team can produce.
7. Esposito's Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 11 reviews
Reviewed By GingerM218
The new Espositos owners are delightfully preparing great Italian fare again. From pizza to platters to sandwiches and salads, we are very thankful to have this fine restaurant on our "yes" list! It's a keeper! Costs are competitive with surrounding places but the taste is what will keep you returning.
6. Zanos Italian Market & Trattoria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 51 reviews
Reviewed By 77RobertH
The place was empty and the waitress said âsit anywhereâ. I read the menu and ordered, the place was still empty. Gruff man asked me to move to a tiny table. You never get a second chance to make a first impression. I left and went to another restaurant.
5. Manera's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 219 reviews
Reviewed By Fancyfreebob
Greeted warmly, seated quickly, and enjoyed a fine meal: nightly special chicken with artichokes, olives, and tomato over spagetti. My wife had a very nice, and substantial eggplant parmigiana. Very nice meal. BYOB, though they have a local winery's offering of wines for sale. Great service, crisp, well dressed simple salad, all done in a quiet, pleasantly simple room. Very nice dinner.
4. Luigi's Ristorante
Overall Ratings
4 based on 36 reviews
Reviewed By John K
We have a few Italian restaurants in the area here, and most are fine, but I really like Luigi's for a couple of reasons. First of all, there's a separate area from the restaurant for just having pizza or some other small meal. Second, the service is friendly, efficient, and fairly quick. We've had pasta dishes there and pizza, and I have no complaints about the food or service. The cost isn't cheap, but it's within the range of what is charged elsewhere.
3. Vinnie's Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 29 reviews
Reviewed By S1613LSmichaelk
When my parents first moved into the area , and I came to visit, , Vinnie's was our family dine out place. The food was great and the staff was great.In my opinion, both the food and service declined over time. The food quality and preparation to be of far lower quality and taste of the competition. There were times they got they orders wrong. We had to send food back . I hope they turn it around. But I go elsewhere now.
2. Marchioni's Pizza & Pasta
Overall Ratings
4 based on 37 reviews
Reviewed By S1613LSmichaelk
If you like pizza and Italian food you will like Marchioni's Pizza and Pasta. I have been here several times and have always enjoyed the food , and never been disappointed. The Pizza is fresh and served hot. They use premium ingredients and the freshest available. Plenty of topping chooses too.I am a big fan of their Hot Muscles. In my opinion they should bottle the sauce and sell it nationally. The muscles are large , and very tender. They are cooked to perfection. The fried calamari is also great.I have eaten a lot of Chicken Franches in my life. This was tops! A surprise for a restaurant this type and size. I mean this is all Italian and all Juicy. I would throw this Chicken up against a five star restaurant, and it would win!The salads are good and the wings are good. They also make a great burger. The prices are very reasonable, and in fact surprisingly low given the quality of the food.The restaurant has seating. It is kept extremely clean. The restrooms extremely clean. The staff is extremely friendly! The owner is a great guy, and yes, he is very involved in the business and really cares about his guests. If you are in this area, be sure to stop here!
Where to eat American food in Barnegat: The Best Restaurants and Bars
1. Naples Italian Ristorante & Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 72 reviews
Reviewed By 77RobertH
They will make pizza the way you like it just ask. Want a thin crust pizza with light sauce and extra sausage, just ask. I suspect they use the best flour, cheese, sauce and other ingredients available, there is no other way of explaining the high quality of their pizza. Their calamari is light and delicious, the extensive menu seems to hit all of the Italian bases. Their garlic knots are loaded with garlic if you care for such things.
