Location: Amherst
Top Restaurants in Amherst
Countries
Most Popular Italian food in Amherst, Ohio, United States
Find out what Italian restaurants to try in Amherst. Amherst (/ˈæmhərst/) is a city in Lorain County, Ohio, United States. The population was 12,021 at the 2010 census.
Things to do in Amherst
8. Jim's Pizza Box
Jim's Pizza Box is an Italian restaurant and pizza shop that is now serving Vermilion, OH. We are locally owned and operated. We credit our delicious cuisine to the time-tested recipes of our matriarch, Momma Josephine. Her Italian-American recipes are st
Reviewed By Ralowe08
Our first visit to the restaurant was a disaster due to customer service. It was during their first week open, so we figured it may not run smoothly. Since then, we have ordered online for pick up with great success. Pizza is great - love the crust. Their jalapeno popper calzone is amazing! They are becoming the best pizza place in town!Thank you so much for giving us a second chance. We are so grateful for everyone's patience and we have grown so much as a business in the last few months. Thank you for the kind review and we hope you dine again with us soon!
7. Salvatore's Ristorante Italiano
Overall Ratings
4 based on 42 reviews
Reviewed By hapgeorge
We frequently (a few times a month) get takeout from here. The food is great! I love the linguine in clam sauce (white and red are great). My hubby's fav is chicken cacciatore. The kids like the antipasto salad and the chicken alfredo. We've never had a bad meal from here....ever. Always great!
6. Selenti's Pizza
Reviewed By Jaden W
There's nothing really special about Selenti's Pizza that stands out its just the Average Pizza you'll find and it's Alright not a place to go to all the time.
5. Lenoci's Spaghetti House
Overall Ratings
4 based on 38 reviews
Reviewed By nicetryohio
Have only tried the pizza, its good but not as authentic as it should be. Just my taste, have tried this version of Pizza in both New York and South Florida which has many options for this style of Pizza. With that said and and you want a pie that has some of the New York style quailities , this is your place. Appears clean and well kept, counter help very friendly.
4. Cork Tree Tavern
Reviewed By BrynMawrBK
My husband found the Cork Tree Tavern in Amherst online when we were driving our daughter back to college nearby. I can't believe it isn't already on TripAdvisor, because it's excellent. It has been discovered because it was packed when we visited. Outdoor and indoor seating, a handsome bar and a terrific menu for food as well as wine and cocktails, and a romantic atmosphere combine to make this a standout anywhere. The pastas were outstanding, the vegetarian risotto delicately delicious, salads and flatbread wonderful. A trio of miniature cupcakes for dessert capped a dinner that could not have been improved upon. Our server was personable and knowledgeable, which added to our complete enjoyment of the evening. Don't miss the Cork Tree Tavern -- it's worth the drive!
Ohio, United States Food Guide: 10 Bar food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Amherst
3. D'Tutanelli's Pizza
Reviewed By zanadu2010
Went here with family for lunch. Got right in and seated. Waitress was prompt and got drinks right away . We all ordered pizza and a calzone, which was really large for a small. Also got bread sticks. Every item was good, not overly sauced or spiced like some places. The crust was outstanding, soft and easy to eat. Good place for pizza.
Where to eat American food in Amherst: The Best Restaurants and Bars
2. Yala's Pizza and Eliseo's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 99 reviews
Reviewed By Extraordinary763283
I've been eating Yala's Pizza since high school. I'm way way past high school and have switched to Eliseo's. I find their pizza much better than any chain pizza. The toppings are fresh and plentiful. The service is fast and friendly. It feels like family is making your pizza. I recommend the next time you have a taste for a good pie, call Eliseo's.
1. Old Towne Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 77 reviews
Reviewed By FooFighter44
This is the best place for foldover pizzas in the area. I highly recommend the BLT foldover! Family owned and operated. They have more than just foldovers, but the foldovers are my favorite!
