Location: Sister Bay
Top Restaurants in Sister Bay
Top Things to do in Sister Bay
Countries
Most Popular Bar food in Sister Bay, Wisconsin, United States
Find out what Bar restaurants to try in Sister Bay. Sister Bay is a village in Door County, Wisconsin, United States. The population was 876 at the 2010 census.
Things to do in Sister Bay
1. Sister Bay Bowl
Overall Ratings
4 based on 584 reviews
Reviewed By smithatnt
Iâm sorry to say we had a bad lunchtime experience here. Service was extremely slow, and they ran out of chili when we were waiting. The whitefish chowder was cheesy (maybe this isnât out of the ordinary, but it wasnât enjoyable like the others I had without the cheese). The cheese curds we ordered as a starter were greasy and also not very good.
Top 10 American food in Sister Bay, Wisconsin, United States
2. Fred & Fuzzy's Waterfront Bar and Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 698 reviews
Waterfront dining. Come for the food and drinks. Stay for the sunsets. Home of the World Famous Cherry Margarita. Door County's hidden gem. A seasonal business open Memorial Day to the end of September.
Reviewed By PartnersNTravels
What a pleasant surprise after we finally found where to park thanks to golf cart shuttle driver. A short walk from parking we were excited to find outdoor seating right next to the water. Smoked fish appetizer with Cherry Margarita-couldn't have been more perfect at this quasi margaritaville shoreside setting. Our server was very tentative, thank you Roberta! Due to the confusing parking I would give it a 4 star but the music made up for it.
3. Husby's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 548 reviews
Reviewed By GentlemanFromVerona
We go there a couple of times each Summer when we visit Door County...it is truly "everyman's" place to eat. Not pretentious in anyway. Pub food...burgers, soups, wraps and the prices are very good. It is very popular with local people so it has a neighborhood feel. You can eat in-doors in the bar area or their dining area...the outside is good for people watching but the tables are small...a good time for everybody, not rowdy.
4. Boathouse on the Bay
Overall Ratings
4 based on 226 reviews
Come enjoy the fully remodeled restaurant and bar with the best water views in all of Door County. New rooftop dining and rooftop bar. Expanded menu has something for everyone. Welcome to the new hotspot in Sister Bay.
Reviewed By resident57966
First time at this place and we were totally OK with it. The cheese soup was outstanding. There were 6 of us and we all got something different. I had the perch basket. Very good basket..........the tarter sauce was a good surprise as I am not a fan usually. It worked great with the perch.
5. Northern Grill & Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 230 reviews
Reviewed By WL_Mpls
We arrived a few minutes after 7pm on July 5th, we were a party of six and looked inside and outside before deciding on a table outside - most tables inside were for four or less. The restaurant was about half full at that point - I noticed at least a half dozen tables inside were empty, and at least half the outside tables were too. And yet it took a full hour for us to receive our order. After 45 minutes we complained - we werenât the only ones either - and were told âthe pizzas take a little longerâ by the waitress. It was still another 15 minutes before we got our food. Eventually the restaurant manager came to speak to us and she told us, after telling us the kitchen was really busy (despite half the tables being empty), âif we told everyone it would be an hour wait before they were served, nobody would come here.âI told her that a 60 minute wait is unacceptable, especially when the restaurant was half full. She neither accepted that basic fact about customer expectations at a restaurant, nor apologized for keeping us, including my 80+ year old parents, waiting an hour for our order. Beyond that central incompetence, when we were seated outside, the waitress took our drink order, and after telling us she broke the opener trying to open our bottle of wine (?!) (she had to go back inside for a few minutes after bringing the bottle) we were told that there is no table service outside and normally you have to order food with the bartender (?!). However she offered to take our order, which saved us from having to walk over to the bar with dinner orders for six people, which apparently is the normal procedure at this restaurant.After we finished our meal, the manager had the waitress deliver the message offering us free dessert because of the wait, rather than taking the responsibility herself. We thought about it, but also wondered how much longer it would take to get it. But after looking again at the menu, we found there was no dessert listed on any of the menus! We just laughed at that point at the sheer incompetence! The waitress came back and when we told her there was no dessert on the menu she said, âoh we donât have a dessert menu, let me tell you what we have for dessert....âWe laughed again and passed. The food itself was average Italian fare you can find at just about any typical Italian restaurant- Average thin crust pizza, spaghetti bolognese, marinara, etc. only served in 15 minutes by any competent restaurant.Avoid.
