Location: Tannersville
Top Restaurants in Tannersville
- 1. Last Chance Antiques & Cheese Cafe
- 2. Deer Mountain Inn
- 3. Selena & Nick's Diner
- 4. Mama's Boy Burgers
- 5. The Catskill Mountain Country Store and Restaurant
- 6. Jessie's Harvest House Restaurant & Lodge
- 7. American Glory BBQ
- 8. Maggie's Krooked Cafe & Juice Bar
- 9. Prospect Restaurant
- 10. Circle W General Store
Top Things to do in Tannersville
Countries
Most Popular American food in Tannersville, New York, United States
Best American restaurants nearby. Discover the best American food in Tannersville. View Menus, Photos and Reviews for American restaurants near you.. Tannersville is a village in Greene County, New York, United States. The village is in the north-central part of the town of Hunter on Route 23A. The population was 539 at the 2010 census, up from 448 at the 2000 census.
Things to do in Tannersville
10. Circle W General Store
Overall Ratings
5 based on 79 reviews
Reviewed By Karesson
CIRCLE W serves the best sandwiches and salads in the Catskills region. And, they also sell a lot of nice things in their shop. Organic nuts, local granola, bars, drinks... A Great to stock up on sustainable/organic items and snacks. I love the hummus sandwich served as a bowl. YUM! and, the servings are really huge. Everyone I've asked who's been here love it. You won't go wrong. Good for vegetarian and vegan options too . .
9. Prospect Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 66 reviews
Prospect Restaurant at Scribners Lodge serves a playful twist on local cuisine inspired by the rich and diverse offerings of the Hudson Valley.
Reviewed By bethbI8794WX
We sat at the bar, our bartender was very nice, conversational and made great cocktails. The views are beautiful, service is not rushed-you're in a relaxing environment (aprés ski).We ordered a few apps that were all delicious: shishito peppers, diver scallop crudo and the cheese plate. My only complaint, we had to order the $5 bread because there were only two slices of bread with the cheese plate (there were three of us & we didn't ration well). We will be back!
8. Maggie's Krooked Cafe & Juice Bar
Overall Ratings
4 based on 146 reviews
Reviewed By 851less
I introduced my wife and daughter to Hunter - very sad how muchhas changed, but thrilled that Maggie is still serving up an amazingbreakfast.It's not cheap, but worth every penny. I recommend the pancakes.Get a great breakfast before hitting the slopes
7. American Glory BBQ
Overall Ratings
4 based on 68 reviews
Reviewed By CCM0518
Ribs, pulled pork and Texas brisket were all flavorful and tender. We ordered the 6 rack ribs and all of them were large, tender pieces. The portion in the 2 meat basket is a decent size so can definitely be split between 2 people. Coleslaw was fresh. Cornbread was airy with kernels in it. Three different sauces at the table to pick from - all good and each tastes unique. Service very good and waitress very knowledgeable so was able to help us select many menu items that worked with my allergies. Waited about 15 min for food to arrive. May not be inexpensive, but is reasonably priced.
6. Jessie's Harvest House Restaurant & Lodge
Overall Ratings
4 based on 21 reviews
Jessie's offers a cozy dining experience that serves delicious elevated comfort food with locally sourced ingredients in a warm an welcoming environment, plus a tavern-style bar and fireplace lounge. Outdoor seating is also available (seasonal). The lodge
Reviewed By mvidro
I ordered the pan-roasted Catskill trout, served with roasted mango hummus and sauteed kale, basted in honey-thyme oil. Although a standard menu item, the fish was so overcooked that portions couldn't be separated from the underlying skin. While I was disappointed, my friend ordered two specials: clams and fishes tacos. She found both excellent. My final rating is the average of the overall experience.
5. The Catskill Mountain Country Store and Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 43 reviews
OUR STORY âA little piece of the countryâ can be found at 5510 Main Street in Windham and at our location at 6014 Main St. Tannersville. Two of the areaâs best-loved family destinations. We are glad you found us on the web and would love for you to come v
Reviewed By orrdin
The place is a hybrid store and restaurant and we stopped here for breakfast and it was fantastic. Omelettes, pancakes and other choices all delicious and reasonably priced. Add to the mix prompt and really friendly service and you have a real winner.Thanks orrdin for the wonderful review! We will definatly let our staff know how much you enjoyed coming to our store. We hope you get back to the mountains and visit us again soon. Regards, Natasha and Drew Shuster
4. Mama's Boy Burgers
Overall Ratings
4 based on 74 reviews
Mamaâs Boy Burgers, at the iconic Smileyâs location at the traffic light in Tannersville, serves delicious, locally-grown, grass-fed, Angus beef burgers at affordable prices; and Hoffmanâs Hot Dogs (Both all beef and white hots). Mamaâs Boy also has a var
Reviewed By c00pertravel
We visited at mid-day (around 3pm), and the place was packed with no available tables, so we decided to take our meals to go. We ordered 2 burgers, once with french fries and the other with tater tots. It took approx. 20 min to receive our order.The burgers, while tasty, were on a small side. My 2 beef patty burger was not much larger than the one you would get from BK, which was a disappointment, since burgers are the specialty at this place.Unfortunately, we did not examine the contents of the bag in time, otherwise I would have taken it back to the counter right away. The tots were very good, but the french fries were an embarasement (see my photo). My burger also came with caramelized onions, of which I counted exactly 3 pieces.I think the owner should shake up the kitchen a bit, or start losing business of repeat customers, and rely only on one-time visitors.
3. Selena & Nick's Diner
Overall Ratings
4 based on 71 reviews
Reviewed By Maus10Wardsboro
I really hate to write a bad review but we had an awful time at this diner Saturday night. I really think the poor waitress was the only one doing anything that night. There were two bus boys who could get drink orders and cash out diners but the waitress was running around like crazy. Took 45 min to get our 4 dinners, two of which were salads! I counted 30 people in the whole place so I am not sure what took so long. I finally had to ask where our food was. She came out moments later acting annoyed saying she was waiting until everything was ready together but she decided sense it was taking so long she brought out what was ready. All three meals came out including one salad but the other was not ready yet she said.. very strange. They could make one Caesar salad but not the second one???? Mostly the food was good. Not great, Unfortunately my open face hot turkey sandwich had been done and sitting under the lights the whole 45 min we waited. The gravy had a skim on the top from sitting and it was cold. It was really a bummer of a meal. Very disappointed.
2. Deer Mountain Inn
Overall Ratings
4 based on 92 reviews
Nestled in the Catskill Mountains, just 2.5 hours away from NYC, youâll find a secluded escape with breathtaking views that is Deer Mountain Inn. With 2 roaring fireplaces and walls adorned with Catskill ephemera and Hudson River School paintings, our coz
Reviewed By 752HelenB752
Did not stay at the Inn but thoroughly enjoyed attending a wedding there. Gorgeous inside. Fabulous outside seating that got chilly this time of year with limited view. Inside and outside bars. Two fireplaces and pretty stairs to the lawn. The food and service excellent. Baby grand piano should someone want music during cocktail reception. We were impressed.
1. Last Chance Antiques & Cheese Cafe
Overall Ratings
4 based on 450 reviews
Family restaurant serving lunch and dinner daily. We specialize in american comfort food including steaks, burgers, meat loaf, and chicken pot pie.
Reviewed By BackRoadsUSA
Love the ambiance, a fun building with some booths, some tables, lots of seating choices. Collection of all kinds of antique bottles and more- not sure if some of these items are for sale... Friendly service- Lots of comfort food choices on the menu- like Meatloaf- really enjoyed my fresh green salad, and the tomatoes! Grandmas Meatloaf with mashed potatoes was enough to share- and the brown gravy just the right amount! Honestly I could have used a spiced up Meatloaf but if just your basic Grandmas Meatloaf is your speed-- order this! Solid choice in Tannersville!
