Location: Sidney
Top Restaurants in Sidney
Countries
Most Popular American food in Sidney, Ohio, United States
Best American restaurants nearby. Discover the best American food in Sidney. View Menus, Photos and Reviews for American restaurants near you.. Sidney is a city in Shelby County, Ohio, United States. The population was 21,229 at the 2010 census. It is named after English poet Sir Philip Sidney and is the county seat of Shelby County. As well, many of the city's elementary schools are also named after famous writers, such as Emerson, Longfellow and Whittier. Sidney was the recipient of the 1964 All-America City Award. In 2009, it was the subject of the documentary film 45365.
Restaurants in Sidney
10. Subway
Reviewed By DickandRobin
African American woman with glasses (name?) provided the best service I ever experienced at the 1520 Michigan Street store (#4779-0). Other Subway employees typically only care when their next break is. She was in control, motivating those working with her. A professional role model.
9. Subway
Reviewed By TeamSloan_USA
Subway is since years a very healthy choice in a world full of junk food... we love it, and the restaurant here in Wapakoneta Ave is a very clean, friendly one of the chain. Subscribing the newsletter on their main website gives you also a weekly coupon, that is another nice way to take care of ourselves. Highly recommended!
8. Buffalo Wild Wings Grill & Bar
Overall Ratings
3 based on 35 reviews
Reviewed By 140kennethy
service wasnt bad and food was acceptable. however I dont think you should sprinkle seasoning on wings after cooking and call it dry rub
7. Bob Evans
Overall Ratings
3 based on 34 reviews
Welcome to America's Farm Fresh. Stop by this fall for tender, juicy, USDA choice steaks served all day along with your cooler weather comfort favorites. Serving breakfast, lunch or dinner at our table or yours. Click, call or come in today!
Reviewed By RunningEsme
I keep trying and keep getting disappointed. Came with a group during lunch break. As soon as we were seated we ordered drinks. Drinks took an average amount of time to arrive. We ordered immediately and then waited and waited and waited. Forty minutes later our food shows up, and the food was all from the lunch menu, most of it soups and salads. Was late getting back to work, which also happened the last time I ate here for lunch. Will definitely not return for lunch. Also missed the old potato-cheese soup. That one had bacon and scallions. The new version just has potato and cheese.
6. Firehouse Subs
Reviewed By ALesserKnownPath
If you're looking for the best sub sandwiches in the Sidney, Ohio / Shelby County area, you'll find them at Firehouse Subs!Located just off of Interstate 75 in the Kroger Shopping Plaza, and next to Jojo Vapes and Hothead Burritos, Firehouse Subs offers a wide selection of hot and cold sandwiches, along with the standard chips / soda fare.On our visit, we had the New York Steamer (made of USDA Choice Corned beef brisket and pastrami, melted provolone, deli mustard, mayo, and Italian dressing), and the Smokehouse Beef and Cheddar Brisket (USDA Choice beef brisket smoked for up to 16 hours, melted cheddar, mayo, and Sweet Baby Rayâs® BBQ Sauce).Both sandwiches were truly excellent; hot soft buns, lots of delicious meat, fresh toppings and condiments, and flavors that were very, very good.Service was exemplary, and the prices very fair. You can sit and eat in the ample seating area, or take it with you to go.One clue to the popularity of this Firehouse Subs location is the steady stream of people picking up large orders for area businesses and factories, a sure sign that Firehouse Subs is doing subs right!BOTTOM LINE: If you're looking for the best sub sandwiches in the Sidney, Ohio / Shelby County area, head over to Firehouse Subs for a great sandwich!.
5. Farmstand Pizza & Carry Out
Overall Ratings
4 based on 23 reviews
Reviewed By ALesserKnownPath
If you're looking for a Great Pizza Restaurant in Sidney, Ohio / Shelby County, you just might want to give Farmstand Pizza a try.You'll see a lot of very positive reviews for this restaurant over the course of many years, so you know that there's a priority there with the owners and staff to run a top-notch operation.That said, the staff are friendly, helpful, and - as others have said - treat you like family.On the TripAdvisor-based 1-5 rating system, I'd rate Farmstand's food as follows:Pizza: 4Wings: 4Cheesy Bread: 5 (just may be the best cheesy bread in Sidney!)Salads: 4Ice Cream: 5Shakes: 5Appetizers: 3.5Your food is made fresh as soon as you order it, so plan on a short wait for your delicious food (home delivery times are right on time with the time that they promise you), but you'll probably think that it was worth the wait.And the prices for all are very reasonable!So, if you're on the hunt for a Great Pizza Restaurant in Sidney, Ohio / Shelby County, check out Farmstand Pizza!.
4. B & K Root Beer
Reviewed By TeamSloan_USA
In our opinion, this is the best place in town for Spanish hotdogs, which are absolutely delicious. French fries are always perfectly cooked, not raw nor burned. Root beer here is the best ever. And they're always friendly, even with our dog. Old style food stand which won't disappoint you. Only negative note is... unfortunately they won't re-open until next spring! Can't wait, we miss your delicious food guys! Highly recommended.
3. Perkins Restaurant & Bakery
Overall Ratings
4 based on 22 reviews
Reviewed By Cheryl02760
I think this place is pricey for the type of restaurant it is. Service is not always the best either.
2. Smok'n Jo's Bbq
Overall Ratings
4 based on 67 reviews
Reviewed By shannon812
We were in and out in 20 minutes. Place seemed really clean and the food, like most bbq, was delicious. I just got a pulled pork sandwich with fries. My husband got the pork dinner. He liked it really well. This is a great alternative to fast food.
1. The Bridge Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 123 reviews
Reviewed By amygW8178ZN
Very nice atmosphere but the food was just ok. I had to send my steak back twice and it still wasnât cooked correct. For the price of the food we didnât feel like it was worth it.
