Location: Monticello
Top Restaurants in Monticello
Top Things to do in Monticello
Countries
Most Popular American food in Monticello, New York, United States
Best American restaurants nearby. Discover the best American food in Monticello. View Menus, Photos and Reviews for American restaurants near you.. Monticello /ˌmɒntɪˈsɛloʊ/ is a village located in Thompson in Sullivan County, New York, United States. The population was 6,726 at the 2010 census. It is the seat for the Town of Thompson and the county seat of Sullivan County. The village was named after the residence of Thomas Jefferson.
Things to do in Monticello
10. Beaver Lake Concession
Amazing concession with all of your summer favorites! Vegan options available.
9. Savory Sweet Eatery
8. Jonny's Kitchen
Food trailer serving Sabrett hot dogs on Martin's potato roll, freshly made hot heroes, tacos, sandwiches and fried snacks.
7. KFC
See what the Colonel's cooking at your local KFC. Stop in today and enjoy our world famous chicken - it's Finger Lickin' Good!
Reviewed By hh73050
Place was clean, food was standard KFD ok, BUT the kids serving us were more interested in flirting with each other than serving us , did not enjoy their antics
6. Subway
Reviewed By Mishey71
Disliked~most all of it. Discourteous staff. Very, VERY tight with their toppings (I swear person making our sandwiches was COUNTING everything we asked for!!~seriously). Unclean and atmosphere was unwelcoming. Very disappointed.
5. 24 / 7 Diner
Overall Ratings
3 based on 46 reviews
Reviewed By 94741233
I was pleasantly surprised at the meals my wife and I had here. While this is framed as a diner, the restaurant has an very nice modern appearance and food that is better than what I'm accustomed to getting in diners. The tableware is nice and there are cloth napkins.I had the soup of the day, tomato basil, and it was as good as any tomato basil soup I've had anywhere. I also had the Philly cheesesteak sandwich, and the large roll was great and the ingredients were very good, about as good a cheesesteak sandwich as I've had anywhere. My wife had the chili, and it was made with beef meat that was not hamburger, and better than average. Our fries were also better than average.But the service was a huge letdown. Our server was pleasant enough, but from our observations, clearly assigned to too many tables. When we arrived, the restaurant was less than half full and there were numerous empty, clean tables, yet we were given a pager and told that it would be 15 minutes before they could seat us. This clearly points to an understaffing situation. Enough servers would enable them to fill more tables and avoid inadequate service. Our server did not return at any time during our meal to offer refills of our beverages, which I needed. It took a while to obtain our check and process it. So, if you have time and patience, you will get a good meal here. But the inadequate staffing will be reflected in the quality of service you receive.
4. Winners Circle Buffet Monticello Casino Raceway
Overall Ratings
3 based on 27 reviews
This is a buffet restaurant located in the Monticello Casino Raceway
Reviewed By hh73050
Casino's are famous for their buffet food, Monticello Casino Raceway is the exception. the food is OK but nothing to write home about. Pricey , limited choices, salad bar is the best part of the spread. Tight seating, waitstaff friendly, place quite clean, shrimp fresh and large. Children not allowed.
3. Cellaio Steak
Overall Ratings
4 based on 61 reviews
Renowned chef, author and restaurateur Scott Conant introduces an Italian-inspired steakhouse, Cellaio, nestled in the picturesque Catskill Mountains. A play on the Italian term for a butcher's pantry, Cellaio offers Conant's take on the traditional steak
Reviewed By lovethebeach11229
Delicious. Made reservations a month ahead of our visit. Service was excellent, simple yet very nice decor. Shared the meatball appetizer, steaks cooked to perfection, pasta pomodoro could have used more garlic and chimichurri was not the best. Enjoyed the tirimasu fir dessert. We were not rushed - could have sat all night(probably not like that in season)
2. Miss Monticello Diner
Overall Ratings
4 based on 130 reviews
Reviewed By Terry1497
The prices and the food canât be beaten. A hot open roast beef for $9? With a delicious side of mouth watering mashed potatoes and brown gravy, itâs undeniably the best thing on their menu. The soups are homemade and delicious. Nothing Iâve eaten has been average, only good and above. Service is spectacular. Keep it up!
1. Tilly's Diner
Overall Ratings
4 based on 104 reviews
Reviewed By Anne9202014
I go by this Tilly's Diner all the time and I have never stopped. Based on reviews, I decided to meet a friend and her grandkids there today. The wait staff could not have been more pleasant and helpful. The coffee was fresh and hot, my breakfast was piping hot and delicious. The diner was very clean. One of the kids did not eat her breakfast. The waitress noticed and offered to get her something different. I will certainly return!
