Location: Henrietta
Top Restaurants in Henrietta
Countries
Most Popular American food in Henrietta, New York, United States
Best American restaurants nearby. Discover the best American food in Henrietta. View Menus, Photos and Reviews for American restaurants near you.. Stephen L. Schultz (D) First elected 2017
Things to do in Henrietta
10. The Melting Pot
Overall Ratings
4 based on 117 reviews
Reviewed By chopin1981
I had a Groupon and it was my first visit here. The hostess and manager are very welcoming, the restaurant looked new and clean. Our server was very polite.The cheese fondue was very tasty. We polished it off within minutes. The salads were flavorful, but very small.The entree was not appropriate for the method of cooking offered in the restaurant. We had filet mignon, tuna, duck etc. and had to throw it into the bowling broth. The filet and tuna ended up grey and barely edible, even though they cooked for 1 minute. They looked really unappetizing. The servers should warn the customers that beef and tuna will look unrecognizable and will taste odd after boiling them. If I knew the result of all of this, I would have ordered shrimp and lobster.The dessert fondue was very good. The restaurant has acknowledged my husband's birthday by serving us champagne and printing "Happy Birthday" on his dessert plate.
9. Sticky Lips BBQ
Overall Ratings
3 based on 540 reviews
Reviewed By Larry W
Enjoyed this meal, as I tend to at every visit to Sticky Lips. I had a 1/2 rack rib platter with two sides - coleslaw and baked beans. all was very good, and the "cherry bomb" slathering sauce goes really well with the ribs. Unlike our last visit, the service was very good and the food came our quite quickly. This is a fun place to enjoy very good BBQ, and I do recommend it.
8. Bar Louie
Overall Ratings
4 based on 156 reviews
Eat. Drink. Be Happy. What does it take to be a regular at Bar Louie Rochester? An enjoyment of the craft and the desire to experience something out of the ordinary. From our Chicago roots, we've always known that having a comfortable place to hang out, g
Reviewed By gsanto
I had the âblackenedâ fish tacos that had a little sprinkling of paprika on the fish. Definitely not blackened. There was a smear of guacamole, few diced tomatoes and little else. This was put on 2 uncooked corn tortillas layered on top of each other and had no taste. I would have sent them back but I was with a friend who was treating me and I didnât want to make her feel bad.
7. Tully's Good Times Rochester
Overall Ratings
4 based on 120 reviews
Reviewed By michelledJ4188MO
Great food, service was great. We had Kevin as our waiter and he was friendly and attentive. There are many TV with various sports events on each so if you like sports you will enjoy this place. It can tend to be a bit loud so if you are not into that then this is not for you.
6. Delmonico's Italian Steak House
Overall Ratings
4 based on 328 reviews
Reviewed By Tracey B
I have taken both my employees and one of our customers here. Great atmosphere. We sat in a private room with curtains. Filet Mignon was delicious. Drinks are good. Service was good.
5. Peppermint's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 146 reviews
Reviewed By Jerry B
We were on our 1st Tour to Cape Cod via Bus. Peppermint's was one of the meal stops along the way. We were very impressed with the service, quality of food, atmosphere and ease of entry. Just a great experience. Our bus load took a portion of the restaurant and the rest of the seating was taken by local business. The place was full ad service was fast. How much better can you get than that?
4. Fireside Grill and Sports Bar
Overall Ratings
4 based on 117 reviews
Reviewed By CCdreamer
I met relatives here for lunch today and it was very good. We all ordered the fish sandwich special. None of us had any complaints whatsoever, The Fish was excellent. I can say the same for the friendly, helpful service. Good value, good food! I will definitely return.
3. Sticky Lips Pit BBQ
Overall Ratings
4 based on 817 reviews
Reviewed By RCross74
Wonderful food and a large selection of over 50 different beer on tap. Super helpful staff and very cool atmosphere. Very good pricing.
2. Pi Craft Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 97 reviews
Reviewed By Memmett
Brought 4 teenagers here and it was great - no one has to compromise - we all got what we wanted. The oval pizza was a good size for a teenage boy and we even were able to bring some leftovers home. It was fresh and made to order, about $60 for the 5 of us each getting a pizza and a drink. The staff was friendly and very accommodating. Would definitely recommend and visit again.
What to do and see in Henrietta, United States: The Best Places and Tips
1. DiBella's Old Fashioned Submarines
Overall Ratings
4 based on 283 reviews
Reviewed By barrettcpa
We ordered four different subs here, and each one was the best we have ever had. No, these are not $5 subs, or High School fund raiser subs. They are great (big) meals on delicious rolls. We had the Godfather, Chicken Caesar, Steak (hot), and BLT. I deferred to the sandwich maker's judgement as to what to add, and told him, "We've never eaten her before. Just make it so that that we'll want to come back." We definitely will be back. We thought we would have to (and were planning to) return to Rochester to have more, but find they have a few stores in the Albany area, which we will make point of going to.
Henrietta Food Guide: 10 Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Henrietta
