Location: Carmel
Top Restaurants in Carmel
Top Things to do in Carmel
Countries
Most Popular American food in Carmel, New York, United States
Best American restaurants nearby. Discover the best American food in Carmel. View Menus, Photos and Reviews for American restaurants near you.. Carmel (pronounced CAR-mul) is a town in Putnam County, New York, United States. As of the 2010 census, the town had a population of 34,305.
Things to do in Carmel
10. Northwood Inn
Overall Ratings
3 based on 24 reviews
Reviewed By Patricia J
We love kielbasa and pierogies I was very excited to try them. I had the hot Polish platter which had 1 stuffed cabbage, a few pieces of grilled/fried kielbasa and 3 pierogies: 1 meat, 1 potatoe and 1 sauerkraut. The stuffed cabbage was big but had no flavor, not even the cabbage! The pierogies were soggy/mushy and very little flavor. The platter cost $17.99 so it was not cheap. I may not have minded paying that had it been better. I would say the kielbasa was the best thing on the plate. I also told a friend about before I went and she and her family had gone before we did and she had the platter as well and was also very disappointed. My husband had the goulash and potatoe pancakes which he enjoyed very much. I would go back again to try something different but definitely not for the polish food. The waitress/bar tender was there by herself so the service was slow. We were the only people in the restaurant but the bar had a few customers.
9. Patrick's Pub & Grill
Reviewed By arnie31346
First, if this pub was in our neighborhood we would be here more often, there is a great ambiance and the place is very warm and comfortableJJ is a great hostess with a wonderful personality.Now, let's talk Happy Hour food.Irish Nachos, freshly fried homemade potato chips, shredded pork, sausage and shaved cheddar cheese, large portion and yummy.Blarney Rolls, corned beef, cabbage, carrots, all in an egg roll shell with dijon mustard sauce, very different and very good.Double Dusted Wings came mild, as we asked, tender and moist and very tasty.Everything is very fresh and very good.Patrick's is a great find, we are now regulars.
8. Southeast Grille House
Overall Ratings
4 based on 68 reviews
Casual fine dining. closed from 3-5 p, everyday except sunday. dinner served all day sunday
Reviewed By Brewster18
My family and I go here every Friday night. Itâs such a lovely restaurant. The owners are so accommodating, and friendly. The food is excellent, the staff are so friendly. We never have a complaint. The prices are very fair.
7. Atomic Wings at Greek Village Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 16 reviews
Reviewed By milliegordon2
I have eaten here often - it is a good alternative to a traditional diner since it offers some Greek specialties. Over the years, the prices have gone up and the portions have gone down. Service is efficient although the waitresses always seem so down-trodden.
6. McCarthy's Grill House
Overall Ratings
4 based on 21 reviews
Reviewed By Michelle A
Tucked away up on a hill with a waterfall and outdoor seating, McCarthy's provides great friendly service to all the locals whether is happy hour or celebrating a special occasion. Large menu choices, great food and average service. (If you sit outside service is usually slow) Restaurant is clean and friendly. Bathrooms are clean and large parking area for the patrons.
5. Cutillo's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 30 reviews
Reviewed By BFaber203
Have stopped here a few times over the last 15 years. I wanted this to be our new favorite place for special occasions and dinners. Sadly, it has simply gotten worse and worse. The food is good, but pricey. Service has gotten worse over time, and there has been no attempt to keep the facility from looking/feeling run down. Good news is I have always been able to get a table - but I think this is because people stopped frequenting Cutillos.
What to do and see in Carmel, United States: The Best Places and Tips
4. Carmel Diner Inc.
Overall Ratings
4 based on 42 reviews
Reviewed By DANIEL M
Old fashioned diner with on site parking. Limited menu compared to other diners. The prices were very good, but the food was just OK. I had the roast chicken which was good, but the potatoes seemed very watery and was probably instant. The vegetables were OK and seemed fresh. The coffee was lousy, (i drink it black so I can tell immediately) and the pie was very good. If your hungry it's ok, but not as good as other diners.
Carmel Food Guide: 10 Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Carmel
3. Eveready Diner
Overall Ratings
4 based on 308 reviews
Reviewed By Christian D
We stopped for Breakfast at Eveready. The place was a ghost town. Two clients in a huge dining room.The food was good, nothing exceptional. I had the eggs Benedict and the hollandaise was probably from a jar or a mix, not really good. Coffee and prices are reasonable.
2. Smalley's Inn
Overall Ratings
4 based on 97 reviews
Reviewed By 372susan2018
We went in October and the decorations for Halloween are fantastic. The food is good and the portions are large. It is not overpriced. It is kid friendly and they have a kids menu. The only reason I didn't give it 5 stars is b/c the manager (an older guy) was really cranky. The waitresses were nice.
1. George's Place
Overall Ratings
4 based on 40 reviews
Reviewed By E M
We have began coming here on and off about 5 months ago. When we first went in.. We detected a strong smell of mold and mildew at the entrance of the Diner. The server said they had just laid some cement hence the smell and assured us that it was noi mold and mildew. We have been there since and the SAME smell is pervasive when we walk in. We opt to eat either outside or in the front where the windows are. The smell is less offensive by the windows. However,.. we visited last week end and had no option other than to sit inside... We both got instant headaches, terrible malaise.. politely walked out, So sad because it has good diner food.,
