Location: New Buffalo
Top Restaurants in New Buffalo
Countries
Michigan, United States Food Guide: 5 Italian food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in New Buffalo
Find out what Italian restaurants to try in New Buffalo. New Buffalo is a Lake Michigan beach getaway convenient to Indiana and Chicago. The large, broad public beach is the main attraction, but you can also explore downtown New Buffalo's shopping and dining options. Or, if you feel like taking a chance, the Four Winds Casino Resort has 130,000 square feet of gaming space. Owned by the Pokagon Band of Potawatomi Indians, its design evokes their heritage.
Things to do in New Buffalo
1. Brewster's Italian Cafe
Overall Ratings
4 based on 462 reviews
Over the last 25 years, Brewster's Italian Cafe` has grown from a small bakery to a full-service Italian restaurant in the heart of Harbor Country. Located in downtown New Buffalo, Michigan, Brewster's offers seasonally-inspired items and locally sourced
Reviewed By mflyon
We had breakfast in the enjoyable courtyard with our family We had pancakes with delicious berry sauce.Another day we had lunch and each had a "make your own" pizza. Lots of ingredients like artichokes, sundried tomatoes, mushrooms....to chose from. For desert we shared an italian cream cake. Both time service was good even during busy lunch time.Thank you so much for your kind words! We will look forward to seeing you again sometime soon.
Where to eat American food in New Buffalo: The Best Restaurants and Bars
2. Terrace Room
Overall Ratings
4 based on 179 reviews
Enjoy rustic Italian cuisine with a waterfront view. Handmade pastas and regional dishes inspired by the season are complemented by a carefully curated wine list and an intimate fireside setting. When weather allows, the outdoor terrace is one of Harbor C
Reviewed By Glen_Arbor_Blues
We started out with a berry cider that was good. The goat cheese appetizers was great with garlic bread. Brussel sprouts were smoky but good. My dad enjoyed the shrimp appetizer and the shiraz. My salad was good with pepperocini, tomatoes, cucumber. The side of cauliflower was good as well as the ravioli stuffed with spinach and cheese and three sauces. I didn't care for the mini cookie dessert things at the end.
3. Villa Nova Pizzeria - New Buffalo
Overall Ratings
4 based on 107 reviews
Reviewed By MrH0bbes
We were staying at a vacation cottage and asked for recommendations for pizza delivery. Our hostess recommended this pizzeria, and we are very happy that she did. We were able to schedule delivery, which was very convenient, and the pizza arrived right on time. Most importantly, it was delicious! All of us agreed it was some of the best thin crust pizza we had ever tasted.
4. Roma Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 39 reviews
Reviewed By Chris L
The food was very good...very fresh and delicious. The new owners are doing it right. We go here whenever we go to New Buffalo...this time was an improvement from the last. The restaurant was nice and clean, the tables didn't wobble and knock drinks over and service was immediate to get our drinks and order. Then...the problem. We were the only people in the restaurant and it took nearly an hour to get our food. The staff courteous and fun and the food was great when we finally got it. Wait was just to long for on one else there.
5. Dominic's
Reviewed By harborctylover
Dominic's closed their resturant to the public for a few hours so we could have a buffet dinner in celebration of a birthday. We had 70 people there. Dominic's did a great job working with us to make it a special event. The food and service was 'right on' for the occassion.We have eaten at this establishment multiple times before and wanted to highlight our appreciation for the job they performed.A word of caution. This resturant is located in a former truck stop but has been redone to deliver the italian flavor. Don't let the 'truck stop' parking lot and exterior keep you from trying this resturant.
