Location: Matlacha
Top Restaurants in Matlacha
Top Things to do in Matlacha
Countries
Florida, United States Food Guide: 9 Italian food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Matlacha
Discover Restaurants offering the best Italian food in Matlacha, Florida, United States. Matlacha ( /ˈmætləʃeɪ/ MAT-lə-shay "MAT-la-shay") is a census-designated place (CDP) in Lee County, Florida, United States. As of the 2000 census, the CDP had a total population of 735. It is part of the Cape Coral-Fort Myers, Florida Metropolitan Statistical Area.
Things to do in Matlacha
9. Lelulo's Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 125 reviews
Reviewed By 834davee
Close to where we were staying, we tried this place for a quick carryout pizza order. Pleasantly surprised by the size, taste, and quality of the pizza. Being from Pittsburgh, loved the hometown touches. Will definitely eat here again when visitng the area!
8. Carrabba's Italian Grill
Overall Ratings
4 based on 308 reviews
Reviewed By transitionus
Usually very good service tonight awful non existent food mediocre at best although along with wilted Romain my husband thought was kale to bad Chicken Parm with a tinny 1x1 inch square of Lasagna on their classic menu item was a staple but not anytime soon l.Hello,This is not at all the food and service experience we had hoped for. If youâd like to get in touch directly, please fill out our Contact Us form and we will reach back out: https://www.carrabbas.com/contact-us Thank you,LeahCarrabbaâs Italian Grill
Where to eat Soups food in Matlacha: The Best Restaurants and Bars
7. Dante's Coal Fired Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 284 reviews
Reviewed By PrincessSlipperFeet
Came in with the family tonight and really liked the atmosphere. It was well-decorated and cozy with a nice open layout. The bar area looked very attractive- somewhere to maybe come back for an appetizer and a beer sometime, perhaps. (Until you see the prices... drafts started at $4.50 for domestics. Even the soft drinks were overpriced. Not very normal at a pizza restaurant.)The service was nice and very efficient. The shocker, however, are some of the prices. Typically when I go out for pizza/Italian food, I almost always order both appetizers and side salads for the table. All of the appetizers were a bit overpriced, and none really stood out to me, so we opted to skip it. Next, for salads, almost all of the salads were around $10. No $3-$5 smaller side or Caesar salads or anything? Come on. We then decided to split a Caprese salad. The salad was absolutely gorgeous, and tasty, but was mostly just an arugula salad with a few small tomato chunks and bits of mozzarella cut up with some red onion. Not a traditional Caprese salad.The pizza, I will say, was very good. The crust was nice and crispy on the outside and the sauce was good. The cheese was of excellent quality, as were the ingredients. One last thing that I found to be strange though, was that there was no pizza on the kids menu. I thought this was WEIRD for a place that advertises pizza as its specialty. I had to order my second grade son a 12â pizza ($10) because the kids menu was very limited, and again, no pizza.We will probably give it another chance one day, but I really hope that they can come back down to Earth with their prices or at least have some daily specials.
Most Popular Gastropub food in Matlacha, Florida, United States
6. Buffalo Pizza & Wings
Overall Ratings
3 based on 24 reviews
Reviewed By Tripping9900
Glad to have found this place as it is convenient (in a Publix plaza), reasonably priced and has served up good pizza on both visits. The pizza is thin with a nice, crispy crust, tasty cheese, adequate amount of sauce, good portions of toppings, and cooked just right. If you like your pizza with some juiciness to it you will not be disappointed.You can get individual slices (they are large slices) which is nice especially for lunch.No ambiance (some tables with a tv playing CNN) but the counter workers have been friendly and the menu is more than just pizza (pasta dishes, sandwiches, etc.).They deliver (minimum of $20 or $25 depending on location).
5. Buon Appetito Restaurant & Bar
Overall Ratings
4 based on 135 reviews
Come join us for authentic Southern Italian cuisine, family atmosphere, hand-made dishes, Full Bar, nightly entertainment. Buon Appetito first opened it's doors in 2004, in a small Ft Myers business community. After establishing the name "Best Kept Secret
Reviewed By johns1228
Arrived around 5PM and were immediately seated. Menus were brought and drink orders were taken. One of our party of 4 wanted something on the menu without pasta. Waitress checked with chef and no problem. Had appetizers of bruschetta and calamari, both were very very good. Dinners consisted of a chicken special(which the person who ordered) said was wonderful! Others ordered parmesan which was very good, other dinner was a white lasagna and red lasagna combo which was excellent. Said person requesting a special order received what the asked for and it too was excellent. totally a great evening. Only one suggestion-they have music on Friday night and it was way too loud if you were in the restaurant. If you were in the bar it was probably fine but when they started we couldn't even carry on a conversation. Suggestion-either lower the volume of the music or put it in the bar. Really it was awfully loud
4. Overtime Pizzeria and Sports Pub
Overall Ratings
4 based on 373 reviews
Reviewed By ilbarb01
Visited with my wife recently. It is really a great neighborhood establishment. Very reasonably priced food and drink. The menu is extensive and the food very good. Have tried sandwiches, salads, pizza and some entreeâs, all really good. Very friendly and efficient service at the bar. We especially like Gina. Will be a pleasure to return again and again. Thank you. Thank you so much for your rating and comments, we're so glad you enjoyed the food. We appreciate your business, come back again soon.
Best Southwestern food near Matlacha, Florida, United States
3. Ceno Grille
Overall Ratings
4 based on 386 reviews
Ceno Grille serves fresh, homemade Italian and Greek cuisine for lunch and dinner. For amazing food, service and atmosphere, look nowhere else! Ceno Grille is a small cozy restaurant perfect for the whole family. We have a large menu with many different o
Reviewed By Don V
Two times here in past week. Food and service was FANTASTIC! My wife had eggplant parmagian and I the their sausage. Highly suggest both! Thank you George and team!
Florida, United States Food Guide: 10 Pub food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Matlacha
2. Pine Island Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 54 reviews
Reviewed By flnine300
This is a great place for pizza. The pie was fresh, crispy, and delicious. The owners are very welcoming and helpful. Thereâs plenty of parking and seating. Very clean and well air conditioned dining room. I would highly recommend that you stop here for a meal or get carry out.
Where to eat Seafood food in Matlacha: The Best Restaurants and Bars
1. Miceli's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 1363 reviews
Casual dining, fun atmosphere, outdoor seating, live entertainment 7 days a week.
Reviewed By Steve R
been going to Miceli's since they took over for Matlacha Oyster Bar...usually awesome, but today my wife's prime rib was awful...yes the server offered to replace it after we had eaten, but trying to be nice she said ' no, that's okay '...I figured they'd adjust the bill, but they did not...I just hope this isn't an indication that they're usually high standards are going downhill...
