Location: Treasure Island
Top Restaurants in Treasure Island
Countries
Florida, United States Food Guide: 10 Italian food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Treasure Island
Best Italian restaurants nearby. Discover the best Italian food in Treasure Island. View Menus, Photos and Reviews for Italian restaurants near you.. Treasure Island is a city in Pinellas County, Florida, United States. It is situated on a barrier island in the Gulf of Mexico.
Things to do in Treasure Island
10. Mario's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 366 reviews
Reviewed By Brooksville01
Located in a non-descript strip center this tiny Italian treasure offers delicious food. This was my second visit. Very unimpressed with service the first time, I decided the food was good enough to give a second chance. Service was greatly improved, food still excellent, and they allowed us to bring our own wine, with a reasonable corkage fee. Shared the mussel appetizer with two dining companions and stopped eating only because we wanted to save room for our entrees. Serving portion was large for an appetizer and very tasty. I had the veal saltimbucca......two large pieces of veal topped with ham, cheese and the saltimbocca sauce. Another dining companion had the chicken piccata and raved about how good it was even the next day. They do not take reservations and you will likely wait for a table but it's worth it.
9. Verducci's Pizzeria & Trattoria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 1261 reviews
Authentic Italian Cuisine and Pizzeria since 1976. Making authentic Italian from scratch every day for St. Pete Beach!!!
Reviewed By GypsyTraveller94
This is a first class restaurant. The new building is airy and spacious, but you still feel privacy in your booth. Servers are experienced and friendly. Food. Well, that is why you came, right? Mussels were swimming in wine garlic sauce that screams for sopping with crusty bread. Veal special was just ok, but nice. I think good veal isnât easy to find. The salads came with dressing; no wasting time asking which kind you want. They know what is good. The lemoncello cake was a fabulous ending, and we took a pizza home! We come here every trip to SPB and we are never disappointed.
8. Palm Court Italian Grill
Overall Ratings
4 based on 1151 reviews
Tucked away at the end of the Grand Palm Colonnade at Island Grand, Palm Court Italian Grill offers an intimate dining experience with your favorite culinary creations from the Mediterranean. Enjoy a romantic candlelit dinner indoors or under the stars on
Reviewed By rfuller85
My husband and I visited St. Peteâs for our anniversary trip. We stayed at another hotel on the beach (wish we hadnât) and walked over to Palm Court for our anniversary dinner (so glad we did!) I had the lamb chops and they were amazing. My husband had one of the chicken dishes. Great food and atmosphere - would definitely recommend to anyone visiting!
7. Vito & Michael's Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 328 reviews
Reviewed By ERat
Thought Iâd give this place a try after a recommendation from our server at Bongoâs Beach Bar. We usually get our pizza from Bueno, but figured weâd try a pie from someplace new. Placed the order at 5:55 on a Saturday night, planned on a longer than usual wait...NOPE, 20 minutes! When I arrived, they were very busy. Thought for sure Iâd have to wait another 10 mins or so. Nope, order was hot and ready when I arrived. Pizza was good, not true NY style, but still really good. Philly cheese steak was good too. Not authentic Philly style with cheese wiz and onions, but close enough for a restaurant 900 miles from Philadelphia. I would return and would recommend for anyone to give it a try.
6. Carino's Italian Caffe
Overall Ratings
4 based on 238 reviews
Reviewed By 184cherh
The Mussels were huge and the sauce delicious!! We had the Special, crab meat, shrimp over linguine. The house sauce/Gravy is amazing! Service was excellent! Prices fair. A little dated as far as decor, but very very clean!! Has a piano bar as well. Highly recommend!! We definitely be returning here!!
5. Tuttorosso Pizzeria Napoletana
Overall Ratings
4 based on 359 reviews
Reviewed By firefighter4u
We are in the area on vacation and wanted pizza for a rainy evening. We were seated right away. Nice atmosphere. Waiter seemed aloof. Pizza itself was ok, nothing special. Garlic balls were good. Probably will go elsewhere next time for pizza.
Where to eat Cafe food in Treasure Island: The Best Restaurants and Bars
4. Feola's Italian Ristorante & Lounge
Overall Ratings
4 based on 386 reviews
Join us for great food and drinks. Located in The Thunderbird Beach Resort on the sandy shores of Treasure Island. All of your favorite Italian dishes along with other favorites such as Buffalo Wings, Quesadillas, and Burgers!Come in as early as 8 am for
Reviewed By LovinOurLives
Shelly is the best Bartender in Feola's!! We are there every week and she takes good care of us! Thank you Shelly! Roben & Rich
3. Gigi's Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 718 reviews
Reviewed By A-kaYak-ur
There were just 3 of us and "the babe", as we call the goddess. Our granddaughter. Service was good and we were seated almost immediately. Nice considering some eateries on the beach almost always have a wait time.The pasta dishes were all quality dishes with ample servings of gravy (yes, gravy is indeed the red sauce we all call "sauce"). All in all, we would likely give this eatery an above average rating. If the competition between restaurants weren't so stiff along the gulf beaches, the rating would be more like a very good.Don't hesitate to enjoy a good Italian meal at Gigis!!
Best Seafood food near Treasure Island, Florida, United States
2. Britt's Coal Fire Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 1076 reviews
Britt's Pizza has delicious homemade pizza, pasta, subs, and more made fresh. Our pizza and pasta sauce explodes with flavor, and we also have zesty subs and salads. Come in or call today, and experience the great flavor of Britt's Pizza!!
Reviewed By Jerseyfla
Ordered our first pizza from Britt's as a takeout. The price charged was more than was listed online as well as in the restaurant's menu. Cashier didn't seem to care. Toppings on the "Supreme" were skimpy, only partially cut, and the crust was partially burned. I won't be going back.We are sorry you had this experience we will review our prices to make sure they are adjusted and match accordingly!
Most Popular Contemporary food in Treasure Island, Florida, United States
1. Original Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 374 reviews
Reviewed By Geraldine M
My husband and I love a good pizza and this one didn't disappoint. We had the meat lovers 12 inch for lunch. With a couple of beer, it hit the spot. The sauce was good with tons of cheese and meat. The crust delicious. They have a large menu with burgers and tacos. So everyone would be happy. Price very reasonable. We will return in the next few days! We will be back next year.
