Location: Phelps
Top Restaurants in Phelps
Top Things to do in Phelps
Countries
Best Pizza food near Phelps, New York, United States
Discover Restaurants offering the best Pizza food in Phelps, New York, United States. Norman Teed (D)
Things to do in Phelps
10. Ciccino's Pizzeria & Restaurant
Overall Ratings
3 based on 129 reviews
Reviewed By tracees2018
My husband and I had dinner here. My husband works in Geneva and has had the pizza there prior, and enjoyed it. The restaurant was nicely decorated and had plenty of seating for a Friday evening. I had the chicken Caprese and my husband ordered a wrap. My husband enjoyed his wrap. Unfortunately, my chicken was very bland.I ordered the vegetables as a side,which tasted like they were from a frozen bag right out of the freezer. I had to ask for bread for the meal as well. I found it amusing that the house wine was a boxed wine, in the heat of wine country. Even the staff was bland, our waitress didn't even introduce herself. I don't believe I will give this restaurant another chance, I was disappointed.
9. Domino's Pizza
Visit your Newark Domino's Pizza today for a signature pizza or oven baked sandwich. We have coupons and specials on pizza delivery, pasta, buffalo wings, & more! Order online now!
Reviewed By sandiv2016
I live local so I have the pizza delivered, I have never been into the shop, I don't know anything about clean, or friendly staff.
8. Salvatore's Pizza
Reviewed By sandiv2016
Staff was pleasant. Pizza was good but very expensive. Over fifty dollars for one pizza and wings. Only two soft drinks.
7. Pontillo's Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 14 reviews
Reviewed By mdkadk
Landing on the Newark Canal and listening to a village concert got us in the mood so we walked across the river and landed at Pontillo's. Ordered up a medium 'roni and black olive, and sipped our Orange Crush while we waited. Pie came out hot, with abundant toppings. I would prefer more sauce, but the crust was good - not spectacular but a good chew to it. Price was the biggest problem - $13 for a 12 inch two topping is a bit steep. Not a large menu as we were hoping for calzones but settled for the pie. Definitiely worth stopping for the flavor - if you've got the cash. Located above the Canal docks, go out back and enjoy the waterfront view!
6. Sbarro
Home of the original XL NY Slice. Since 1956, Sbarro has been serving the XL NY Slice. Starting with made-daily hand stretched dough, San Marzano style sauce and topped with 100% Whole Milk Mozzarella cheese.
Reviewed By Horty83
While I wasn't expecting much from a service plaza restaurant, the meal was terrible. $14 for a small plate of spaghetti, Caesar salad, a breadstick and a drink. While none of the options looked promising, I can't imagine them being worse than my choice. The spaghetti was the worst I've had. The salad was the only item I had any hope for yet it was soggy and the croutons were just gross. I would have been upset spending 5$. I won't be eating at Sbarro again.
5. Cams New York Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 76 reviews
Reviewed By Denise C
Great wings and pizza. My favorite is the white garlic pizza. You need to buy the xlarge to get the thin crist. Thats the only way i like my garlic pizza.
What to do and see in Phelps, United States: The Best Places and Tips
4. Uncle Joe's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 100 reviews
Reviewed By brandylei12
I got a pepperoni pizza and cheese sticks and both were very mediocre. The cheese sticks were probably the most disappointing not just because they werenât hot but just the breading tasted uncooked and like cornmeal. The pizza wasnât to my liking other than the crust I will say the crust was soft and I could have eaten an order of just that but the pizza left me under whelmed and made me wish Iâd just got out to eat or gotten a pizza from a chain. Really wish Iâd loved it like my friend did.
Phelps Food Guide: 10 Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Phelps
3. Halsey's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 408 reviews
Reviewed By Onhill
We walked in without reservations and they told us they could accommodate us in about 5 minutes, so we had a drink at the bar and were promptly seated. Had a great waitress and enjoyed some local wine and beer, along with some salads and pizza made in the wood fired brick oven.Traveled here by boat, from the home we rented on the east side of Seneca Lake, and utilized the free town docks near the Ramada to tie up for this dinner visit. It was a short 5 - 7 minute walk to Halseyâs and we enjoyed walking through the vibrant area. We caught the tail end of the sunset as we boated back to the house, after our pleasant dining experience.
Where to eat Pub food in Phelps: The Best Restaurants and Bars
2. Nima's Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 21 reviews
Reviewed By U634XYjeffb
Food: ordered two toasted subs and both were excellent. We are Clifton Springs natives back for an overnight visit and were hoping for classic NY toasted subs and we were thrilled to get what we had hoped. The bread was great, the meat was plentiful, and the sandwiches were the best we had in years.Value: around $7.50 each per large sub which is a good value. Well worth the money spent.Service: pretty average. Older lady who served us seemed worn out and overworked although they had only been open for 3 hours and weren't very busy. But unfortunately there's more mediocre service these days than service to brag about.Overall a great visit and I strongly recommend their subs.
1. Lapresi's Pizza Emporium
Reviewed By Evelyn Deb J
I've been enjoying Lapresi's food for 20 years now and it's always the same-delicious! The pizza is just right-light and tasty red sauce, crust that's a touch crispy around the edges-and my personal favorite, crumbled sausage. They have all sorts of subs too, and their wings are great!Friendly staff and consistent quality are what keep me going back again and again. I definitely recommend them for fast, fresh, delicious food.
