Location: Newcomerstown
Top Restaurants in Newcomerstown
Countries
Best Pizza food near Newcomerstown, Ohio, United States
Discover Restaurants offering the best Pizza food in Newcomerstown, Ohio, United States. Newcomerstown is a village in Tuscarawas County, Ohio, United States, 85 miles (137 km) east-northeast of Columbus. In the late 1770s, this was the largest Delaware Indian village on the Tuscarawas River, with 700 residents. Chief Newcomer (Netawatwes) was the leader of the western Delawares here, and they called the village Gekelmukpechunk. Early French traders and English settlers named the village Newcomerstown after the chief. Soon after the start of the American Revolutionary War, the Delawares moved west to Coshocton, about halfway through what is now the next county.
Things to do in Newcomerstown
1. Terry's Pizza Shoppe
Reviewed By 19Pink69
Very small town pizza shop that uses frozen pizza crust. Buffet is offered most of the day, which is ok if you like watered down spaghetti sauce, "garlic" bread that is mostly just bread (no butter and garlic), and wilted lettuce. They do put their wings on the buffet and I cannot say anything bad about those. Now, they did have very good deep fried chicken, but the last 2 times we ordered it, the pieces looked to be from baby chickens. Friday nights they have an all u can eat fish dinner, and that is also pretty good. Would I recommend this place? NO...will I go back? NO. The owner made a VERY rude comment about an overweight customer, thinking nobody caught what he said. I was disgusted and never went back. Cleanliness needs some work. Walls are decorated with sports memorabilia.
2. Domino's Pizza
Visit your Newcomerstown Domino's Pizza today for a signature pizza or oven baked sandwich. We have coupons and specials on pizza delivery, pasta, buffalo wings, & more! Order online now!
Reviewed By NFTravller1
When I travel, sometimes I just want something consistent and quick that isn't a hassle. Domino's locations usually are great at this.I was staying at a local Hotel, not far from the restaurant, however, even though they offer delivery, for some reason they wouldn't come to my hotel. Therefore I decided to take the 2-3 minute drive to pick up the pizza.Upon arrival, my food was ready on time, and payment was quick. They did not have on hand the red pepper flakes I ordered however (this is not unusual for Domino's - not sure why they offer them as a choice on there website when most locations don't have them). No big deal as it has happened dozen of times before.The sides I ordered were as expected, however, the pizza had an odd taste - the cheese was odd, and had a strong garlic flavor for a pepperoni pizza. Just wasn't a good taste compared to what I expect from Domino's - very inconsistent to other locations. Could be that Domino's has a different taste profile in Ohio when compared to New York and the rest of the country?Anyways, disappointed by the delivery not being available, and the taste not being comparable to other locations.
3. Amici's Pizza West Lafayette
Reviewed By leelee1317
Cute little hometown pizza shop that has changed hands many times over the years. Alan and his wife do it right! Their food is great and they Center the decor around the towns high school sports, which is a big deal in this town. They hire kids from the local community and support a lot of school activities and community activities. And there's nothing on the menu that isn't fantastic!
