Location: Bayville
Top Restaurants in Bayville
Top Things to do in Bayville
- 1. Sagamore Hill National Historic Site
- 2. Caumsett State Park
- 3. Bayville Adventure Park
- 4. Shu Swamp Preserve - Charles T Church Nature Preserve
- 5. John P. Humes Japanese Stroll Garden
- 6. Morgan Memorial Park
- 7. Bruce Museum
- 8. Sands Point Preserve
- 9. Cold Spring Harbor Fish Hatchery & Aquarium
- 10. Nassau County Museum of Art
Countries
Best Pizza food near Bayville, New York, United States
Find out what Pizza restaurants to try in Bayville. The Village of Bayville, often referred to as Pine Island, is a village located on Long Island Sound facing Greenwich, Connecticut. The Incorporated Village of Bayville is located within the town of Oyster Bay in Nassau County, New York, United States. The population was 6,669 at the 2010 census. The village was incorporated in 1919 during the incorporated village movement which allowed many larger estate owners on Long Island to establish political and security control over their domains.
Things to do in Bayville
10. La Pala Bistro
Overall Ratings
4 based on 20 reviews
Reviewed By Arthur B
It was a freezing weekday night so the restaurant wasn't exactly crowded. The owner (?) was very friendly and accommodating. I ordered something unusual, at least for me. It was a combination of pasta with fresh mozzarella and tomatoes - served hot - sort of a hot caprice salad on noodles. It was excellent, but could have been hotter. I'd go back.
9. La Casa Rustica Family Style
Reviewed By dinerone1
The appetizers were so good we almost couldn't eat dinner. It was somewhat dark and quiet. The portions ase very generous. I would recommend the Osso Bucco or any pasta dish.
8. Forest Avenue Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 21 reviews
Reviewed By Susan H
A friend of mine loves this place - and I don't know why. Pizza is nothing special. We had a 12" pizza with mushrooms (rubbery - from a bottle), sausage (sliced flavorless) and onions (undercooked). Service was lackluster. Many better places to eat in Locust Valley and Glen Cove.
7. Locust Valley Pizzeria
Reviewed By Winie62
I am a pizza lover. I discovered the Grandma pie here and it is one of the best. Crust is good with Fresh Mozzerella & basil. Also had the Tuscany Chicken hero. Fresh grilled chicken w/ roasted peppers & fresh Mozzerella.
6. Vito's Ristorante & Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 21 reviews
We are proud to offer delicious traditional Italian cuisine to Long Island. Stop by today and see what everyone is talking about!
Reviewed By Sharon_B_NY
Came here as a family of eight. Good food and good service except when the young waiter spilt the marinara sauce down my back while clearing the table. All at the table enjoyed their food.
Most Popular Mexican food in Bayville, New York, United States
5. IT BGL
it.bgl is a wood burning oven, all-day eatery focusing on wood fired bagels & pizza, coming soon to Oyster Bay, NY.
Reviewed By Mikecarstop
Upon entering this new establishment, we were greeted by staff, and talked to the owners. The interior decor is creative and in good taste. There are plenty of tables to sit at with comfortable chairs. The wall menu states many foods including sandwiches, salads, and pizza. Their bagels are made on premise and have a nice texture and tasty. After ordering, the meal is delivered to your table, or take out. The food is fresh, good combinations, and filling. The location is clean, staff is friendly, and helpful, and street parking is plentiful. Looking forward to my next visit in the area and stopping by to eat at IT BGL.
4. Mario's Pizzeria of Oyster Bay
Overall Ratings
4 based on 35 reviews
Reviewed By walterw457
The restaurant was easy to find, adequate parking and the interior was clean. There were numerous pizza varieties to choose from. The two slices I tried were great. Each slice had an abundance of toppings, they were flavorful and the crust was light and crispy. All in all it was one of the better New York pizzerias I've been to. I'll definitely return if I find myself in this area again.
Where to eat Italian food in Bayville: The Best Restaurants and Bars
3. Pietro's Brick Oven Pizza
Reviewed By Cynthia V
This place is under new management. Ever since that happened the food there is amazing! Everything there is good from the entrees to the pizza and the calzones and stuffed rolls. Their service is also great. After a few times of going there they remember you. My husband and I have gotten take out food from there and also have sat down and ate there. All the times we've gone there the food has been wonderful! I would definitely recommend going here to anyone in the Oyster Bay area!
2. Nino's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 20 reviews
Reviewed By John P
Hands down best regular pizza. Very spoiled and picky pizza lover. - 2 well down slices and garlic knots with oil
Where to eat American food in Bayville: The Best Restaurants and Bars
1. Ralph's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 33 reviews
Reviewed By impactbk1
Ralph's Pizza restaurant has always been a focal point for locals and visitors to Bayville by the "sea.For over 50 years Ralph's has served some of the finest pizza on Long Island! Family owned and operated with a small town friendliness and gracious hospitality.In 2017 the original owners sold Ralphs to a hardworking coupleWho came here from Italy. Connie and Pasquale have spruced up and tastefully renovated Ralph's with a new decor, tables, chairs, and an exciting new menu! Today Ralph's continues to offer some of the best pizza on Long Island, as well as authentic fine Italian dining.I had the pleasure of sampling some of Connie's new dishes and her awesome pizza and pastry. Our meal began with a small plate of Ralphs new homemade bread..mouthwateringly delicious with a small bowl of Tuscany extra virgin olive oil for dipping..Connie then served a pizza sampler plate of assorted pizza squares :Pizza topped with eggplant marinara, Grandma Pizza made with mozzarella cheese and a lite and delicious red sauce. A spectacular baked clams marinara pizza made with An out of this world bechemel sauce, and bacon! As good as it gets !For our main course we shared a large Veal Chop Valdostana medium ,served with a creamy mozzarella topping. Our vegetable was a perfectly made broccoli rabbA meal that could have been served in one of long islands best Italian restaurantsConnie wanted us to finish our meal on a sweet note and served us homemade cannoli's in two flavor a regular plain cannoli and a chocolate chip cannoli. An amazing way to end s superb Italian feast!Kudos to Connie and Pasquale on the beginning of a new era of excellence at the new Ralph's in Bayville!
Top 3 International food in Bayville, New York, United States
