Location: Allegany
Top Restaurants in Allegany
Countries
Best Pizza food near Allegany, New York, United States
Find out what Pizza restaurants to try in Allegany. Allegany is a town in Cattaraugus County, New York, United States. The population was 8,004 at the 2010 census.
Things to do in Allegany
8. Napoli Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 19 reviews
Reviewed By Linda55vac
Napoli is the best place in Olean for pizza. The Friday night fish fries are really good. You can sit in the dining room with family or grab a bite in the relaxing bar area. Friday night brings live music. Love the bartenders and Tony. FUN place to be during good weather out front on the patio.
7. Pizza Hut
Reviewed By Lou327
Have been here several times over the years and never had a problem. While traveling through the area, I called ahead to have pizza ready so I only had to stop in and pick up and was very happy that the staff informed me how to best get to the restaurant since there was a lot of construction prior to my arrival. Classic Pizza Hut food.
6. The Broken Wing Pizzeria & Grille
Overall Ratings
4 based on 18 reviews
Reviewed By nylady21
The personal flatbread pizza with pulled pork was exceptional. Great crispy crust and abundant, high quality toppings. The Buffalo chicken wrap had a wonderful, thin pizza-like crust. There were a number of different craft beers in addition to the standards. Service was friendly and attentive. The atmosphere was warm, with background music that allowed for conversation. Great place with many regular locals, but we were warmly welcomed too. Excellent value.
5. Brooklyn Bakery
Reviewed By Hammer132014
We lucked out finding this place during our stay in Olean. This choice came via recommendation from a local couple I talked to about good pizza places. What a great choice! This is wood fired, stone oven, absolutely delicious pizza. It was delivered hot. Oh, and it was delicious!! Great pizza, great price, quick delivery!.....all adds up to two thumbs up!
4. Domino's Pizza
Visit your Olean Domino's Pizza today for a signature pizza or oven baked sandwich. We have coupons and specials on pizza delivery, pasta, buffalo wings, & more! Order online now!
Reviewed By considerthis24
We got pizza from the Olean Domino's while on vacation recently. We are grateful to the gentleman who helped us (assistant manager, I believe) because they accommodated a severe nut allergy in our family, which we really appreciated. Thank you.
3. Mio Gelato E Cafe
Reviewed By CharliesAngel2013
I don't give out excellent ratings very often, LOL. But Mio Gelato deserves those five circles! I haven't gone here in a while but went a couple of weeks ago with my son and my mom. I wasn't expecting anything spectacular, but I was really pleasantly surprised. We just ordered a large pizza, which I already know is by far, the best pizza in town. The girls working were very friendly and took the time to offer different options. They were even very patient with my son who has a hard time deciding on things, but they never once rolled their eyes, tapped the table with their pen or did any of the other signs of annoyance that teenage workers usually do. In fact, all of the employees really impressed me. They were very attentive to all of us and the pizza maker was showing my son how he makes the pizzas. I had the lemonade, which they fresh squeeze! I'm pretty sure its the only place in town you can get that. The place is very clean and has plenty of seating. The tables all have pizza stands like authentic Italian restaurants. This is the best thin crust pizza you will find. No matter where I go, I always compare the pizza to this. Then we had dessert. There is a very nice selection of desserts from a variety of flavors of gelato to traditional canolis to cheesecake and themed brownies. My mom and I both had the gelato and my son had an M&M brownie. The gelato was huge! The brownie must have been pretty good too since my son ate every bit of it.
2. Tasta Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 42 reviews
Reviewed By justinsL9355ME
Can't go wrong with there pizza and wings here. There's always that moment when someone says "I want taste pizza"! Really quick service and recently renovated so I'm guessing the prices will refelct. Although I'm a believer in u get what u pay for. I have no problem paying for it if it's good.
Where to eat American food in Allegany: The Best Restaurants and Bars
1. Graffiti Pizza and More
Overall Ratings
4 based on 18 reviews
Reviewed By brandon d
Best pizza around! they're open late and the staff is always friendly and very accommodating. any topping you can think of is available, and the portions are immense! Ive ordered multiple times and never had a bad experience, they even have a signature "lasagna" pizza which is to die for!
