Location: Orange Park
Top Restaurants in Orange Park
Top Things to do in Orange Park
Countries
Best Italian food near Orange Park, Florida, United States
Discover Restaurants offering the best Italian food in Orange Park, Florida, United States. Orange Park is a town in Clay County, Florida, United States, and a suburb of Jacksonville. The population was 8,412 at the 2010 census. The name "Orange Park" is additionally applied to a wider area of northern Clay County outside the town limits, covering such communities as Fleming Island, Lakeside, and Bellair-Meadowbrook Terrace.
Things to do in Orange Park
10. Luca's Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 48 reviews
Reviewed By MammaShibs
With so many chain restaurants in the area, it is a treat to visit a family owned business. Jackie (Luca's spouse) was our server and she took care of our party of 5.I enjoyed the Chicken Luca with lemon garlic over Fettuccini and everyone else had a great meal.Wonderful relaxing experience.We will definitely come back to visit.
9. Picasso's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 217 reviews
Reviewed By Loonytuna
The name of this restaurant does not do it justice it is not just a pizzeria, though the people I have been there with that love pizza love the pizza here.This is a much better Italian Restaurant & Beyond! I am originally from the Northeast where Italian food is very real and very good, there are serious deficiencies in the quality of Italian food here in Jacksonville.But not at Picasso's! They make meatballs that can compete with the best I've ever had, their sauce while a little bit spicy for me, is fantastic.But here's the kicker, being from the New York area and loving pastrami sandwiches I have been hunting for a decent pastrami sandwich since I arrived in Jacksonville 5 years ago, and until last night I had no success. But last night I had the pastrami sandwich, or correction, the 1/2 of pastrami sandwich, which was the size of a good size pastrami sandwich anywhere else, and found that it was good enough to compete with most of the pastrami sandwiches I've had in the Northeast.To the owners of Picasso's I would say thank you! I would also say, while I don't put your pastrami sandwich in the same class as Katz's Deli in New York City, I think it is better than everything I've had almost everywhere else! I hope you take this as a compliment oh, it is meant to be the highest compliment.So in closing, all I can say to those who have not been to Picasso's, get there as soon as you can, be hungry, and enjoy some of the best food you're going to have in the Jacksonville area.Finally, one last thing, the wait staff is absolutely perfect.
8. Moon Dog Pie House
Overall Ratings
4 based on 158 reviews
Moon Dog pie house serves authentic made to order New York Thin and Chicago deep dish pizzas in an eclectic, funky and family-friendly environment. Full menu includes sandwiches, salads, pasta, wings, and desserts. Expanded bar area with 13 beers on tap.
Reviewed By Hollynover
Weâve been having dinner at Moon Dog Pie House for 3 years. My husband and 5 year old son always spilt a pizza. One half with no sauce, the other half with sauce. We go there about 1 time a month. Tonight, a Monday night with many open tables, we were told the cook said they were too busy to do âno sauceâ on half the pizza. Itâs never been an issue before but tonight it was. We cancelled our order and found another restaurant nearby that was more than happy to accommodate our request. I am terribly sorry to hear about your experience Holly. Please feel free to reach lut to me so I may attempt to make things right. Kamus McNair (General Manager)
7. Vito's Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 46 reviews
We are a small family owned pizzeria. Our menu is small so we can concentrate on fresh quality food. We'd love for you to give us a try! We offer dine-in, carry out & free delivery (limited area).
Reviewed By Dwight K
We've been trying all the pizzeria's around us over the last year, and Vito's is our favorite by far. The folks working there are really friendly, pizza is made fast and is delicious! Prices are very reasonable too. We've always done carry-out, but will likely dine in at some point. Only downside for us is that it is a 20-minute drive to Vito's from were we live, but it's worth the drive, even though the pizza isn't steaming hot by the time we get home. Worth the trip every time!!!Hello, and thank you for taking the time to leave such a positive review of your experience with us.!We are a small family owned and operated pizzeria and truly appreciate our customers!We would love to have you dine in with us sometime.â¤We hope you have a great Thanksgiving and look forward to seeing you soon!
6. Enza's Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 335 reviews
Welcome to Enza's Italian Restaurant offering Italian Cuisine in a relaxed and contemporary atmosphere. Join us for live piano music 6 nights a week on our baby grand at "My Husband's Bar"
Reviewed By joannr472
The food was AMAZING!!! The food was like my wonderful grandma's. The service was so good. I felt like I was on a cruise, the atmosphere, the attention, only thing missing was looking out into the water! The anniversary dessert, tiramisu was decorated with hearts and happy anniversary in chocolate! Not to mention it was AWESOME! We will be back!
5. NYC Meatballs
Overall Ratings
4 based on 64 reviews
Reviewed By Suzanne Y
Don't let the name fool you, there's so much more to NYC Meatballs than meatballs!!!!The hand-tossed pizza is amazing! The wings are so good, they have a cult following.The garlic knots, fried pickles and mozzarella sticks are awesome appetizers. But the insider secret is that NYC Meatballs is the only place in Clay County, and one of the very few in Northeast Florida, to serve authentic poutine. Being married to a Quebecer, our family knows poutine and NYC is the place to go for the real stuff!!!!!!!In fact, we've never been disappointed with anything we tried there.The owner is super friendly and very community focused. Service is great! They have recently expanded to keep up with the demand. It looks great and there's tons more seating. Definitely the place to go in Oakleaf!
4. Joey Mozzarella
Overall Ratings
4 based on 541 reviews
Reviewed By Suzanne Y
Tucked away in a little strip mall on Blanding, there's one of the best Mom and Pop style Italian restaurants in Northeast Florida. The garlic knots that come with all pasta meals (or can be ordered on their own) are wickedly delicious. They are homemade and amazing! Just the knots alone would make you want to return.The pasta dishes were amazing!!! My husband had the chicken parmesan. If had a delicate breading that let the chicken be the star of the dish. Delicious!I ordered one of the specials - Basil Chicken and Shrimp. The sauce was an alfredo with spinach and tomatoes in it. Wow! This was easily the best pasta dish I can ever remember eating in a restaurant. And it was huge!The staff is super friendly and attentive. Much to my delight, it was also BYOB. And the neighboring strip mall has a grocery store with a good selection. To make the whole package even better, their prices are excellent! It cost less than a meal for 2 at a chain Italian restaurant and was 100% better.
3. Santioni's Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 223 reviews
Authentic home cooked Italian Food served in a casual fine dining atmosphere. Our banquet room is perfect for events of up to 50 people. We offer catering, catering delivery and a drive-up window for your take out order.
Reviewed By Brenda S
If you want a delightful atmosphere and delicious food this is the place. The food is very good. I have tried several different entrees and all have been delicious. The bread is delicious. Service is excellent. The live piano music adds a nice touch, too. For a relaxed evening and delicious dinner, I highly recommend this family restaurant.Brenda, that you so much for capturing the essence of our goals in your review! Great food, great service and great ambience!
Where to eat American food in Orange Park: The Best Restaurants and Bars
2. Enza's Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 335 reviews
Welcome to Enza's Italian Restaurant offering Italian Cuisine in a relaxed and contemporary atmosphere. Join us for live piano music 6 nights a week on our baby grand at "My Husband's Bar"
Reviewed By joannr472
The food was AMAZING!!! The food was like my wonderful grandma's. The service was so good. I felt like I was on a cruise, the atmosphere, the attention, only thing missing was looking out into the water! The anniversary dessert, tiramisu was decorated with hearts and happy anniversary in chocolate! Not to mention it was AWESOME! We will be back!
1. Moon Dog Pie House
Overall Ratings
4 based on 158 reviews
Moon Dog pie house serves authentic made to order New York Thin and Chicago deep dish pizzas in an eclectic, funky and family-friendly environment. Full menu includes sandwiches, salads, pasta, wings, and desserts. Expanded bar area with 13 beers on tap.
Reviewed By Hollynover
Weâve been having dinner at Moon Dog Pie House for 3 years. My husband and 5 year old son always spilt a pizza. One half with no sauce, the other half with sauce. We go there about 1 time a month. Tonight, a Monday night with many open tables, we were told the cook said they were too busy to do âno sauceâ on half the pizza. Itâs never been an issue before but tonight it was. We cancelled our order and found another restaurant nearby that was more than happy to accommodate our request. I am terribly sorry to hear about your experience Holly. Please feel free to reach lut to me so I may attempt to make things right. Kamus McNair (General Manager)
