Location: Oconomowoc
Top Restaurants in Oconomowoc
Top Things to do in Oconomowoc
Countries
Best Italian food near Oconomowoc, Wisconsin, United States
Discover Restaurants offering the best Italian food in Oconomowoc, Wisconsin, United States. Oconomowoc /oʊˈkɑːnəməˌwɑːk/ is a city in Waukesha County, Wisconsin, United States. The name was derived from Coo-no-mo-wauk, the Potawatomi term for "waterfall." The population was 15,712 at the 2010 census. The city is partially adjacent to the Town of Oconomowoc and near the village of Oconomowoc Lake, Wisconsin.
Things to do in Oconomowoc
1. Rosati's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 161 reviews
Rosati's Pizza provides the best handmade food, dine-in, carryout, delivery, and catering to the Oconomowoc, WI area.
Reviewed By howitstacks
Several friendly people were at the front entrance to greet us and we were seated right away. We decided also immediately after being seated we wanted to try the chicago style pizza, which we did after a VERY long wait. Our waitress, bless her heart, was working her butt off, but what were all the people by the door doing? We knew to expect a wait for the pizza, so that was NOT the issue. When the pizza came it looked great, but this missed on a lot of levels. (Not enough seasoning in the sauce, crust-meh, undercooked veggies) I will say that the regular/thin crust pizza looked better, but who knows, right?After dinner we waiting a painfully long time (20 minutes maybe) while our waitress was working her butt off before we got our check. The phone was constantly ringing loudly and I could see they were sending a ton of carry out pizzas out, but I still didn't quite understand why with so many staff our waitress was on so many tables.
2. Bella Gusto
Overall Ratings
4 based on 47 reviews
Reviewed By CheeseheadwithTaste
I've really tried hard each time we have been in this deli?, restaurant?, wine bar? to put it on our lists of nice places in Oconomowoc, but can't yet. Oconomowoc is a revitalized downtown now getting more competitive for our dining dollars. The owners/mgrs of this deli need to better focus on service, and not chit chating, wine tasting, flitting around, or just being ambivalent when customers step in, because it is a confusing environment. It doesn't feel friendly We think you order your food at the counter, but they always seem disinterested. The wine prices are pretty high by the glass and you have to order at the deli counter, I guess? This place fills a "short order" need in town but I will agree with other reviewers that the items in the deli cases are very limited, likely desserts they don't make. Not a lot of food that you can see. Then do you sit at a table, then get up to order? Wine this way seems strange. I think a huge improvement would be for them to actually wait on your table....this would make it all better. Or at least greet you and explain what to do. Wish I could comment on the food, but never have gotten to the point of ordering. Just bought sauces and noodles off the shelf to support this as a local stop. For food, Solbie's around the corner and The Irish Pub (fine dining) get our vote and dollars.
3. Eric's hand tossed pizza & subs
Overall Ratings
4 based on 26 reviews
Reviewed By siefs
Eric's is a family owned sub and pizza restaurant that makes wonderful fresh made food. The pizza is so good and the sandwiches are super delicious. The meatball sub is, as they say: "To Die For" with its homemade meatballs and sauce. The food value is very good and you won't be disappointed.
4. Lago Su Bella
Overall Ratings
4 based on 19 reviews
Reviewed By TheBopMan
First time here. So glad we found it. Food was excellent, beautiful lake view, service by our server, Fabiano, was wonderful. She was so helpful with suggestions. Menu reminded us of being in Sicily at a restaurant. Wonderful Sicilian food. Most delicious scallops I've EVER had. Soupa of the day was delicious. Nicely decorated. Wonderful open view of the lake. Large selection of Italian wines. Definitely became a favorite restaurant of ours.
