Location: Montauk
Top Restaurants in Montauk
Countries
Best Italian food near Montauk, New York, United States
Reviews on Italian food in Montauk, New York, United States. A 200-year-old lighthouse serves as a beacon for the Long Island town of Montauk, where fishing, beachcombing, kayaking and surfing vie for your attention. Pack a camera and binoculars for seal watching walks in Montauk Point State Park during the winter. Second House, a 1700s cottage built for East Hampton shepherds, adds to the local history. Summer season brings live music to the town's pubs and cafes. Hither Hills State Park provides access to ocean swimming, a 40-acre freshwater pond and camp sites.
Things to do in Montauk
7. Pulcinella East
Reviewed By TheSecretVagabond
My family of 4 very much enjoyed our recent dinner here. Each waiter provided unbelievably friendly and professional service that felt sincere and enthusiastic. From appetizer to dessert, each course impressed with presentation and flavor. The bolognese was among the best Iâve tried. The sauce on my gnocchi sorrentino was fresh and delicious. The serving size was quite large; I was full but wanted to keep eating the sauce because it was so good. The only complaint: my daughterâs spaghetti needed to boil for another 2-3 minutes. Excellent cappuccino. The bill for an appetizer, 4 entrees, a dessert, 2 cappuccinos, and 2 alcoholic beverages was $180. You can sit outside by the water or indoors. Very nice casual-upscale atmosphere. Weâd return and recommend. A good spot for a special occasion dinner.
Most Popular Healthy food in Montauk, New York, United States
6. La Fine at Montauk Manor
Overall Ratings
4 based on 53 reviews
La Fine is a family style, Italian influenced restaurant that brings the taste of home to Montauk, Long Island. Our inspired menu is comprised of classic Italian dishes as well as chef favorites. Our made-to-order dishes and celebrated recipes provide our
Reviewed By joeybabenewyork
Two years ago we had our wedding reception here, the food was exceptional, the service was great, reasonably pricedThank you for taking the time to leave us such a beautiful review, We are so glad to hear you had great time and hopefully see you soon again.
5. Sausages Pizza & Pastabilities
Overall Ratings
4 based on 64 reviews
Reviewed By funtimefamily12
We planned on going to Hooked, but it was closed as were other restaurants in the off season. We stopped for pizza and garlic knots. Pizza was terrible. Sauce was watery, cheese was overly greasy and slice was paper thin. My husband asked when the pizzas were made they guy said I just took them out of oven. Yeah right. Garlic knots were ok.
4. Primavera Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 54 reviews
Primavera Pizza located in Montauk NY, serves Brick-oven pizza, focaccia sandwiches & salads turned out in easygoing surrounds with lawn seating.
Reviewed By SueSue1121
We were walking around the town and wanted a little something for lunch so we stopped in and the pizza was great.
3. South Edison
Overall Ratings
4 based on 179 reviews
Join us at South Edison and enjoy an eclectic menu packed with local seafood, & farm fresh produce. Executive Chef, and newly acquired Owner, Frankie Fuschetto, continues to craft new dishes that complement our customersâ favorites. Frankie has performed
Reviewed By Nancy T
We were looking forward to dinner at this cute little spot, but found it a disappointment. Prices for the dishes are about $5-10 more than they ought to be, and the service was just plain awful â from the seater, who made us wait ten minutes even though the table weâd reserved was empty, to the waiter who was unable to or uninterested in giving us info about the pasta dish, to the server who delivered ONE oyster, then, when we pointed out weâd ordered half a dozen, exclaimed âWhy would they send you ONE OYSTER?!â We canât imagine why...but we do know we wonât ever be back.We apologize this happened and you feel this way. We would like to be given a chance to come back in and fix this situation. We have new staff and love to have you give us a 2nd chance. Feel free to contact us and weâll handle this personally
Where to eat Sushi food in Montauk: The Best Restaurants and Bars
2. Scarpetta Beach
Overall Ratings
4 based on 201 reviews
Scarpetta is LDV Hospitality's signature restaurant concept that first launched in New York's Meatpacking District. The Italian expression, "fare la scarpetta," describes the gesture of taking the little boot-shaped piece of bread to soak up the remaining
Reviewed By GregF
We enjoyed an excellent dinner at Scarpetta Beach at Gurney's. We asked for a outside table with our reservation, and we seated along the railing with a wonderful view of the ocean, beach and sunset. Superb location!We started with two excellent drinks - their âSan Remoâ and âPalermo Old Fashioned" cocktails, both spins on a Negroni. Nice, generous pours of liquor, as there should have been for $19 each.The fluke crudo was good; I wish, however, I had tried the yellowfin. Our waiter described the black cod as "blackened and spicy." Thankfully, it was neither. The skin on top was spiced, but mildly so. Very tasty dish, perfectly prepared. My wife enjoyed the lavender glazed duck. Very pleasant evening dining under the stars, and the culinary highlight of our visit to "The End."
1. Pizza Village
Overall Ratings
4 based on 265 reviews
Pizza Village has been serving high quality pizza and delicious Italian meals since 1957. We serve a huge variety of pizza and a full Italian menu. We serve fresh salads, soups, appetizers, heroes, and hot traditional Italian dinners. We are open daily ye
Reviewed By LollysLook
Itâs a quick and easy dinner at Pizza Village. They have good Italian entrees and slices in a casual setting.
