Location: Hackettstown
Top Restaurants in Hackettstown
Top Things to do in Hackettstown
Countries
Best Italian food near Hackettstown, New Jersey, United States
Reviews on Italian food in Hackettstown, New Jersey, United States. Hackettstown is a town in Warren County, New Jersey, United States. As of the 2010 United States Census, the town's population was 9,724, reflecting a decline of 679 (-6.5%) from the 10,403 counted in the 2000 Census, which had in turn increased by 2,283 (+28.1%) from the 8,120 counted in the 1990 Census. The town is located in the easternmost region of the Lehigh Valley.
Things to do in Hackettstown
9. Frank's Pizza
Frank's Pizza is currently located at 7 Naughright Rd, Hackettstown, NJ 07840. Order your favorite pizza, pasta, salad, and more, all with the click of a button. Frank's Pizza accepts orders online for pickup and delivery.
Reviewed By Rbyers32
We ordered two tuna melts. they also come with fries. Our tuna melts, when we got them were tuna subs with carrots in them. The fries were also freezer burnt. Uneatable lunch. Waste of money. Should have went to quick check or wawa
8. Blackstones Bar and Grill
Overall Ratings
3 based on 17 reviews
Reviewed By jimr20162016
We have been to this location several times but usually ordered burgers or sandwiches. This time we ordered ribs and parmigiana chicken. The ribs were juicy but did not taste like they were barbecued or smoked. There was no taste other than the sauce recently poured on top of them. The chicken parmigiana was covered in cheese, so much that it was tough to get down to the chicken under the pool of cheese. The chicken, like the ribs, had no taste. If I had to guess at the preparation based on the taste, I would guess the meats were boiled. They tasted like soup meats.
7. Sonny's II
Reviewed By 836thomasd
Sonny's II has very good pizza and pasta entrees - counter staff is friendly and provides great service.
6. Franks Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 20 reviews
Reviewed By jane1957CalifonNJ
Whenever I am in Hackettstown I make sure I'm hungry enough to stop at Franks Pizza. They have many types of Pizza my favorite is the white broccoli it's the best. Also the Pasta Faggiolia Soup is to die for. It's very tasty. So looking for Pizza or Soup in Hackettstown Franks is the place.
Where to eat Healthy food in Hackettstown: The Best Restaurants and Bars
5. Gabby's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 10 reviews
Reviewed By Cindy586
Went for dinner with another couple. It was seat yourself and couldn't find a clean table, finally wiped one off with a napkin. Server was very nice but not very attentive. Fried calamari was undercooked. Dinners were generous but rather bland. Oil/vinegar cruettes were disgustingly dirty and sticky, asked for salad without onion & olives - came with onions and olives! Silverware was spotted/dirty. Should have clued in to what was in store by the fact that it was Friday night and only one other table was occupied! Won't be going back!
Top 10 American food in Hackettstown, New Jersey, United States
4. Taste of Italy
Overall Ratings
4 based on 12 reviews
Reviewed By DocRKS
This location has gone through some changes of ownership and management over the recent few years with predictable good and bad experiences. However- today marked our 3rd trip enjoying dinners and pizza under the current ownership and each one of our 3 visits has proven to be a Very Good experience with well prepared and nicely presented meals and some excellent pizza offerings!Today my wife elected to try a variety of pizza types as her meal (almost like the Spanish Tapas approach to having a meal!). Each selection was very tasty with the Grilled Chicken over Arugula and the White Pie with brocolli being especially good. I had a delicious and tender Calamari Marinara over linguine in a spicy sauce- offered at a great price of only $8.95!!Good food, nicely kept dining room, pleasant staff and a BYOB!!!! All this makes Taste of Italy a winner on the Hackettstown scene.
Most Popular Contemporary food in Hackettstown, New Jersey, United States
3. Pasta Grill by Enzo
Overall Ratings
4 based on 39 reviews
Authentic Italian cuisine with a modern flare using fresh, quality ingredients!
Reviewed By EV8
Don't be fooled if the parking lot isnt full. Went Fri night for dinner. Huge salads and tasty bread. Fire grilled polo fresco was delicious big portion.Nice to find healthy choices on a menu. The scallops on the pasta special were cooked perfectly. Friendly prompt service.
2. Toscana
Overall Ratings
4 based on 26 reviews
Reviewed By Bali_mannia
While holidaying in USA our friends took us here for dinner. Small quaint resturant but easily accommodated our group of 10. Great relax atmosphere, almost like stepping into small family resturant in Italy. Great friendly service. Amazing menu, food was delicious. Highly recommend going here and the Eggplant Parmi
1. Mama's Cafe Baci
Overall Ratings
4 based on 306 reviews
Specializing in gourmet pizza, pasta, chicken, and seafood selections, also offering full Gluten Free, Vegetarian and Vegan menus, gourmet desserts & coffees. Enjoy wine, beer and cocktails, we're open late with live entertainment and outdoor garden dinin
Reviewed By Culture93233
I just came back from Mama's extremely disappointed. We got two dishes, chose the dish from the specials popular items menu thinking that it will match my expectation. I had good Italian and bad Italian in life but I have never had such a cheap tasting meal as these dishes. Same was with appetizers. I tried to eat but I couldnât. I asked waitress to take it back because I am returning the dish. Chef(or owner), who was hosting a friend in front of our table came over and acted very concerned while i was looking at my receipt as I was signing and calculating tips. He never offered to take the price out when full and nearly untouched plates were returned. It was not my intention but it might have been a right thing to do. My dish was Pescatore described in menu as seafood with basil and tomato sauce. Well, there was no taste of fresh ingredient at all but overwhelming aroma of dried oregano sauce that you could get at Shop Rite. I have never complained at any restaurant and felt very uncomfortable to return dish but in this case me and my partner were siting and watching our plates that we could not even touch and looking at the cook who was hosting his friend in front of us made me to ask why did the menu offered basil for ingredient and we couldnât taste or see it and meal did not looked fresh. He said âthere is basil as wellâ. Whatever that might mean. I am writing this for those who are browsing for good Italian place in town and do not plan to waste time on disappointment.PSI was there about a year ago and food was different. Never will visit again. Italian food deserves better.Hi Maia, First, thank you for your honest review. I do remember your visit to our establishment, and I am sorry that you had a negative experience. I recall walking to your table, and speaking with you for several minutes about our food and preparation, offering to remake the dish more to your liking. We prepare all of our dishes to order, and utilize only fresh ingredients from local providers. If the cuisine was not to your liking, we would always do all we can to make sure our customers are happy. I hope that you will visit us again, as it truly is important for us to have our patrons engage with Mamas in a positive manner. We are a family owned and operated establishment and value our guests after every visit. I realize that you are upset at the moment, but I urge you to please contact me on the phone 908-852-2820 (ask for Tom or Sheri) or email me directly at [email protected] so that we can hopefully rectify your experience. We hope to hear from you soon. Very Best, Tom
