Location: Cicero
Top Restaurants in Cicero
Top Things to do in Cicero
Countries
Best Italian food near Cicero, New York, United States
Find out what Italian restaurants to try in Cicero. Cicero is a town in Northern Onondaga County, New York, United States. The population was 31,632 at the 2010 census. The name of the town was assigned by a clerk interested in the classics, honoring Cicero, a Roman statesman.
Things to do in Cicero
10. Joey's Classic Italian Dining
Overall Ratings
4 based on 569 reviews
We are a family owned restaurant serving quality Italian food since 1982. We are located off of Carrier Circle in Syracuse - New York State Thruway Exit #35
Reviewed By 553rogers
On our way home from a East coast vacation. Stayed at Residence Inn. Joeyâs is only a few minutes ride from RI. We arrived on a Wednesday night about 6:30. Able to get a table right away upstairs. We started with mushroom soup. Homemade and very good. I had a Caesar salad and the dressing did NOT come from a store. Great homemade dressing. Wife had the homemade Ravioli with a Very large meatball. Had to been over 8 ounces! I had the Fishermanâs platter with side fettuccine. A large portions and very tasty. Nice âby the glassâ wine list. Waitress very pleasant. Service was great. Unable to eat dessert because of large portions. Prices very reasonable. ENJOY!!
9. Grimaldi's Luna Park
Overall Ratings
4 based on 403 reviews
Reviewed By RoadWarrior_BOS
This Grimaldi's may have a family connection to the original Syracuse Grimaldi's on Erie Boulevard. But, the last name is where the connection ends. In the past, we've eaten at the original on Erie Boulevard too many times to count, and every time we had a memorable experience. From those experiences, we can not remember a single bad experience. On the other hand, this Grimaldi's in Carrier Circle did not pass muster. We experienced a situation where our reserved table was given to another party while we waited 45 minutes to an hour beyond our reservation. We in turn were a bit later provided a second rate table, and everything continued downhill from there. Our waiter had an attitude and further reinforced a bad experience. Mediocre, poorly prepared Italian food topped the experience off. The positives we took away were that we were able to have a reasonably fun time with our family, despite the negatives we experienced, because the drinks were good. Unfortunately, we were overall disappointed which is rare considering the Grimaldi family's signature contribution to the greater Syracuse restaurant scene. We'll try a different Italian restaurant in the area next time.Dear Road Warrior,We are very sorry to hear you did not enjoy your experience at Grimaldi's. I remember your party last night and the mix up, for which we are very sorry. Your party seemed very understanding of the situation and were enjoying yourselves while you waited. Not too much after you were seated and promptly waited on. We wanted to make sure your order was put in the kitchen to ensure your enjoyment. Please understand that we would have gladly offered something towards your meal had we known your displeasure. Since everyone finished their meals and were checked on repeatedly we assumed you all enjoyed your food and experience. We invite you to come back again with our compliments. Please email me @ [email protected]. Rita GrimaldiOwner
8. Twin Trees III
Overall Ratings
4 based on 107 reviews
Family friendly, casual restaurant. We can accommodate large groups. Reservations accepted. Salad Bar included with entrees.
Reviewed By LinPolinsky
We were a group of eight people. We were seated promptly and waited on shifty. The waitress was very friendly and efficient. The sausage pizza was wonderful. We really enjoyed this meal! Price was right also. We will return!Thank you for the nice review and we are very happy you were pleased with everything!
7. Lakeshore Pizza
Overall Ratings
5 based on 14 reviews
Reviewed By eyerishwoman
Most of their business is takeout or delivery but they do have a small table to eat in. We had a large cheese pizza and a dozen Garlic Parmesan wings delivered Saturday night. We have had their food many times and it has always been great...never a disappointment. The delivery was quick, courteous and efficient. Their antipasto salad is also very good although we did not order it this time. We will only order our pizza from them from now on.
6. Twin Trees Cicero
Overall Ratings
4 based on 36 reviews
We are located at 6259 Route 31 in the 31 Centre Plaza on the corner of Button Road and Route 31. Our dining room seats approximately 50 diners. Our all-you-can-eat salad bar features fresh cut vegetables and salads made daily. As always, our main focus i
Reviewed By Scott A
I always get the wings and pizza. The price is good and the food is always very good. Twin trees has some of the best food. I would go back again.
5. Grotto
Overall Ratings
4 based on 65 reviews
Reviewed By bal1234
They are a tiny bit pricey but well worth it. They have a different menu and so, so good. They are very close to a church so they can't serve hard liquor - but who cares?!? They have a great choice of wine and beer. The service is excellent. They have a tiny bar that gets crowded and looks kind of fun. You can have a nice drink while waiting for your table (if you have to wait). Again, the food is excellent.
Where to eat Seafood food in Cicero: The Best Restaurants and Bars
4. Cicero Country Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 37 reviews
Reviewed By linda h
After a day trip looked for a place to eat in cicero. Found this place on the web, & saw lots of cars there! Always a good sign.Staff was quick&friendly&efficient.All orders are homemadeThe lasagna was excellent & though thick was served hot throughout!Best i have had.Salads fresh&crisp - no bag lettuce here.Pizzas looked wonderful!Going back soon.
3. Vicinos Brick & Brew
Overall Ratings
5 based on 16 reviews
Cozy, fun and friendly atmosphere with a variety of food. Full bar with a great selection of local craft beers to choose from. Pizza made and cooked in front of you while you eat.
Reviewed By bal1234
They have really, really good wood fire pizzas. Their meatballs just won People's Choice award at the 15th annual Meatball Madness, held Sunday, March 31, 2019 at the New York State Fairgrounds. Most of their food we have tried so far is very good. A couple things have been not as good - like their greens and wedge salad. But the food is good so I just won't order those two items again. They have a great choice of beer and they also have 5 beers that they fill from the bottom of the glass - really cool. I'm very glad they opened near me, I have a new favorite to go to.
New York, United States Food Guide: 10 Pub food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Cicero
2. Sapori by Antonio
Overall Ratings
5 based on 51 reviews
Reviewed By MarG599
We were looking for a nice family dinner for two families with two players heading to a basketball tournament in Buffalo NY. We debated eating from the take-out side or the more pleasant, slightly more formal, but very unassuming dining room. We chose the dining room. The decor was nothing special, but one interesting wall was full of clocks!Service was pleasant and timely, with a knowledgeable server (Chef's daughter).I had 'Antonio's Favourite' (chicken), with a side of 'Penne Arrabiatti' My wife had the 'Veal Marsala' All our dishes were of very sizeable portions. My dish came as advertised . . . full of artichokes, sun dried tomatoes, portabello mushsrooms all smothered in a delicate white wine and butter lemon sauce. It was simply delicious and very plentiful. My wife really enjoyed her veal marsala that was full of sauted perfectly to a tender and juicy doneness. Needless to say, we were not looking forward to our next few hours of driving after having ingested such a large flavourfilled and delicious Italian meal.
1. Paladino's Cicero Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 89 reviews
From the business Specialties Our family has been serving your family since 1980. Our dough is made fresh daily and our cheese is the finest in the industry, containing only natural ingredients. We're known for our wonderfully prepared Pizza & Italian foo
Reviewed By donnapertgen
Paladinoâs always has some great varieties ready for âto go heat-and-eatâ. Not JUST your usual cheese and pepperoni. Have always had fresh ingredients, friendly service, clean place to eat, perfectly cooked slices or whole pies!
