Location: Catskill
Top Restaurants in Catskill
Top Things to do in Catskill
Countries
Best Italian food near Catskill, New York, United States
Reviews on Italian food in Catskill, New York, United States. Catskill is a town in the southeast part of Greene County, New York, United States. The population was 11,775 at the 2010 census. The western part of the town is in the Catskill Park. The town contains a village, also called Catskill. The village of Catskill has a well-defined Main Street. There is a public boat launch on the Hudson River called Dutchman's Landing.
Things to do in Catskill
8. Pizza Hut
Overall Ratings
2 based on 15 reviews
Reviewed By OlgaC2009
We went there for grandma 70th birthday party. Got seated almost right away, but when I looked at the floor - carpet was dirty, crumbs were al over the place. It looked like it has been awhile before someone vacuumed the floor. The room was dark and all fans were going. It was kind of cold in there. I went over the look at the salad bar - the unused slots for salad ingridients were dirty and looked like there was rust and dirt right on the bottom of that.We ordered pizza, breadsticks and wings and took them awhile to bring our order.My advise - do not order wings, they tasted like they have been dipped in some chewy dough and reheated a couple times. Blue cheese in the containers was awful. The only good thing from my whole meal was water, lemon wedge in my water was all wrinkly and old.Terrible overall experience. Please save your money and go somewhere else if you desire to have a slice of pizza
7. Bistro 27
Reviewed By judi2
There are multiple specials for lunch every day. The prices are reasonable and you get a lot of food for the money. There is happy hour from 4 to 6. They are closed for dinner now from M-W. They have Italian Night on Thursday for $16.95 and all the house wine you can drink. The Italian food is the best around Catskill. I also love the Ahi Tuna dinner. The presentation was beautiful. One of my favorite appetizers is the clams fra diavalo! It's enough for a meal. I think they have a fish special on Fridays and Prime Rib on Saturday. You should give it a try!!
6. Tatiana's Steakhouse
Overall Ratings
3 based on 57 reviews
Reviewed By Jagular48761
Tatiana's has always been one of our favorite stops while visitng the Catskill region. This was our first experience knowing the restaurant has changed hands under the new ownership. The quality of our meals was excellent - the salad portion was generous and you could cut the chicken with your fork - cooked to perfection. ***Bravo to the kitchen***Caroline our waitress was friendly and attentive with prompt refills on our soda and cocktails. She certainly made us feel welcome which was the signature of the Gjerji family under their prior ownership.My only positive criticism is we dined outdoors. The decking and siding/awnings are in need of some serious TLC and cleaning along with some refreshing of the garden areas. With their grand opening next weekend and new menu, this needs to be made a priority.We are looking forward to returning.
5. Tori G's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 31 reviews
Reviewed By BlakeG987
I've been to Tori G's in the past and have never had a bad meal or experience. My visit last weekend definitely deserves a review. We were heading out on the boat and wanted to grab a couple subs to go. It was about 11:30am so we didn't know if they would be open. My wife grabbed the door knob and place was locked. Sign indicated not open until noon. She was getting back in the car when the owner opened the door and said they just put the slice pies in the oven but was there something else we might want. He invited us in and the guy at counter took our order for two subs. The owner and staff all chatted with us as they set up for the day. Five minutes later we walked out with two delicious subs and an even greater customer service experience. I certainly don't encourage anyone to go there before they are scheduled to open, I just want you to know that this was a "feel good" experience and gave the small town flavor to the place. As a business owner, I respect their dedication. Thanks Tori G's!
What to do and see in Catskill, United States: The Best Places and Tips
4. Pomodoro's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 95 reviews
Whether you are looking for a full service dine-in experience or just a drink during happy hour, we've got you covered!! We are open 7 days a week from 11 am -10 pm for dine-in, take-out and delivery.
Reviewed By alwaysplanning50
A party of three ordered lasagna, regular and stuffed pizza slices, soup and buffalo chicken wings.Lasagna portion was huge - ample for two and very goo. Pizza was very good and served hot but sauce (on the side) for the stuffed pizza was a dollar more. Really???Chicken wings were properly fried, crunchy with a nicely seasoned sauce.Waitress refilled drinks without prompting, but the food cane out of the kitchen in dribs and drabs and made for an awkward dining experience.
Catskill Food Guide: 10 Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Catskill
3. La-Conca-D'oro
Overall Ratings
4 based on 89 reviews
Reviewed By Brandtl
The owners are awesome! I always get the chicken piccata lunch special, side salad with crumbled blue cheese dressing and comes with warm bread & a nice garlic butter. Sometimes the food can be a little inconsistent, but always good and always a pleasant atmosphere. I recommend stopping in even if just for a drink or two.
New York, United States Food Guide: 6 Bar food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Catskill
2. Village Pizza II
Overall Ratings
4 based on 25 reviews
Reviewed By Lauren620
I donât eat pizza, so Iâm not reviewing that. The spaghetti dinner was good, with pasta cooked just right and tasty tomato sauce. But the accompanying garlic bread was really bad: no crust, no yeasty taste, no glutenous stretch; no amount of garlic could compensate.There are a lot of Italian restaurants in Catskill, so being in third place is still pretty good. Iâd place Tori Gâs and Angeloâs ahead of Village Pizza II, but not by a lot.
1. Rip Van Winkle Brewing Company
Overall Ratings
4 based on 104 reviews
Reviewed By Emily R
We were looking for a place to eat after hiking Kaaterskill and this place was perfect. Really good food, big portions, and inexpensive prices. Staff was very friendly as well!
Where to eat American food in Catskill: The Best Restaurants and Bars
